The #LUFC Breakfast Debate (Thursday 11th December)

  • Please bear with us on the new site integration and fixing any known bugs over the coming days. If you can not log in please try resetting your password and check your spam box. If you have tried these steps and are still struggling email [email protected] with your username/registered email address
  • Log in now to remove adverts - no adverts at all to registered members!

ellandback

Well-Known Member
Forum Moderator
Mar 30, 2011
63,356
34,989
113
Southampton
You must log in or register to see images

Good Morning. It's Thursday 11th December, and here are the latest headlines from Elland Road

Has Tanaka nailed down his starting position at Brentford

The last few weeks at Leeds United have shone as brightly for Ao Tanaka. The Japan international was integral to securing four valuable points against Premier League giants Chelsea and Liverpool, yet curiously, his place in Daniel Farke’s starting XI remains far from guaranteed. For a player so heavily involved in Leeds’ title-winning campaign last season, it’s perplexing that doubts linger over his role. Tanaka’s recent exploits underline his value: a precise 20‑yard strike that effectively ended Chelsea’s hopes before half‑time, followed by his dramatic 96th‑minute equaliser against Liverpool. These moments perfectly encapsulate the growing confidence and influence of a player who, earlier in the season, was reportedly struggling for belief in his own game.

Since being drafted into the starting line up against West Ham, due to Anton Stach’s rib injury, Tanaka has enjoyed a run in the side, though he has completed a full 90 minutes only once this season. Even in limited game time, his impact is beginning to tell. The summer acquisitions of Sean Longstaff and Stach, both taller, more physically imposing midfielders have restricted Tanaka to just over 550 league minutes and six starts, narrowing the window for him to reassert himself as an automatic selection. Statistically, his ability to progress the ball stands out; few in Leeds’ squad can match his eye for threading incisive passes or carrying possession into dangerous areas. However, defensive metrics reveal shortcomings, particularly in tackle success rates, where his rivals offer greater reliability.

Yet, what Tanaka lacks in sheer physical presence, he more than compensates for with sharp anticipation, quick interceptions, and a tireless work ethic. His willingness to press, recover possession in advanced zones, and battle for every ball brings a dynamic edge to Leeds’ midfield that numbers alone cannot capture. The recent goals should serve as a timely boost to his confidence, potentially reigniting the form that made him such a key figure in previous campaigns. As Farke continues to manage squad rotation amid a congested schedule, Tanaka’s blend of technical precision and relentless energy could yet force a rethink. For now, the question mark over his name remains, but the evidence on the pitch suggests that Ao Tanaka is ready to prove he belongs at the heart of Leeds United’s midfield.

You must log in or register to see images


Santiago Gimenez loan move unlikely

Over the past several days, Leeds United have been heavily linked with a potential January loan swoop for AC Milan striker Santiago Gimenez – but the feasibility of such a deal remains uncertain. While the Whites have impressively netted eight goals in their last three matches, all against Premier League title contenders, there is a clear recognition within the club that long-term firepower is still a major issue. Dominic Calvert-Lewin and Lucas Nmecha's injury records underline the need for depth if Leeds are to survive this season.

Gimenez, a 24yo Mexican international, built his reputation as a prolific finisher at Feyenoord, scoring 65 goals in just 105 appearances. His performances earned him a high-profile move to AC Milan last winter for an initial £27.9 million. However, his time in Italy has so far been less fruitful, yielding no league goals this season in 627 minutes of play. The lack of game time has naturally caught the attention of potential suitors, with Leeds reportedly keeping him firmly on their radar since missing out on him in 2024.

According to Spanish outlet Fichajes, Leeds stand out as the most determined contenders for Gimenez’s signature, and the Yorkshire club are said to be closely monitoring his situation, evaluating a possible loan or even a discounted permanent deal. Yet, that latter option seems improbable. Nima Tavallaey Roodsari, a well-regarded Italian football journalist and Serie A expert, told the Breakfast Debate that AC Milan have no intention of sanctioning a cut-price sale. Instead, the Rossoneri would more of less seek to recoup the full amount they invested just 11 months ago.

Complicating matters further, West Ham United are also credited with an interest in Gimenez and have reportedly explored a potential part-exchange offer involving Niclas Füllkrug. However, early indications suggest that Milan are not attracted to that proposal, preferring a straightforward cash deal if they were to sell.

While Leeds’ pursuit remains alive, the financial demands set by Milan and competition from rival clubs mean a January transfer may hinge on creative negotiations – or the player himself pushing for a move. For now, Leeds fans can only watch the space and hope their striking ambitions materialise.

You must log in or register to see images
 
With Tanaka, for me there are 2 issues which if he could iron out, would probably mean he’d be at a mid table EPL club, pushing for regular minutes.

Thought last year he was generally outstanding however I had some doubts about him stepping up. Whilst technically a good player he causes problems when losing the ball, due to mistimed or misdirected distribution, or going into challenges he has less chance of winning. You cannot criticise him too much for the latter, it’s what can happen when pressing the opposition. I just wish he’d pick his moments more carefully.

Think he’s done well recently, but I’d still like to see improvement in those 2 areas. He’s a cracking little player.
 
Although he works hard, Tanaka struggles with the physicality/athleticism of the prem in my opinion. He's done really well in some games but been a passenger in others. I fell like he's the antithesis of Aaronson. Aaronson gets no credit whatever he does. Tanaka gets rave reviews for taking a dump.

He also struggles sometimes to remember his job and gets carried away. His defensive marking isn't the best, he had to be subbed a few weeks ago to stop him from getting himself sent off. Someone on here pointed out his role in liverpool's third. I missed it at the time, but when you watch it back it's really poor. He left his man and went on a one-man press, everything he's instructed not to do. His man gravenberch, was promptly given free reign to walk through and set up the goal. Farke was apoplectic. This is the same sort of reason Ramazani was sent to valencia. These are the sort of small details, as Farke call's them, that get you relegated.

To be clear I do like him, he's a very neat and tidy player he definitely helps get our passing game going and he puts in a shift. If people were slagging him off I'd defend him! For me i'd play him in home games against mid-low table sides where we're all out to win, but would likely be starting with Longstaff in other games.
 
  • Like
Reactions: foolee
To add a smilie on mobile, simply open your camera and do the pose/action for the smilie you with to add.

98.37% accuracy rate.

:afro:
i am on about the ones that used to be already on the site/mobile.......not taking my own with a camera, the one i used in the above comment are still there on desktop !
 
i am on about the ones that used to be already on the site/mobile.......not taking my own with a camera, the one i used in the above comment are still there on desktop !
Click on the second set of 3 dots from the left in the reply box, theyre in there
 
  • Like
Reactions: Makemstine Roger
We're all happy with the changes then?

It does seem a little less colourful. A little harsher.

Some of you old bastards will struggle to read the text
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Makemstine Roger