Ian bolton certainly . Tony Coton ? What about Tony Currie ?Genius. Cliff Holton ? I suppose it depends on the criteria
Each position was chosen by a player who was on the Hive so naturally a lot of selections are for team-mate they played with or maybe aware of.
I agree with you on Bolton. Tony Coton was a phenomenal keeper - but we’ve always had some truly top keepers. I think Benny Boy just pips Tony, but I would appreciate it if someone else can break the news to Big TC - I would, but I have a note from my Mum.
David James debut season was sensational. He lost his way a little with the law changes but that was long after he left us. Best all time? TC for me. Not even worthy of debate so far as I'm concerned.
I never saw Mike Walker play (other than video), Pat Jennings I remember as unbelievable, one of the all time greats of any club. David James was most often a colossus, then occasionally forehead-smackingly weak. Andy Rankin was sublime in my memories of him. Do you remember Taffy Davies, whom I spoke of earlier (obvs not as a keeper!)
TC for me too. A story. I played hockey in South Cheshire. Whilst relaxing after a hard game against Fodens ( the hockey club lasted longer then the firm) in their clubhouse, I noticed a Watford pennant. Why ? It turned out that GT had asked the great referee Don Shaw if he knew of a club/location near the NW where WFC could use on the morning of a match in the area - Manchester/Liverpool etc. Shaw, who lived in Sandbach - home of Fodens & ERF - recommended the sports club. And, said the man behind the bar, they are coming up this w/e - Everton at Goodison. Well. I went along on the Sat morning, with 2 sons, and a close WFC friend from Uni days - Mike Rance ,(now a Macc FC legend and MBE for services etc ) with his two sons. Hang on, I'll get to the point. Wandered into the club ground - nothing like security in the 80's. There they were - MY TEAM - doing drills practices etc in front of GT, coaching staff, er one of him. We stood and watched. Amazingly, the best footballer in view, with dribbles, passes, flicks , tricks nutmegs, lobs, and amazing athleticism was one TC ! Never spent a minute in goal. Wonderful morning. I still have the photo of GT with the 4 lads that he let us take. Treasured !! If you want more, I'll tell you about my first - and only - international football appearance. I'm still wating for it to be recognised by UEFA.