Where did it all go wrong?

  • Please bear with us on the new site integration and fixing any known bugs over the coming days. If you can not log in please try resetting your password and check your spam box. If you have tried these steps and are still struggling email [email protected] with your username/registered email address
  • Log in now to remove adverts - no adverts at all to registered members!
If people think we are playing more Football under Powell they were not at the Dagenham game or the Hartlepool game etc. There is too much simplistic talk about long ball or short ball. As John Cartwright a former youth team coach used to say it is not long ball or short ball it is the RIGHT ball.Do you not think that Man U use the long ball. What i am against is the hoof ball to no one in particular. I am also against the tippy tappy football with no end product.
 
Spot on, Martinho, and you can add on the disappointing performances of Rommedahl and Jeffers. Richard Murray was like a rabbit caught in the headlights when Curbs left.
Totally agree with the Parker comments, that deal alone was the beginning of the end

Murphy throwing a strop and then Smertin being sold to the Russians without being able to replace him which broke up Curbs midfield think that was the final straw for him, I don't think he had the enthusiasm to do it all over yet again though I do think if Murray had kept Curbs on for that final season we would have still struggled it was a tough Premier League that year possibly the toughest ever but we would have stayed up and would have still been there today I have no doubt.

The problem with Murray was Curbs was running the club top to bottom all Murray and the board did was turn up and organise community events and I think Murray wanted to 'enjoy' the Premiership more ie have more of a say in running things hence allowing Curbs to leave early.

I also think the board didn't aim high enough for a new manager, some might say we are a small club or we're at our level but we were a mid-table Premier League London club which was usually pushing for Europe until our usual end of season slumps (heavy home defeats to the likes of Leeds, Birmingham, West Brom etc)

I always felt a manager like Ranieri could have been brought in or Hodgson even the likes of Laudrup. Dowie at the time was the equivalent of Avram Grant or Paul Hart - knowing your onto a loser from Day 1 and what didn't help were the poor signings Dowie made too.

It all stems from poor decision making at the top, just about every single decision made post-Curbs was a bad one with the consequences increasing each time to where we find ourselves now - a squad deprived of any quality contracted players apart from BWP and Jackson yet still contains McCormack.
 
For how long are you going to blame Parky? Next season there are not going to be many Parky players left are you still going to blame him? 2 wins in 20 games under Sir Chris. I bet the teams in Div 1 are cacking themselves as our tactical genius,with a bit of money to spend,wins the first 10 games on the trot. Nurse i need some more medication,i just drifted into a parallel world!!!!!!!
 
Dickyplumb, I will never be truly happy till all evidence of Parky is well and truly removed from my beloved club.
The words failure and mediocrity are his middle names, and personally I think I (we) deserve better than that.
I am still taking the tablets, but it seems incurable.
So rather than lick my balls or kick the cat, Parky is my one outlet when it comes to venting ones spleen.<ok>
All in jest - I love him really <doh>
 
I think we should all move on from Parky now as he hasn't been the Manager for a while.With a number of additions that Powell will make and the style of play that he will impose it will be HIS TEAM.Let us judge him on results,his words at the meeting in Bromley not mine. Let us forget he once played for us and judge him by the yardstick that all Managers are judged RESULTS. It has not been an auspicious start.
 
In my opinion the blame is spread evenly between Richard Murray and Ian Dowie...

Murray... All he had to do was select the right replacement for Curbs, imo Dowie was never going to be the right man for the job in a million years and so it proved.

Dowie... Hopelessly out of his depth from day one and signed the most amount of s**t I've ever know of any Charlton manager.



Had Murray replaced Curbs with the right man and had that man used the generous transfer budget wisely, there's absolutely no doubt in my mind that we would still be a Premiership club.

Oh well... no point crying over spilt milk. It's the here and now that's important... but that's my take on it for what it's worth.

Franco - Spot on Mate - succinct and very much to the point 10/10