Transfer Rumours Summer Transfer window

  • Please bear with us on the new site integration and fixing any known bugs over the coming days. If you can not log in please try resetting your password and check your spam box. If you have tried these steps and are still struggling email [email protected] with your username/registered email address
  • Log in now to remove adverts - no adverts at all to registered members!
Status
Not open for further replies.
I didn't see the game but a general point on coaching strikers. Finishing is one of the hardest thing to coach for me. It is so hard to replicate the in game situation for strikers. The majority of chances are not 1 on 1 with the keeper, which is what you see the majority of finishing drills doing. They are useful for repetition of striking the ball, but not a lot else (well maybe you demoralise your keeper!).

The best finishers are usually instinctive ones. They have the angles in their head at all times and know where to place the shot. You see placement over power and you know the finisher is a natural. Isidor has great placement for example. That is hard to coach but it isn't really technique - essentially it is an accurate pass and everyone can do that. It is about being able to do it in the moment. It is instinct, knowing the angle and placing the short in a split second. I have tried all sorts over the years with young strikers but sometimes it is not coachable. The best stuff these days, in my opinion, is when you take the keeper out of the equation. Clubs use tiny goals as the target, which is worthwhile. I used to put empty coke bottles just inside each post and that was the target. You really need to blend that accuracy with a 'no look' situation - so everything at maximum speed and first time finishing. Or you can make them play back to goal and turn and finish, but move the target object each time. Daft little things I suppose, and sorry for rambling while I ate my cheese and beetroot sarnie.

Completely agree with this but the Abdullahi miss wasn't a poor finish as much as a poor choice in looking to square it when he should have finished.

I reckon he learnt his lesson in the best way possible (in a friendly) and next time he's through on goal for us he'll be smashing it in.
 
Moore is obviously not a prem-level keeper. He is a fine second keeper at championship level but his passing is poor and his actual shot stopping is average. I appreciate that people have issues with Patto's kicking but his passing itself is generally very good and helps us a lot.

Jason Steele is in the PL. Let that sink in, after his time here.
 
I didn't see the game but a general point on coaching strikers. Finishing is one of the hardest thing to coach for me. It is so hard to replicate the in game situation for strikers. The majority of chances are not 1 on 1 with the keeper, which is what you see the majority of finishing drills doing. They are useful for repetition of striking the ball, but not a lot else (well maybe you demoralise your keeper!).

The best finishers are usually instinctive ones. They have the angles in their head at all times and know where to place the shot. You see placement over power and you know the finisher is a natural. Isidor has great placement for example. That is hard to coach but it isn't really technique - essentially it is an accurate pass and everyone can do that. It is about being able to do it in the moment. It is instinct, knowing the angle and placing the short in a split second. I have tried all sorts over the years with young strikers but sometimes it is not coachable. The best stuff these days, in my opinion, is when you take the keeper out of the equation. Clubs use tiny goals as the target, which is worthwhile. I used to put empty coke bottles just inside each post and that was the target. You really need to blend that accuracy with a 'no look' situation - so everything at maximum speed and first time finishing. Or you can make them play back to goal and turn and finish, but move the target object each time. Daft little things I suppose, and sorry for rambling while I ate my cheese and beetroot sarnie.
I hate some of the drills I see being used for 'finishing' practice. Often unopposed with the player being able to take 4/5 touches in the box. I think it's the hardest thing to practice as, like you say, it's all instinct
 
  • Like
Reactions: FellTop
32 is a decent age for a keeper its when they are in their prime

This 100% ^

As a retired coach, and Sports Science student, the stats prove that the 'injury free' athlete within Football, will hit a peak between the ages of - 28 to 34.

Howeer, a Goalkeeper's peak (based on ground covered during a season,and phisical exertion factors etc) are highl likely to have a playing career peak between the ages of 31 to 36. :emoticon-0148-yes:
 
Jason Steele is in the PL. Let that sink in, after his time here.

This is why I'll never write off a player, especially a keeper as they are a complete enigma.

Onana cost £50m, at times he looks like he has never played football before and id rather have Patterson...but no doubt he will go somewhere else eventually and be world class.

Keepers must be the riskiest transfer signing at any club.
 
This 100% ^

As a retired coach, and Sports Science student, the stats prove that the 'injury free' athlete within Football, will hit a peak between the ages of - 28 to 34.

Howeer, a Goalkeeper's peak (based on ground covered during a season,and phisical exertion factors etc) are highl likely to have a playing career peak between the ages of 31 to 36. :emoticon-0148-yes:


Goalkeepers often peak in their early to mid-30s because their success relies more on experience, positioning, and decision-making, which improve with age, rather than solely on physical attributes like speed and stamina. While physical abilities like reflexes might decline slightly, the mental aspects of goalkeeping continue to develop, making them more effective in their later years.
Here's a more detailed explanation:
  • Experience and Positioning:
    Goalkeepers with years of experience develop a superior understanding of the game, including reading the play, anticipating opponent movements, and positioning themselves effectively, according to a LinkedIn article on player development. This intuition and positioning become more refined with age.
  • Mental Attributes:
    Goalkeeping requires quick decision-making, the ability to organize the defense, and mental fortitude, all of which are honed with experience. These mental attributes continue to develop well into a goalkeeper's 30s.
  • Physical Decline is Less Impactful:
    While some physical attributes like agility and speed might decline, goalkeepers rely less on these than outfield players. Their core abilities, such as handling crosses, saving shots, and distributing the ball, are less affected by age.
  • Example:
    Players like Edwin van der Sar, who played at a high level into his late 30s, exemplify this trend.
Therefore, while some players might retire in their late 20s, many goalkeepers continue to thrive in their 30s due to the unique combination of experience and refined mental skills that the position demands.
 
Goalkeepers often peak in their early to mid-30s because their success relies more on experience, positioning, and decision-making, which improve with age, rather than solely on physical attributes like speed and stamina. While physical abilities like reflexes might decline slightly, the mental aspects of goalkeeping continue to develop, making them more effective in their later years.
Here's a more detailed explanation:
  • Experience and Positioning:
    Goalkeepers with years of experience develop a superior understanding of the game, including reading the play, anticipating opponent movements, and positioning themselves effectively, according to a LinkedIn article on player development. This intuition and positioning become more refined with age.
  • Mental Attributes:
    Goalkeeping requires quick decision-making, the ability to organize the defense, and mental fortitude, all of which are honed with experience. These mental attributes continue to develop well into a goalkeeper's 30s.
  • Physical Decline is Less Impactful:
    While some physical attributes like agility and speed might decline, goalkeepers rely less on these than outfield players. Their core abilities, such as handling crosses, saving shots, and distributing the ball, are less affected by age.
  • Example:
    Players like Edwin van der Sar, who played at a high level into his late 30s, exemplify this trend.
Therefore, while some players might retire in their late 20s, many goalkeepers continue to thrive in their 30s due to the unique combination of experience and refined mental skills that the position demands.

Agree......And, it's perfect logic :emoticon-0148-yes:
 
  • Like
Reactions: Teessidemackem
No chance. And the rules have changed.

If intimidation of refs is what we want the game has gone further to ****e than I thought.
Haway man there were zero penalties awarded against them at old trafford for 6 seasons. If thats not referee intimidation I don’t know what is
 
He made a couple of decent saves at the weekend mind.
The saves he had to make were straight at him most of the time though.

I’d say it was an okay performance from him on Saturday, a 6/10 one.

Certainly don’t want him playing in goal for us in the premier league regardless.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Hudson92
Moore is obviously not a prem-level keeper. He is a fine second keeper at championship level but his passing is poor and his actual shot stopping is average. I appreciate that people have issues with Patto's kicking but his passing itself is generally very good and helps us a lot.
Patto distribution is shocking man. Does not command his box. Decent shot stopper tho
 
You must log in or register to see media

Sunderland continue to negotiate with Leicester to lower Bilal El Khannouss' release clause, estimated at £22m, with 10% on a future resale. Nottingham Forest and Aston Villa are in the race. Monaco are still waiting for a departure before moving forward with an attacking player [HASHTAG]#Mercato[/HASHTAG]
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Jarca and Scout73
You must log in or register to see media

Sunderland continues to talk to Leicester to lower Bilal El Khannouss's €26 million clause, and 10% on a future resale. Nottingham Forest and Aston Villa are in the running. Monaco is still waiting for a departure before moving forward with a #TransferToday offensive.
26 is way too high for him
 
You must log in or register to see media

Sunderland continues to talk to Leicester to lower Bilal El Khannouss's €26 million clause, and 10% on a future resale. Nottingham Forest and Aston Villa are in the running. Monaco is still waiting for a departure before moving forward with a #TransferToday offensive.
This one doesn't seem to be going away, very talented footballer tbh but would be worrked about losing 3 CMs for the AFCON
 
You must log in or register to see media

Sunderland continues to talk to Leicester to lower Bilal El Khannouss's €26 million clause, and 10% on a future resale. Nottingham Forest and Aston Villa are in the running. Monaco is still waiting for a departure before moving forward with a #TransferToday offensive.

This one confuses me a bit. Don't see where he fits. Seems a good player though.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.