Vidal with only one leg would still be better than Fletcher, Cleverly, Fellaini or Anderson. I don't know enough about his knee injury tbh, but I wouldn't let that rule him out...it didn't with RVN. Vidal is a box to box type, ideal both defensively and going forward. Carvalho I don't know enough about, but perhaps just have faith in reports and our scouts (although they're a bit of a joke) and we need to take a bit of risk with emerging talent rather than continuously waiting for them to cut their teeth at another medium/big club before we pay triple the price we could have got them for. I agree about the number of injuries. Hopefully Herrera and Kagawa will be back as options in midfield straight after the international break. With regards to ADM, don't get me wrong, he's already shown today he's exactly what we need...but like Mata, if he has ****e around him he can't do it all on his own.