Willo or Taylor

Basically I want to know which one you prefer. Personally I think Taylor is ****e, and I just cant see how so many people like him. I'm not going to say Willo is class because he is far from it, but I think he deserves to be ahead of Taylor.

 

Taylor

 

Williamson if I have to choose , but think we need a better CB to partner Coloccini.

 

Williamsons better in the air, but Taylor's better all round

 

Willo easily for me.

 

Willo every day of the week, including Sundays!

 

I think people are just committing a knee jerk reaction to the Villa game if you ask me, because i did a poll on this a few days before the game and it was 60/40 in Saylors favour.

I personally think neither should be good enough to get in our starting 11 next year, we need someone better.

 

I've always preferred Willo, not just based on the last game against Vile. He has a good understanding with Colo, better header of the ball and has made some fabulous long passes (the one for Shola to head onto Nolan to score the first against Wolves springs to mind).

 

Chris Samba.

 

This is certainly not a knee jerk reaction from me, I have been saying for weeks, months even, that Saylor is not as good as some people made out and I hope Willo keeps him out of the team until we bring in someone better.

 

I have to disagree with his "understanding" with colo. As a pair, their miscommunication with each other has cost us atleast 6-8 points this year. Also Williamson cannot pass for ****. He knocks it out of play and thinks "i'll show them how safe i am, no nonesense from me", when there is a simple pass available to him. I don't like over playing at the back but he takes the no nonesense stuff too far. Him kicking the ball out lead to Stoke demolishing our box the second half at st james' because for some reason he didn't understand that that's exactly what big teams like Stoke want you to do, and they depend on that.

 

Didn't he wave to you?

 

On current form; Williamson. Should he get back to his best; Taylor.

 

That's 1 game mate, every time i've seen Saylor play he's been terrible, always taking the ball out of the path of the keeper and putting it in the net.

They do have an understanding, we look alot stronger if we have them to playing, Colo gets to push forward a bit whilst he covers, how they work Willo can pass though, Wolves was a perfect example.

But hey, that's just my opinion.

 

Thought I remembered something about that, though I do think Taylor is better just.

 

Agree with you on this though.

 

No it wasn't just one game, it's nearly every game

 

*in your opinion.

I think Willo and Colo have a good understanding.

 

Not really, solid against Blackburn at there ground, solid against Wolves, solid against West Ham, I reckon he's 50/50 each game.

 

Thank you!

You have to accept other people have different opinions sometimes.