"No I don't know and neither do you. You're basing your view on 'Brendan must be right'. I don't subscribe to that"- KJ No you dont ,you only subscribe to you being right. Everyone else including a guy that has coached/studied/taught players from all over the world cant possibly be right about Dobbie can he Its more to do with trusting the manager than thinking he must be right about everything, RE dobbie i think he made the right call
Rodgers plan in the Premier didn't include Dobbie . Rodgers plan worked magnificently .... end of ! . To argue against Rodgers decisions on players playing time is fruitless on the heels of the success he had playing Dobbie in the Championship & not playing him in the Premier . When it comes to Dobbie , I have no problem with Rodgers take on the situation because he knows best !
Jackash- Rodgers gets to see him everyday and knows his game,why people think there should be a minimum time to judge is beyond me, it could be something as simple as not closing down the opposition quick enough or refusing to run and work as hard as the other players in a game situation. Maybe he doesnt do the graft on the training field and therfore doesnt even get close to selection? truth is the only person that knows is BR, and as i said before he isnt a dummy, his job as a coach means there are things he will look at that will not be obvious to us, it may well be something really simple but we have to respect the fact Brenden has got this right, the league table is proof of that and Gylfis performances have showed what we need at this level in that position.
Rogers knows best? Most of the time I would agree, but I believe alot of his substitutions have had a few posters on here confused and often they havnt worked out. Could be wrong about the Dobster too.
Dobbie has gone on loan to shoot the bluebirds down!! he s agent dobbie mun!!! rodgers aint a mug, cant build a prem team with championship players.Dobbie will be first of many to get ****ed off in the summer and rightly so,we have too many average players taking a wage at the swans, dobbie is slowas **** at this level,out of his depth ,nice bloke but not a prem player.
Who the **** is talking about "before this season" ?? its the end of the season now mate,have you been sleeping for 6 months?? the time is coming to sort out the deadwood, of course we couldnt go and buy a ****in brand new team when we went up are you daft!! the time to progress is now,we didnt kow how we were going to do at the start but we have something to build on now,that includes deadwood like Bessone,tremmell the giant that cant catch and one or 2 others, Luke moore can go along with Lita, Dobbie too can **** off too fat and slow for prem football with all those wages saved we can build something more streamlined.
That is to the point manselton problem some of these ****ers have contracts and we can't just offload them like that lol
"its the end of the season now mate,have you been sleeping for 6 months?? " Funny as Hell fair play In fairness there does need to be quite a few to move on and maybe some painful choices(dobbie being extremly painful for some no doubt) we need to keep a tight squad that can compete and i think there should be massive praise for the medical staff who have kept the boys in top shape all season
A possibility of reaching 50 points , after Man U 's 4 - 4 result with Everton today we could be in line at the opportunity to bring down United's title bid & a final game at Liberty against Liverpool after being applauded off the pitch at Anfield are the ways I'll remember this season . Not on a bunch of what if scenario's regarding player decisions , that in the big picture , fit to a tee . All the best to Dobbie but he;s just not that important frankly , seems some think we've benched the next superstar & we clearly haven't .
Seeing as we seem to ****ing like ****ing swearing, no I am not ****ing daft. It is you that is daft, for I didn't once mention going out to buy a whole new team. Your original post said "You can't build a PL team out of Championship players". Tell me, what the **** have we just done? Survived our first ever season in the PL with what were Championship players.
Dobbie is no superstar, supersize maybe but no superstar !! If we dont move players on we will no room for wages, Lita and moore will find a club, dobbie is nailed on for blackpool ,bessone can go and spend the money he robbed off leeds and the jolly green giant tremmel can go and play somewhere where the pressures of catching the ball are less important. some of those lads are out of contract anyway i think so happy days for us and we might even bring in some cash for the save gylfi fund
NJ: why do you moan when posters 'get personal' but revel in it yourself, encouraging others to do just that? Of course I 'subscribe to being right'. What's the point of having an opinion if you don't believe it's the right one? JA is perfectly correct. The comment from manselton was "cant build a prem team with championship players" and the reply was to the effect that Rodgers (contrary to QPR, but exactly like Norwich) did exactly that. Fair point, don't you think? Manselton: If Dobbie is 'too fat and too slow' for the Prem what say you about Holt? Half the pace and twice the size. As I recall the 'fat and slow' Dobbie almost single handedly delivered Prem football to this Club. Some respect please.
We didnt build **** all fella ,we took a massive gamble and it worked all because we have a decent manager that signed ...<coughs> a premier league centre half in caulks and a top european attacking midfield in glyfi siggurdson do you want to know where we would be right now without those 2 "prem type players?? bottom 3 mate no problem, so i am right in what i say, we need to build a prem team, not get one in on loan and hope for the best, dont forget scotty sinclair who was prem class and the reason we got promoted in the first place. the boys done good this year, some of them come out the other end thats what we build off, if you think it was the championship players what done it then you really have been sleeping mate !! we knew we had scotty,ash,allen and taylor who was potential prem class we also added routs who done good so its not really a massive step but without siggs and caulks we would have been ****ed!
The fact remains our team was built upon the players that got us there - Championship players with little and sometimes no Prem experience. Yes, some invaluable contributions from quality loanees but I thought Britton, Agustien, Allen, Sinclair, Dyer, Taylor, Rangel and Williams (some would say the backbone of the team) played for us in the Championship. Dunno. Maybe I was sleeping and missed it all. Maybe I'll wake up in the shower and it was all a dream.
holt is fat and slow but stands in the right place because he is fat and slow. he aint afraid to put his head in where it hurts and be like an old fashioned player who dont mind a bit of rough and tumble,most prem centre halfs are like fannies these days, holt is cut from lower league stock so the right long ball and he gets you results, dobbs as much as he is a legend is just fat and slow without holts head or heart, a great championship player but cant cope with pace in the prem most of the boys struggle with it to be fair but dobbs is a focal point that aint worked in this league,maybe if he got fatter he will be more effective
Can't follow your logic. Because there isn't any. I don't know why you resort to insults. No need for it. Yes, I can comment on Dobbie's size because I have met him. See? That's logic. Next lesson, so pay attention: So the team that got us promoted was a 'Championship team' but the team that kept us there was a 'Prem team'? I'll say this slowly.... We - kept - more - or - less - the - same - team. Perhaps you were sleeping during the transfer windows. Caulker came from the Prem and we were doing pretty well before Siggy's arrival from the Bundesliga. Graham came from the Championship. Almost to a man this was a 'Championship side' that has delivered another season for us. Ask QPR how they are doing with their 'Prem team'.
Just because a MOD starts getting a bit of stick the thread gets closed down, all seemed ok to me ,nothing nasty just pure comedy ,something that is in short supply on this forum lately, now i see why . Pathetic .
