Tonali vs Guimareas vs Anderson

  • Please bear with us on the new site integration and fixing any known bugs over the coming days. If you can not log in please try resetting your password and check your spam box. If you have tried these steps and are still struggling email [email protected] with your username/registered email address
  • Log in now to remove adverts - no adverts at all to registered members!
Status
Not open for further replies.
Gangsta Ginola said:
Howe has faults 100%. But he’s done brilliant for us so far.

Is he elite though?

He's taken us far but I’m not sure he can take us to the very top but we shall see either way.
Click to expand...
Yes he is elite. I personally don't think Pep would have got the squad EH inherited to the point we're at now
 
  • Like
Reactions: Maximin Effort, Rum & Black for 2, magpie290761 and 1 other person
Gangsta Ginola said:
Howe has faults 100%. But he’s done brilliant for us so far.

Is he elite though?

He's taken us far but I’m not sure he can take us to the very top but we shall see either way.
Click to expand...

Newcastle can't get a big name or elite manager, although I don't think any of today's so called greats are anything they're cracked up to be. Pep for example went straight in a Barca then Bayern and off to City after they were established. I think it's more a case of what the club does.

Howes as good as any of them tbh..we're only going to be looking at the likes of Potter and Southgate or maybe some other muppet.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Gangsta Ginola and Rum & Black for 2
No27 said:
Newcastle can't get a big name or elite manager, although I don't think any of today's so called greats are anything they're cracked up to be. Pep for example went straight in a Barca then Bayern and off to City after they were established. I think it's more a case of what the club does.

Howes as good as any of them tbh..we're only going to be looking at the likes of Potter and Southgate or maybe some other muppet.
Click to expand...

Yeah we’re not about to wheel out Luis Enrique. I think we need the club dynamic to work far, far better - data-led scouting, flexibility from Howe on transfers, tactics and loyalty, better financial management, etc.

That said, we’re way below where we should be right now.
 
No27 said:
Newcastle can't get a big name or elite manager, although I don't think any of today's so called greats are anything they're cracked up to be. Pep for example went straight in a Barca then Bayern and off to City after they were established. I think it's more a case of what the club does.

Howes as good as any of them tbh..we're only going to be looking at the likes of Potter and Southgate or maybe some other muppet.
Click to expand...
So simple fact is Howe is the best choice right now. But he has to adapt and learn from his very obvious mistakes.

I think he will. I hope he will.

Burn at LB has to stop.
Gordon up top…. Never again.
 
GodAlmighty said:
I honestly don't understand what your issue is with the transfer policy. It baffles me.
Click to expand...

Barnes, Elanga, Wissa, Ramsey, etc - millions spent on loading the squad with replicas of the first eleven, limiting our ability to change and focused heavily on PL experience that isn’t yielding results.
 
  • Like
Reactions: No27
Roland Deschain said:
Barnes, Elanga, Wissa, Ramsey, etc - millions spent on loading the squad with replicas of the first eleven, limiting our ability to change and focused heavily on PL experience that isn’t yielding results.
Click to expand...

Barnes is totally different to Gordon in that he lacks pace and his finishing is far better, Elanga has electrifying pace which Murphy doesn't have, Wissa is completely different to Woltemade, Ramsey probably better than Joelinton technically but too soon to say.

I certainly wouldn't have said we've stacked up with replicas. Are you sure its not jsut because you'd rather have had different names?
 
  • Like
Reactions: GeordieHalfbreed, magpie290761, Diego and 1 other person
GodAlmighty said:
Barnes is totally different to Gordon in that he lacks pace and his finishing is far better, Elanga has electrifying pace which Murphy doesn't have, Wissa is completely different to Woltemade, Ramsey probably better than Joelinton technically but too soon to say.

I certainly wouldn't have said we've stacked up with replicas. Are you sure its not jsut because you'd rather have had different names?
Click to expand...

Wissa different to Nick is the only thing I’d agree with. Nicks played football for Newcastle being the main diff.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom
Back