Off Topic The Politics Thread

  • Please bear with us on the new site integration and fixing any known bugs over the coming days. If you can not log in please try resetting your password and check your spam box. If you have tried these steps and are still struggling email [email protected] with your username/registered email address
  • Log in now to remove adverts - no adverts at all to registered members!

Should the UK remain a part of the EU or leave?

  • Stay in

    Votes: 56 47.9%
  • Get out

    Votes: 61 52.1%

  • Total voters
    117
  • Poll closed .
Read what I said... actually I'll repost it for you

"There seems to be a lot of fear about a 'Euro Army' despite the fact that it would take a huge swing of opinion across the member states to actually achieve that - something that is deeply unlikely to occur."
I did read it and there will be a Euro-army because Germany and France want one and they pull all the strings. Besides can you imagine some of the eastern block countries saying "no'?
 
I did read it and there will be a Euro-army because Germany and France want one and they pull all the strings. Besides can you imagine some of the eastern block countries saying "no'?

Well I can't imagine it getting past a veto, no.

I have read the same, but it all boils down to agreement on all sides or a compromise that neither the UK or Ireland for a start would be prepared to make.
 
Plenty of people homeless going to food banks and in poverty, mass unemployment for the young...
And I am not talking about the UK, I'm talking about the EU.
Look at the ground the far right has made in EU countries and how millions around Europe agree with Brexit and want it for their own countries.
People want to talk facts. Instead of remoaning and keep putting our country down check out the Euro news.
EUROPE DO NOT WANT US TO HAVE ANOTHER REFERENDUM. They will be glad to see the back of us. instead of keep knocking your country support it and believe in it.
What does supporting and believing in your country mean, exactly? Agreeing with you? What’s British about giving in, agreeing to something you strongly believe is wrong and which will damage your country?

You claim that we haven’t seen any of the doom and gloom results of Brexit (even though it hasn’t happened yet) that were predicted (apart from austerity being extended for another five years). Enlighten me as to the amazing benefits we have seen so far. People were told this would make their lives better - any examples of that?
 
  • Like
Reactions: bobmid
What does supporting and believing in your country mean, exactly? Agreeing with you? What’s British about giving in, agreeing to something you strongly believe is wrong and which will damage your country?

You claim that we haven’t seen any of the doom and gloom results of Brexit (even though it hasn’t happened yet) that were predicted (apart from austerity being extended for another five years). Enlighten me as to the amazing benefits we have seen so far. People were told this would make their lives better - any examples of that?

I do think this is a really interesting point... being positive is one thing, but we have nothing to be positive about... no detail... no assessments... no substance... seriously no-one in their right minds would buy a washing machine or a car on the basis of the sellers' say so, but we are being expected to make arguably the most important decision of our (and our children's) lives based on the say so of a cabal of vastly wealthy individuals that expect us to just acquiesce like good little proles.

In a climate where distrust of politicians is rife... that kind of blind trust is in pretty short supply. Especially since the only reason the referendum was called was because the PM at the time used it as a vote of confidence and insurance against the rise of UKIP... and lost.
 
What does supporting and believing in your country mean, exactly? Agreeing with you? What’s British about giving in, agreeing to something you strongly believe is wrong and which will damage your country?

You claim that we haven’t seen any of the doom and gloom results of Brexit (even though it hasn’t happened yet) that were predicted (apart from austerity being extended for another five years). Enlighten me as to the amazing benefits we have seen so far. People were told this would make their lives better - any examples of that?

Here is one good thing that has happened. Our Prime minister doesn't have to sit in the boring meetings in Brussels trying to achieve something they will never let her have. That is over now. That's a 'benefit'
Here are some more. Sadly like I said yesterday people are not excepting good news or ignoring it. Here are 2 nicely explained articles.

The Good News on Brexit They’re Not Telling You
https://www.nytimes.com/2017/07/31/opinion/brexit-european-union-good-news.html

There is plenty of good Brexit news, we’re just ignoring it
When Brexit good news does crack the surface it is routinely skewed too. “Despite Brexit” reporting is an editorial technique that particular newspapers excel at. Should the UK’s economy prove “resilient”, it is despite, never because of, Brexit. If ever there was a case of cognitive dissonance it’s this method of
rationalising every failed gloomy prediction. Spot on
https://inews.co.uk/opinion/comment/brexit-media-coverage-ignores-good-news-theres-lots/

As for the pound....
The pound surged to $1.3691 on Friday - the highest since the result of the EU referendum in June 2016 was known - on reports that Spain and the Netherlands are willing to back a soft Brexit deal.
https://www.theguardian.com/busines...-gains-despite-dip-in-oil-price-business-live

Pound hits highest level since Brexit vote
http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-42661361

Remoaners can stick that in their croissants
 
Last edited:
Funnily we were told by many that Farage was an 'idiot' and he didn't know what he was talking about and now the usual suspects hang on to his every word? funny that?:huh:

I don't believe I ever said he's an idiot. He is a devious, lying, racist hypocrite though. Unfinished business Nige.
 
  • Like
Reactions: QPR Oslo
/

As for the pound....
The pound surged to $1.3691 on Friday - the highest since the result of the EU referendum in June 2016 was known - on reports that Spain and the Netherlands are willing to back a soft Brexit deal.
https://www.theguardian.com/busines...-gains-despite-dip-in-oil-price-business-live

Pound hits highest level since Brexit vote
http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-42661361

Remoaners can stick that in their croissants

So the pound surged on the suggestion that we might end up with a 'soft' Brexit - which is the description normally used for staying in the Single Market. Imagine how much further it would surge if we didn't leave at all.
 
I think you are right, I can’t see the point of referenda in a representative democracy like ours. Honestly. MPs are elected to make the decisions, it’s bottling it when governments call a referendum. We never get one on going to war, I notice.


You're the only one who has admitted to not wanting referendums. So presumably everyone else on here is happy with them? (No..........wait!!)

I'm torn about them myself to be honest. Then I hear people like Ken Clarke saying that "the people can't be trusted to make the right decision" and I immediately think "**** you", give me a vote. I believe that the present class of politicians, of all colours, are without doubt, the worst in as long as I can remember. They're all either inept, self-serving, corrupt, terrorist supporting, elitist, untrustworthy inadequate idiots and I wouldn't trust any of them to make a decision that is in my Country's best interest.

Either we have referendums and abide by their results (the latest one was indeed advisory, but the Government made it clear that if we voted to leave, that is what would happen. It wasn't a difficult question.........stay or leave. I knew exactly what I was voting for, but hey, we've done all that to death).

I suppose that, in an ideal World, I'd like to have no referendums and feel able to rely on my elected politicians to make enough good decisions. As things stand, that feels like putting the leader of North Korea in charge of the USA's nuclear arsenal!!
Often it seems to me that our politicians are completely out of step with public opinion, mainly because so many of them live in their elitist bubble, so on balance, I'd stick with giving the people a say on huge questions like leaving the EU.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ELLERS
Well, it was advisory, so it holds no legal obligation, despite Theresa May's keenness to describe a difference of less that 2% justification to claim it was the 'will of the people' - a concept that is laughably naive if you claim it to be unchanging and something that should stand in perpetuity.

OnAnd if you do believe that... then the vote to join the EU was equally 'the will of the people' - should that not stand as finite and unquestioned? Clearly a flawed argument don't you think?

Interestingly, in the period between the 2010 and 2015 elections a surprising percentage of the electorate were swing voters according to the BES - http://www.britishelectionstudy.com/bes-findings/how-were-almost-all-swingers-now/

Out of the something like 44m registered voters that amounted to potentially 11m (clearly not accounting for those that don't vote) that are undecided enough in their party politics to change from one to another side of the political divide every few years. If you take the 34m that voted in the referendum - that might suggest that 8.5m might change their minds if offered another chance to express their opinion - and what we do know for sure is that only a small swing would be needed to change the 'will of the people' to remain.

Also it's not about just rerunning the vote, not sure why people are hung up on that... indeed that would be indeed slightly pointless. Conversely giving 'the people' the opportunity to cast their vote on the basis of actual fact and detail rather than the unsubstantiated slogans and bombast of the Brexit campaign is hardly the traitorous behaviour that the more dogmatic among us would prefer us to believe.

It's often forgotten that we do know what membership of the EU entails, including costs, responsibilities and all the associated trade and social impacts.

But whether you like it or not we still have absolutely no idea about how Brext will impact the country - on the basis of that alone it would suggest that the idea that a single advisory vote should be construed as a final (and somehow legally, politically and socially binding) contract is ludicrous.


Still don't know if you're in favour of referendums or not?
 
That’s because the government impact assessments only exist in a form that could have been written by an 11 year old, apparently.
They were basically summaries of specific industries with some analysis of future risks and opportunities - but not including Brexit.. In fairness there are so many possible negotiated outcomes that they would only have been guesswork anyway. And that is exactly what they should have said.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ELLERS
Here is one good thing that has happened. Our Prime minister doesn't have to sit in the boring meetings in Brussels trying to achieve something they will never let her have. That is over now. That's a 'benefit'
Here are some more. Sadly like I said yesterday people are not excepting good news or ignoring it. Here are 2 nicely explained articles.

The Good News on Brexit They’re Not Telling You
https://www.nytimes.com/2017/07/31/opinion/brexit-european-union-good-news.html

There is plenty of good Brexit news, we’re just ignoring it
When Brexit good news does crack the surface it is routinely skewed too. “Despite Brexit” reporting is an editorial technique that particular newspapers excel at. Should the UK’s economy prove “resilient”, it is despite, never because of, Brexit. If ever there was a case of cognitive dissonance it’s this method of
rationalising every failed gloomy prediction. Spot on
https://inews.co.uk/opinion/comment/brexit-media-coverage-ignores-good-news-theres-lots/

As for the pound....
The pound surged to $1.3691 on Friday - the highest since the result of the EU referendum in June 2016 was known - on reports that Spain and the Netherlands are willing to back a soft Brexit deal.
https://www.theguardian.com/busines...-gains-despite-dip-in-oil-price-business-live

Pound hits highest level since Brexit vote
http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-42661361

Remoaners can stick that in their croissants

Thank you for the information
 
Costs me a extra £200 a month at the moment ... I can live with that

Ellers is right imo it will just be swings and roundabouts re money.

None of us will care that’s to say it will absorbed as natural life

Making Britain Great again however will be and is a very pipe dream. It’s a win win for me personally as I can live either place depending on current values at the time

I certainly hope for a revolutionary approach that completely shatters the south of England and brings in a equilibrium on house prices.
I would love to see that

As for competing on trade then that’s a massive revolution required and may take decades or generations. Our logistics of transportation for example will require a massive overhaul nationally to give our any chance of getting anywhere close to our neighbours. Getting goods from AtoB to buy or sell can’t cope now. The entire subject is on a knife edge imo just one factor cripples everything.

Goods and margins in the U.K. are currently cut to the bone now... we have never had it so good. Price wars and fierce competition keeps it that way. From this it’s logical to see rise across the board . I can only see casualties here.

The amount the pound is worth could be irrelevant if what you get for it in the future is less. Household budgets imo are not that far removed from business ... the average national household debt in the U.K. we know is the highest in Europe across the regional and so called invisible class systems.

Making Britain great again in the minds of nationists is a pipe dream albeit a good one
My only fear that I base my opinions on is we have spent too much time blaming other people for the nations failings and time has overtaken us to a point whereupon it looks impossible to change that culture .

We are in this mess because we made our own history we sold out in effect and now are left with people saying that’s not fair ... it’s not fair ... it’s immigration. With a divided people who can’t agree or unite on jack **** in what world does that look promising ?

Remainers and Brexiteers we are all a bunch of twats ... we do not have the culture or mind set to recover couple that with weak politics it’s looks massive to me.

Sorry but I am very much guilty of being I’m alright jack and wanting the best for my family ... it’s the true Anglo Saxon way
I have the pride in being able to speak the truth that I am a hypocrite.

Stick that in two slices of white bread
 
Costs me a extra £200 a month at the moment ... I can live with that

Ellers is right imo it will just be swings and roundabouts re money.

None of us will care that’s to say it will absorbed as natural life

Making Britain Great again however will be and is a very pipe dream. It’s a win win for me personally as I can live either place depending on current values at the time

I certainly hope for a revolutionary approach that completely shatters the south of England and brings in a equilibrium on house prices.
I would love to see that

As for competing on trade then that’s a massive revolution required and may take decades or generations. Our logistics of transportation for example will require a massive overhaul nationally to give our any chance of getting anywhere close to our neighbours. Getting goods from AtoB to buy or sell can’t cope now. The entire subject is on a knife edge imo just one factor cripples everything.

Goods and margins in the U.K. are currently cut to the bone now... we have never had it so good. Price wars and fierce competition keeps it that way. From this it’s logical to see rise across the board . I can only see casualties here.

The amount the pound is worth could be irrelevant if what you get for it in the future is less. Household budgets imo are not that far removed from business ... the average national household debt in the U.K. we know is the highest in Europe across the regional and so called invisible class systems.

Making Britain great again in the minds of nationists is a pipe dream albeit a good one
My only fear that I base my opinions on is we have spent too much time blaming other people for the nations failings and time has overtaken us to a point whereupon it looks impossible to change that culture .

We are in this mess because we made our own history we sold out in effect and now are left with people saying that’s not fair ... it’s not fair ... it’s immigration. With a divided people who can’t agree or unite on jack **** in what world does that look promising ?

Remainers and Brexiteers we are all a bunch of twats ... we do not have the culture or mind set to recover couple that with weak politics it’s looks massive to me.

Sorry but I am very much guilty of being I’m alright jack and wanting the best for my family ... it’s the true Anglo Saxon way
I have the pride in being able to speak the truth that I am a hypocrite.

Stick that in two slices of white bread

Zzzzzzzzzzz
You will be okay, you can live in France and come back to the UK when you need NHS or Dentist, or maybe cheaper food or may I say it QPR.
Lots of people live in EU don't want Brexit because it will upset their way of life so 'F22k' the ones that live in the UK.
No chance, things will change and people don't like it