Unless the ball goes in the net within a couple of seconds, what is the advantage in not being awarded a penalty Mr Madley?
Rival watch
- Thread starter Spurlock
- Start date
-
Please bear with us on the new site integration and fixing any known bugs over the coming days. If you can not log in please try resetting your password and check your spam box. If you have tried these steps and are still struggling email [email protected] with your username/registered email address
-
Thousands of empty seats at Arsenal...maybe owners will start realising they need to.lowet ticket prices. Looks piss poor on tv and you can literally hear a pin drop.
Ref denies WBA a stonewall penalty to play advantage.
Ref gives arsenal a stonewall free kick on edge of penalty box even though arsenal had advantage.
The inconsistency from refs within a match is mind boggling.
Ref gives arsenal a stonewall free kick on edge of penalty box even though arsenal had advantage.
The inconsistency from refs within a match is mind boggling.
Now Alan smith is praising Ramsey for "staying on his feet" ... ignoring the fact that it was not a foul so in fact he was praising someone for not cheating 
1-0 HT. Arsenal incredibly lucky to go in ahead, in my opinion.
Although that level of incompetent officiating shows why most players don't bother. Madley's a terrible ref. It gave him an excuse to bottle giving a penalty to the away team.
I agree and it's outrageous that players have to 'act' to get the proper decision from the ref. We should be encouraging the kind of play Rodriquez (sp) displayed which is in the best traditions of the game. The penalty should have been awarded and the fact the player got up should be rewarded not penalised.
He's dreadful. Him and Antony Taylor do my crust in.
Truly Madley was Deeply Crap.
The authorities continue to bury their heads in the sand. Refs do decide games, it does not "even out over the course of a season". Unbelievable that the outcome of such a valuable commodity is decided subjectively.
All the ridiculous nonsense about how to implement the Video Assistant Referee is so much hot air. Mic the bloke up t the ref and linesman and whilst watching the live feed he just tells the ref when he's got major decisions wrong or the ref can ask him if there's a problem with a decision - penalties, bookings, sendings off, offside goals would seem to be the obvious ones.
The only issue would be that the VAR would not shut up when last night's idiot, Madley, is officiating. Still, last night's game was a farce and it was all down to him.
The WBA non-penalty shows how football could
learn from rugby union. In rugby, the ref lets play
continue beyond the infringement. If the player
scored, then job done. If not, then award the penalty.
Action against the infringing player (card etc) will
always happen regardless of which of the above
occurs.
All of the ref decision making would have happened
in 5 seconds max yesterday.
learn from rugby union. In rugby, the ref lets play
continue beyond the infringement. If the player
scored, then job done. If not, then award the penalty.
Action against the infringing player (card etc) will
always happen regardless of which of the above
occurs.
All of the ref decision making would have happened
in 5 seconds max yesterday.
