One of the best radio programmes in "606" but I think it seems to go through peaks and troughs depending on who has presented it. Initially Danny Baker was a bit annoying but I think it started to become compelling when David Mellor started to present it-I was surprised how good he was and came up with some good debates. It was most fun when Richard Littlejohn chaired it. Despite these characters, I feel it has become more variable as the programme has split between Saturdays and Sundays.
The reason for this , in my opinion, is Robbie Savage. I think he courts controversy and is sometimes hostile towards callers. After about 30 minutes, I get really annoyed with him whereas when the likes of Jason Roberts have been on, I feel he has a lot of good things to say and is thought-provoking. I wish he would be on my often. I also think that Steve Claridge is very good. I am also a bit disappointed that Alan Green is no longer going to chair the show next season as I find him very assured and professional and a presenter who genuinely engages with his callers. For me, Alan Green is the best presenter this programme has had and whilst he can sometimes be a bit opinionated too, I would have to say that he talks a lot of sense. In contrast, Savage is just a loud mouth and not in the same league I'm afraid.