Been thinking about posting this for a while. I dont want to be divisive in any way so have erred on the side of caution. But I thought maybe we can discuss and share. Probably an entirely selfish post too.
I have to be honest I am not hugely enjoying the summer tfr window. I am not totally in tune with the idea of spending huge sums on a team, having just watched one do such a miraculous thing for my club. I am not naieve, I know the gap between leagues. But I am an old fart in many ways and my footballing values, and my love of the game, does not come from buying players. My enjoyment comes from seeing a team progress together and learn together.
My connection to Sunderland is my hometown club obviously. A bit more than that is the players who have represented us with a passion and desire that matches what they get from the stands. Ours is a club that genuinely thrives on its fan base being that 12th man. Circumstance means I cant go often these days, and it will have to be less this season sadly, but when I am lucky enough to get an away game in we are a remarkable bunch. I have had such a wonderful time following these lads. It is the players I remember and associate with those times. John McPhail, Marco and that team under Smith. Lads like McPhail got right under my skin. Before that people like Elliott and Cummins were heroes. I moved through years and players like Armstrong attracted my idolisation. Bracewell, Pascoe, Tony Norman. Benno, Bally, Martin Smith. I loved them all. Reidy gave me some great memories with Quinn and Superkev. Tommy S and Micky Gray. I can associate memories good and bad to players and I felt a connection.
The team we had last year was the first in a while I felt we had a real connection with as fans. I could relate to them. I loved them for what they gave us. Our pride back? An identity I could fully buy into. Not since Reidys days have we had a side so committed to us as fans imo. I feel sad because it was only weeks ago we had these lads. Now I am left with a sense they wont get much chance to continue their journey with us. I will always relate last season with the likes of Jobe, Rigg, Neil, ONien. They will live always in my footballing memory.
I hope the new lads do the same, but I will be honest and have my doubts. That is because I have some poor memories of big name players not getting Sunderland, or maybe it was just rank bad management on our part. How many of them will be here long term I wonder? Are we a stepping stone? Will all of them feel how Jobe felt about Sunderland when he was here. We were his stepping stone but he gave us everything he had on and off the pitch. My great memories are of those that came to us, or were grown by us, and who just went all in on the club. I really hope all of these new lads do, honestly I do. There is an awful lot of them seemingly coming in.
Lastly, and at risk of sounding insular, I think we really do need some Brits to come in. Our footballing culture is different. Not saying any better or worse, but we are different. Even Wenger recognised the absolute essential value from English lads across the pitch.
I get it right. The game has moved on, and I havent. That is absolutely fair. I just wanted to share my own perspective and struggles with what is happening. Footy is a bit more to me than £20m players and a desperate bid for a place at the top table. Footy moves me like no other sport can, and footballers do that. But if I am honest I love them like I do my wife (almost) and I value the long term relationship.
So if I am less than excited on the tfr thread about another winger from Seria B, you know why
Sorry for the rambling nonsense.
Haway the (New) Lads. Ignore footballing dinosaurs like me.
I have to be honest I am not hugely enjoying the summer tfr window. I am not totally in tune with the idea of spending huge sums on a team, having just watched one do such a miraculous thing for my club. I am not naieve, I know the gap between leagues. But I am an old fart in many ways and my footballing values, and my love of the game, does not come from buying players. My enjoyment comes from seeing a team progress together and learn together.
My connection to Sunderland is my hometown club obviously. A bit more than that is the players who have represented us with a passion and desire that matches what they get from the stands. Ours is a club that genuinely thrives on its fan base being that 12th man. Circumstance means I cant go often these days, and it will have to be less this season sadly, but when I am lucky enough to get an away game in we are a remarkable bunch. I have had such a wonderful time following these lads. It is the players I remember and associate with those times. John McPhail, Marco and that team under Smith. Lads like McPhail got right under my skin. Before that people like Elliott and Cummins were heroes. I moved through years and players like Armstrong attracted my idolisation. Bracewell, Pascoe, Tony Norman. Benno, Bally, Martin Smith. I loved them all. Reidy gave me some great memories with Quinn and Superkev. Tommy S and Micky Gray. I can associate memories good and bad to players and I felt a connection.
The team we had last year was the first in a while I felt we had a real connection with as fans. I could relate to them. I loved them for what they gave us. Our pride back? An identity I could fully buy into. Not since Reidys days have we had a side so committed to us as fans imo. I feel sad because it was only weeks ago we had these lads. Now I am left with a sense they wont get much chance to continue their journey with us. I will always relate last season with the likes of Jobe, Rigg, Neil, ONien. They will live always in my footballing memory.
I hope the new lads do the same, but I will be honest and have my doubts. That is because I have some poor memories of big name players not getting Sunderland, or maybe it was just rank bad management on our part. How many of them will be here long term I wonder? Are we a stepping stone? Will all of them feel how Jobe felt about Sunderland when he was here. We were his stepping stone but he gave us everything he had on and off the pitch. My great memories are of those that came to us, or were grown by us, and who just went all in on the club. I really hope all of these new lads do, honestly I do. There is an awful lot of them seemingly coming in.
Lastly, and at risk of sounding insular, I think we really do need some Brits to come in. Our footballing culture is different. Not saying any better or worse, but we are different. Even Wenger recognised the absolute essential value from English lads across the pitch.
I get it right. The game has moved on, and I havent. That is absolutely fair. I just wanted to share my own perspective and struggles with what is happening. Footy is a bit more to me than £20m players and a desperate bid for a place at the top table. Footy moves me like no other sport can, and footballers do that. But if I am honest I love them like I do my wife (almost) and I value the long term relationship.
So if I am less than excited on the tfr thread about another winger from Seria B, you know why

Sorry for the rambling nonsense.
Haway the (New) Lads. Ignore footballing dinosaurs like me.