Should Shaun Wright-Phillips be dropped from the QPR team?

What did warnock say when he signed him? Something like 'others have their doubts but I think he can net 10 goals a season'?? Or something similar?

They've all been brainwashed by his ex England status

Apart from the first toon match and disallowed goal against the baggies I can't see what he's added to the team

 

Like a stone!

 

7 of the voters so far are obviously Reading fans

 

The funny thing is, only Derry is below him in the betting odds for our top goalscorer which is pretty bad for a winger. Even Boswinga, Hulse, Dyer and DJ are at lower odds.

 

Not for Sunday as his pace will murder the Reading defence

 

Shouldn't have been in the team to be dropped in the first place!

 

His pace? Leave it out Ellers, Gorkss would overtake him these days!

 

Hoilett on the right, Taarabt on the left with 3 central midfielders. Cisse up top. That would murder them imo.

 

"very good first half, dreadful second"

No chance you'd tell the actual truth once in a while?

 

Let's just say that we respectfully disagree with your analysis of his contribution so far this season. There hasn't been any that I can recall

 

SWP should stick with playing with this lot

please log in to view this image

 

.

 

Is the Pope catholic?

I'd rather we gave Ephraim a chance.

 

for the record i don't think SWP has been (totally) useless all season, he's been pretty handy defensively at times. The trouble is, of course, is that he's a winger and needs more to his game than the ability to track back a bit. His distribution is shocking at the mo (and he can't shoot) and he actually put us under more pressure defensively as he gives the ball away so often. Don't get me started on his crossing.

I think he could easily start on sunday with park not in the side though.

However I'm with everyone here in wanting to see this '5 across the middle, 3 centre mids, Tarbs and Ranking Junior Hoilett on the wings' experiment happening.