Off Topic Stoptober

How does it work for prisoners and guards where (I think) prisoners can smoke in their cells?

Well at HMP Everthorpe, which is Cat B, the inmates are only supposed to smoke outside. The guards have designated smoking areas (or they did do, not sure if they still exist) outside. However, it's a prison, nobody really gives two ****s and the cons pretty much smoke everywhere except the cafeteria.
 
Well at HMP Everthorpe, which is Cat B, the inmates are only supposed to smoke outside. The guards have designated smoking areas (or they did do, not sure if they still exist) outside. However, it's a prison, nobody really gives two ****s and the cons pretty much smoke everywhere except the cafeteria.


I think the legislation refers to public places, or some such, so I guess prisons are a grey area on that?
 
Simple, because there is cross party support to ultimately try to end smoking in the UK........there is not & I do not see there ever being an appetite in the UK for that policy to change or make smokers even more a pariah than they currently are

That will never happen. As has already been said, the money the government rakes in from tobacco sales is enourmous; were they to ban it completely they'd lose out on billions, if not trillions of pounds, a defecit which would be balanced from...where? At present the government take in £12bn a year, they're hardly going to outlaw it because of a few campaigners. They'd have to ramp up taxes, make more cuts, spend money on rehabilitating those who are heavily addicted and so on.
 
I think the legislation refers to public places, or some such, so I guess prisons are a grey area on that?

Not for much longer......it would have been changed already if not for opposition from the Prison Governors Association which fears riots with over 70% of the prison population being nicotine addicts then being forced to go cold turkey
 
I think the legislation refers to public places, or some such, so I guess prisons are a grey area on that?

Correct, it's hard to say really because unless you're an inmate or guard (my info comes from the latter) it's just speculation. But as far as I'm aware what you say is right, it's purely public places that are affected by the ban.
 
Correct, it's hard to say really because unless you're an inmate or guard (my info comes from the latter) it's just speculation. But as far as I'm aware what you say is right, it's purely public places that are affected by the ban.

Legislation covers the workplace.....a prison is a workplace for all those who are not incarcerated in one.....

http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-34395034
 
Legislation covers the workplace.....a prison is a workplace for all those who are not incarcerated in one.....

http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-34395034

Aye, but isn't the grey area the issue that the cell is a home for the prisoners, which isn't covered by the legislation?

What's the score with people whose job entails visiting people in their own homes? Can they refuse to work in one if the occupier refuses to put the *** out, or is that down to the employer?
 
Aye, but isn't the grey area the issue that the cell is a home for the prisoners, which isn't covered by the legislation?

What's the score with people whose job entails visiting people in their own homes? Can they refuse to work in one if the occupier refuses to put the *** out, or is that down to the employer?

I have heard of cases where some employees in these cases have refused to visit homes of heavy smokers. There have even been suggestions that some councils have investigated the possibility of banning smoking in council owned properties
 
I have heard of cases where some employees in these cases have refused to visit homes of heavy smokers. There have even been suggestions that some councils have investigated the possibility of banning smoking in council owned properties

See that's understandable, rented accomodation should permit smoking at the discretion of the landlord. If that's the council then so be it.
 
See that's understandable, rented accomodation should permit smoking at the discretion of the landlord. If that's the council then so be it.

But it is still the persons home & not a public place.....the reasoning was based on council employees or contractors entering the properties as part of their job...where the persons home became the visitors workplace
 
Anybody ever seen the smoking room in Dubai airport? Last time I was there, 5 years ago, it was a glass-walled room smack in the middle of the main concourse, you could barely see through the glass for the smoke inside.
 
But it is still the persons home & not a public place.....the reasoning was based on council employees or contractors entering the properties as part of their job...where the persons home became the visitors workplace

So someone should stop smoking in their own house in case someone has to call at their house who is a non-smoker? These precious sods should get over themselves and remember who is paying their wages.
What next, no alcohol or dogs in the house in case a Muslim has to enter? No pork as both Muslims and Jews would be upset?
 
  • Like
Reactions: look_back_in_amber
But it is still the persons home & not a public place.....the reasoning was based on council employees or contractors entering the properties as part of their job...where the persons home became the visitors workplace

I'd have to check the law on this, but a rented house belongs to somebody else; it is therefore their property and it is therefore their choice as to what can and can't be done upon it's premisis. When you sign up for a rented house, it often stipulates whether smoking is allowed, if the tenant ignores that clause then they are booted out. It should be the same for council houses, as the people who move in after them might be non-smokers and that wouldn't be fair.
 
I'd have to check the law on this, but a rented house belongs to somebody else; it is therefore their property and it is therefore their choice as to what can and can't be done upon it's premisis. When you sign up for a rented house, it often stipulates whether smoking is allowed, if the tenant ignores that clause then they are booted out. It should be the same for council houses, as the people who move in after them might be non-smokers and that wouldn't be fair.

Stop being silly.
 
Stop being silly.

What's silly about it? It's totally fair, if the house doesn't belong to you then it isn't up to you what you do with it. If you leant me your car and it came back with loads of cig burns in the seats and rubbish in the footwells, the response "well it was technically mine at the time so I smoked 20 Lamberts and ate a ****load of Maccy D's" wouldn't really satisfy you, would it?

In the same way, if I rented my house out on the strict understanding that it wouldn't be smoked in, I wouldn't be happy if at the end of the tenancy I came back to nicotine stained walls, cig burned carpets and stinking rooms. If you live in a council house, then unless you're doing that thing where you're eventually gonna buy it from them it isn't yours to do what you want with, therefore you must respect the rules because there'll no doubt be somebody in there after you.
 
What's silly about it? It's totally fair, if the house doesn't belong to you then it isn't up to you what you do with it. If you leant me your car and it came back with loads of cig burns in the seats and rubbish in the footwells, the response "well it was technically mine at the time so I smoked 20 Lamberts and ate a ****load of Maccy D's" wouldn't really satisfy you, would it?

In the same way, if I rented my house out on the strict understanding that it wouldn't be smoked in, I wouldn't be happy if at the end of the tenancy I came back to nicotine stained walls, cig burned carpets and stinking rooms. If you live in a council house, then unless you're doing that thing where you're eventually gonna buy it from them it isn't yours to do what you want with, therefore you must respect the rules because there'll no doubt be somebody in there after you.

You are being silly. Do you think any government would bring in regulations like that for council tenants? How long do you think cigarette smoke lingers you drama queen?
How about banning people from cooking curries in case the smell lingers and the next people in might not like it?
 
  • Like
Reactions: look_back_in_amber
Anybody ever seen the smoking room in Dubai airport? Last time I was there, 5 years ago, it was a glass-walled room smack in the middle of the main concourse, you could barely see through the glass for the smoke inside.
Not seen the one in Dubai but I've seen the one in Singapore Airport, I had to go in to get the Mrs. as she was a smoker at that point, it really was ****ing disgusting.