Yes, for the Just About Managings, private school would be out of reach unless a scholarship or bursary was available. You might well argue that this alone was reason enough to abolish their charitable status. As I say, I don't have a definitive position and would like to hear all the arguments.
All I would say is that I've been cynical about Labour's all inclusive education policies since their proposed solution to kids that were causing havoc in the classroom and clearly needed individual attention to sort out underlying problems, was to keep them in classes even if it disrupted the education of the rest of the class. That was madness.
Does that mean the school as a charity can claim 20% gift aid and the parent claim tax relief on their "donations to charity"? Just asking for a friend.