Rival Watch

  • Please bear with us on the new site integration and fixing any known bugs over the coming days. If you can not log in please try resetting your password and check your spam box. If you have tried these steps and are still struggling email [email protected] with your username/registered email address
  • Log in now to remove adverts - no adverts at all to registered members!
Mate I could pull up threads where LFC fans were saying exact same thing about Rodgers after his first half dozen games, or indeed Dalglish. And look what happened there.

I do think Klopp is clearly a better manager than Rodgers (as Rodgers was a better manager than Hodgson) but none of this equates to improvement for the same reasons we saw with your previous manager.

You probably could to an extent.

And Rodgers was a tangible improvement at the time.

However it took him two years to get us playing well and turning over teams. In the early years it was all possession, no end product.

Rodgers had a good go and had us playing very well and nearly won it.

In the end he became a little too big for his own boots, spent money unwisely, lost a few big players and changed away from what was getting us results, and ultimately knew the guillotine was being wheeled out, as did the players, and couldn't arrest the change in fortunes.

Klopp, with someone else's players, has given the whole club a zap with the defibrillator.

Very early days, but the improvement is there.
 
You probably could to an extent.

And Rodgers was a tangible improvement at the time.

However it took him two years to get us playing well and turning over teams. In the early years it was all possession, no end product.

Rodgers had a good go and had us playing very well and nearly won it.

In the end he became a little too big for his own boots, spent money unwisely, lost a few big players and changed away from what was getting us results, and ultimately knew the guillotine was being wheeled out, as did the players, and couldn't arrest the change in fortunes.

Klopp, with someone else's players, has given the whole club a zap with the defibrillator.

Very early days, but the improvement is there
.

It always happens with new managers, that is why relegation threatened clubs tend to change manager because the bounce effect gains them the extra few points and a chance to stay in the league.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Christiansmith
It always happens with new managers, that is why relegation threatened clubs tend to change manager because the bounce effect gains them the extra few points and a chance to stay in the league.
Kloppyflop gets the new manager effect and the deluded RS dream of the title...<laugh>
 
  • Like
Reactions: Diego
It always happens with new managers, that is why relegation threatened clubs tend to change manager because the bounce effect gains them the extra few points and a chance to stay in the league.

For relegation clubs it does but you assume that the case for established clubs.

It took Rodgers 10 games before he started getting results including losing to West Brom 3-0 at the start, and losses to yourselves and Arsenal.

It took him a few years to get things running smoothly and never got a thrashing at Chelsea or City.

In Roy's first 1o league games we only won 3 games, losing to City, United, Blackpool and Everton and drawing against Birmingham and Sunderland.
 
Kloppyflop is mediocre and only look half decent because his failures have been ignored. Don't take my word for it. It is the Turd himself who said it in the most objective and dispassionate way. <ok>
 
So what you're saying is that Van Gaal's 1.5 years to settle and £400m spend over Klopp means nothing and it all comes down to a Watford own goal, even when you have easier fixtures

Klopp: won 7 of the last 8
Van Gaal: won 3 of the last 9
You do know that Liverpool is in no position to be talking about how much has been spent, right? The return on investment for Liverpool is terrible!!!
 
  • Like
Reactions: HRH Custard VC
For relegation clubs it does but you assume that the case for established clubs.

It took Rodgers 10 games before he started getting results including losing to West Brom 3-0 at the start, and losses to yourselves and Arsenal.

It took him a few years to get things running smoothly and never got a thrashing at Chelsea or City.

In Roy's first 1o league games we only won 3 games, losing to City, United, Blackpool and Everton and drawing against Birmingham and Sunderland.

Aye, but Rodgers and Hodgson were summer changes rather than mid season ones. Mid season changes are very different - the honeymoon period comes during pre season training rather than in competitive games.

Multiple studies have shown that a mid season change at any club creates a bounce of up to half a point per game on average. But that effect lasts only between 12 and 18 games before the performance falls back to the level the club and players are capable of.

Like Dalglish at Liverpool - didn't he get the 2nd most amount of points during his honeymoon period at the end of the 2010/11 season? Then you fell right back to 6th the following year as performances returned to the level the squad was capable of without the bounce.
 
Aye, but Rodgers and Hodgson were summer changes rather than mid season ones. Mid season changes are very different - the honeymoon period comes during pre season training rather than in competitive games.

Multiple studies have shown that a mid season change at any club creates a bounce of up to half a point per game on average. But that effect lasts only between 12 and 18 games before the performance falls back to the level the club and players are capable of.

Like Dalglish at Liverpool - didn't he get the 2nd most amount of points during his honeymoon period at the end of the 2010/11 season? Then you fell right back to 6th the following year as performances returned to the level the squad was capable of without the bounce.

18 games bounce? <laugh>
 
Good reference

According to that, we haven't even hit the peak of Klopp's honeymoon yet, still just warming up

If the expected trend continues we should well placed by the end of January for a strong push for top 4 or the title

Aye, you'll be right up there come January.

Then, as Benitez and Rodgers before him, Klopp will bottle it like a brewery and you'll fall tragically short. Cue much hilarity for all, Coutinho off overseas, and another year of 'rebuilding'

The saga continues <ok>
 
  • Like
Reactions: Peter Saxton
Aye, you'll be right up there come January.

Then, as Benitez and Rodgers before him, Klopp will bottle it like a brewery and you'll fall tragically short. Cue much hilarity for all, Coutinho off overseas, and another year of 'rebuilding'

The saga continues <ok>

And Van Gaal will be repeating his "judge me after 3 years" line