Schar has Trippier to his right and Botman to his left. Botman has Schar to his right and Burn to his left. That's the only information I need to know.
He’s massively overrated by our fans. He did indeed have a good season in the same way Ryan Taylor had a good season at left back when we finished 5th under Pardew
I don't get in to that kind of nonsense fans tend to pick the players they like . It doesn't matter he was part of a Newcastle side with a great defensive record though ... same with big Dan Burn. I think fab schar is a good player that's all I'm saying. Dpp said he couldn't play in a back 4 for years now he's only winning tackles and finding passes because he's standing next to someone.
lol he’s had one good season compared to all the ****e before! I already said he’s had a good season but he has serious limitations. He meanders too much out of position and loses flight of the ball regularly. That said he has definitely improved in heading the ball As I’ve said before he is the new Philipe Albert where all he gets is praise yet defensively was not very good
He was good with rafa too and much like Joelinton who you said was **** has proven you wrong. Shelvey I was with you on but this one you're on your own Mr Peterson.
Let me guess…… he was playing up front? Yes he was ****. Now find me a post of mine that said he was **** as a cm
I did and like I said he had a good season but that doesn’t mean he’s suddenly great in a back 4. In the same way Ryan Taylor was a **** left back despite us finishing 5th. Let’s talk about Longstaff now…..
Thank you for admitting that. Joelinton has played essentially the same period of time as Joelinton has in cm under howe. Longstaff has proven me wrong for sure but I'm not going to hide behind who he's playing next to.
Bit harsh. Wouldn’t put even Lascelles or Clarke as comparative to Bramble never mind Schar. Titus was a one man wrecking ball. Just unfortunately it was always against his own team Woodgate still, for me, ranks as the best defender I’ve seen in a Newcastle shirt. Botman has the potential to take that crown but hasn’t taken it just yet.
Wondered when you would drag up that old chestnut, Ponytail. Just get over it. PA was just the better player no two ways about it.
