Why I DONT rate Koscielney.

Vermaelen is FAR better. Form is temporary, Class is permanent.

But none of our defenders deserve praise for this season.

Kamran is just a lunatic.

 

Yeah, neither do I.

 

Sign Perchinio or Williamson.

 

Vermaelen has been making mistakes since he joined us, this has nothing to do with form.

 

He sccored a cruciaal goal it seems against the toon though.

 

Yep, very crucial goal.

 

I wish just one day a toon player would score a goal when it really matters.

 

.

 

seriously it's got to happen one day and if it's at Everton next week I'll cut off my own cock and **** myself in the arse with it., you know why I'm saying that? because it won't happen.

 

.

 

Bit of a defeatist attitude there. You're in good form, you went to the Bridge and won, going to Goodison shouldn't be too hard.

 

.

 

Weve done well regardless, however if your a Newcastle fan you just know these things. All the best to Arsenal it's been nice being up there with you.

 

I agree with bear on koscielney. Mertesacker and Vermalen for me. Mertesacker has the positioning. He isnt great obviously but he is a leader and great for the club

Also his name is very annoying to spell which doesnt help (koscielney)

 

Vermaelen is not a good defender. Koscielny is.

Vermaelen is not a good defender. Mertesacker is.

You guys watching the MOTD highlights? Embarrassing defending from Vermaelen. Two of the goals were his fault.

 

Yeh I dont rate vermelen that much either but with mert he can do ok. Mert will keep him from running off and make sure we keep a good defensive shape.

I also felt like Mert would make sure somebody sits in front of the back line whereas Kos and Verm dont have the balls to do it.

We need the mert to start when he is back

 

I think Vertonghen would be a good signing. He knows TV well, he's a good defender in his own right, and a solid DM, something we lack (no offence to Coq and Frimpong, they aren't ready yet)

 

Well it's Vermaelen who should be dropped.

Koscielny is our best defender and Mertesacker is second.

Kos + Mert is a pretty solid partnership.

 

Vertonghen would be a great signing.


He cover at CB, LB and DM.

 

To be honest I dont mind. I just want the mert to start when he is back. He wont though. Which makes me sad. I love how the mert is such a team player. Always encouraging the team and organising. I bet he was in song's ear if he left the defence exposed. You need that in a team So kos or verm...you might be right but I dont think it matters much.