Who's next then?

  • Please bear with us on the new site integration and fixing any known bugs over the coming days. If you can not log in please try resetting your password and check your spam box. If you have tried these steps and are still struggling email [email protected] with your username/registered email address
  • Log in now to remove adverts - no adverts at all to registered members!
Bigal2 said:
I don't know what it would take for me to give up my Season Ticket-I cant envisage it ever getting worse than the McCarthy years!
Click to expand...

Getting relegated to the third tier didn’t put me off - it’s about character and values, not results or who the opponents are going to be. The Farage thing was very troubling for me - failure to condemn rioting in Belfast, libraries being cleared of LGBT material, community projects being defunded, the threat to deport millions of people. I took the apology at face value but if Ashton continued to show a lack of judgement - with my 700 mile round trip to Portman Road - it’s not a given that I’m going to continue to put in the miles and hours unless I can get behind the club.
 
The deal looks done. Judging from the reaction on TWTD I’m not the only one utterly baffled by the appointment. Even more baffling it looks as though Ole was shortlisted and Ashton actually chose O’Neil instead.

The only rationale I can come up with is that Ashton is hurting that McKenna left and decided to give everyone the middle finger in a kamikaze gesture.

Or perhaps it’s the genius level ‘no one can follow McKenna so we’ll put O’Neil in for a few weeks to give the next manager an easy act to follow’ play.
 
Last edited:
The only thing that’s baffling is that some people think they are in a better position to make the decision than the guy that has been doing the interviews and knows all the details.
 
As I said before, O’Neil feels like an underwhelming appointment. The main context though is that there was a distinct lack of high level available choices. The World Cup made it more difficult for us to bring in an England coach - such as Anthony Barry - or someone like Graham Potter. Managers like Thomas Frank were unavailable. Given we’re a favourite for relegation, maybe the job was not as attractive as some of our supporters on social media believed.

The main positives for O’Neil is that he did keep both Bournemouth and Wolves up in his first seasons with them. That experience is more useful to us than OGS, who failed keeping Cardiff in the Premier League and has worked for a top domestic club everywhere else. O’Neil is also bringing a couple of highly rated coaches with him - such as Neil Critchley - who will hopefully improve us.

My main concern with O’Neil is that he looked completely out of depth in his second season at Wolves. Despite having top players like Cunha, Pedro Neto, Joao Gomes, and Ait-Nouri, they looked relegation certainties before Pereira turned them around with the same squad. Another concern is that both Pereira and Iraola at Bournemouth improved on what O’Neil did, certainly the latter.

McKenna was always going to be massive shoes to fill. Given the available options, it feels like whoever we picked was going to look like a downgrade. I’ll support O’Neil and hope he can keep the pattern going of keeping teams up in his first season. But I really believed we would’ve attracted a higher calibre of manager.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: TopBunk, Southcoastoldgaffer and Bigal2
Nuggets said:
As I said before, O’Neil feels like an underwhelming appointment. The main context though is that there was a distinct lack of high level available choices. The World Cup made it more difficult for us to bring in an England coach - such as Anthony Barry - or someone like Graham Potter. Managers like Thomas Frank were unavailable. Given we’re a favourite for relegation, maybe the job was not as attractive as some of our supporters on social media believed.

The main positives for O’Neil is that he did keep both Bournemouth and Wolves up in his first seasons with them. That experience is more useful to us than OGS, who failed keeping Cardiff in the Premier League and has worked for a top domestic club everywhere else. O’Neil is also bringing a couple of highly rated coaches with him - such as Neil Critchley - who will hopefully improve us.

My main concern with O’Neil is that he looked completely out of depth in his second season at Wolves. Despite having top players like Cunha, Pedro Neto, Joao Gomes, and Ait-Nouri, they looked relegation certainties before Pereira turned them around with the same squad. Another concern is that both Pereira and Iraola at Bournemouth improved on what O’Neil did, certainly the latter.

McKenna was always going to be massive shoes to fill. Given the available options, it feels like whoever we picked was going to look like a downgrade. I’ll support O’Neil and hope he can keep the pattern going of keeping teams up in his first season. But I really believed we would’ve attracted a higher calibre of manager.
Click to expand...
A sensible and balanced view as ever,Nuggets.IF/when he is appointed I feel there's a vocal minority who will be against him from the start.
 
  • Like
Reactions: TopBunk and Nuggets
Bigal2 said:
A sensible and balanced view as ever,Nuggets.IF/when he is appointed I feel there's a vocal minority who will be against him from the start.
Click to expand...
Reading some of the posts on TWTD and taking a glance at social media, the pitchforks are out already. A couple of my mates and my brother also think it’s a terrible appointment.

I don’t think it’s terrible, but it’s not an exciting one. I understand - and share - the feeling of being underwhelmed, as I felt when he was first linked. He feels like a downgrade on McKenna, despite having a better Premier League record. He will be more flexible with formations, rather than being wedded to the 4-2-3-1 McKenna stuck by. Maybe that will help? But the style of football is likely to be more pragmatic and less enjoyable. If it keeps us up, then I think we’d all take it.

Ultimately though, hiring Gary O’Neil isn’t going to relegate us. What will relegate us is botching our recruitment. This time, we need to be more ambitious than hiring top end Championship talent. We don’t want or need to recruit with an eye on bouncing back. We have a better chance of survival this season and have improved the facilities in line with a Premier League standard. We have to look for value abroad, look for height and physicality, and learn from our lessons last time while identifying what Sunderland and Leeds both did last year.

If he fails and we’re relegated next season, then serious questions have to asked of Mark Ashton. My general perception is he’s a very effective Championship level CEO, but not Premier League class. Big summer for him to prove otherwise.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Southcoastoldgaffer
I do think it would be terrible and I think the barometer is the connection with the fans. That’s not an afterthought. Some people pointing to his ill judged comments after our encounter with them and his bully boy style and rightfully pointing out both his questionable character and his actual awful performance as a manager. The fans’ perspective matters and has a huge bearing on the chances of success. One of the major factors in getting out of scraping out of League One was the energy around the place and in the stands, the patience and backing for McKenna because we could see that he was building something and he’s a likeable person with exceptional character. I don’t think we expect the next Bobby Robson to walk in the door now but to appoint someone that a decent proportion of fans actually have contempt for may prove to be career suicide for Ashton.

The good news is that the appointment isn’t confirmed yet. Let’s hope Ashton is watching the reaction.
 
Nuggets said:
Reading some of the posts on TWTD and taking a glance at social media, the pitchforks are out already. A couple of my mates and my brother also think it’s a terrible appointment.

I don’t think it’s terrible, but it’s not an exciting one. I understand - and share - the feeling of being underwhelmed, as I felt when he was first linked. He feels like a downgrade on McKenna, despite having a better Premier League record. He will be more flexible with formations, rather than being wedded to the 4-2-3-1 McKenna stuck by. Maybe that will help? But the style of football is likely to be more pragmatic and less enjoyable. If it keeps us up, then I think we’d all take it.

Ultimately though, hiring Gary O’Neil isn’t going to relegate us. What will relegate us is botching our recruitment. This time, we need to be more ambitious than hiring top end Championship talent. We don’t want or need to recruit with an eye on bouncing back. We have a better chance of survival this season and have improved the facilities in line with a Premier League standard. We have to look for value abroad, look for height and physicality, and learn from our lessons last time while identifying what Sunderland and Leeds both did last year.

If he fails and we’re relegated next season, then serious questions have to asked of Mark Ashton. My general perception is he’s a very effective Championship level CEO, but not Premier League class. Big summer for him to prove otherwise.
Click to expand...

We can’t tell what the owners think. We are way ahead of their expectations. Have they reset their expectations, will demand more and he’s on thin ice? Do they even see the nuances down on the ground? Or are they looking at the commercial and revenue success and thinking the sun shines out of his behind?
 
YorkieLancsHampyLondoner said:
I do think it would be terrible and I think the barometer is the connection with the fans. That’s not an afterthought. Some people pointing to his ill judged comments after our encounter with them and his bully boy style and rightfully pointing out both his questionable character and his actual awful performance as a manager. The fans’ perspective matters and has a huge bearing on the chances of success. One of the major factors in getting out of scraping out of League One was the energy around the place and in the stands, the patience and backing for McKenna because we could see that he was building something and he’s a likeable person with exceptional character. I don’t think we expect the next Bobby Robson to walk in the door now but to appoint someone that a decent proportion of fans actually have contempt for may prove to be career suicide for Ashton.

The good news is that the appointment isn’t confirmed yet. Let’s hope Ashton is watching the reaction.
Click to expand...
Are these the same supporters who were booing and arguing with Morsy after the Bristol rovers game? We're a very fickle bunch, football supporters. We'll all be wanting to kiss him if he gets the team buzzing on the pitch and keep us up
 
  • Like
Reactions: TopBunk
Comes down to the fact some ‘fans’ love to moan and by doing so they can feel a superiority if it doesn’t work out
(Which is often the case in football if you wait long enough most managers will fail).

I will back him and the club fully as I’ve always done and not be over critical of every little decision safe in the knowledge that all at the club are aiming for success in a business where success is soon forgotten.

‘We’ve got Super Gary O’Neil ……………and so on.
 
Last edited:
Bigal2 said:
I don't know what it would take for me to give up my Season Ticket-I can't envisage it ever getting worse than the McCarthy years!
Click to expand...
Damn fecking right, nothing can ever be that bad!! Altho I recall there were a few on here, that I had several run ins with, that liked MM,
 
I just wonder if all the noise around O'Neil is a smokescreen,I'm probably wrong but just a thought.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top Bottom
Back