I'm a great believer in players being judged on what they do currently not previously or afterwards. The story books at most clubs are littered with signings who have come with great reputations and failed as well as average sorts who shine for them and become legendary. Just a couple of examples are Friio for us and Bollaise for somebody else. I've always maintained that Managers who produce what we would call great sides, Sturrock's first as an example, are lucky to hit on the right mix and personalities. No great stars but look what they achieved. Few of those were great elsewhere particularly.