Off Topic Politics Thread

  • Please bear with us on the new site integration and fixing any known bugs over the coming days. If you can not log in please try resetting your password and check your spam box. If you have tried these steps and are still struggling email [email protected] with your username/registered email address
  • Log in now to remove adverts - no adverts at all to registered members!
Tony Robinson has quit the Labour Party after 45 years, citing “duplicity over Brexit, anti-semitism, and that Jeremy Corbyn has been “complete ****” as leader:
https://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/politics/tony-robinson-quit-labour-corbyn-a8898306.html

It's a shame because I think that Corbyn might do great things for the poor and disadvantaged members of society, in power, unfortunately I think that his appeal is too narrow for him to ever get elected as PM (a bit like Michael Foot in the 80s) and the left of centre vote is getting more split by the second.
 
Tony Robinson has quit the Labour Party after 45 years, citing “duplicity over Brexit, anti-semitism, and that Jeremy Corbyn has been “complete ****” as leader:
https://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/politics/tony-robinson-quit-labour-corbyn-a8898306.html


So rather than remain in the Labour Party and argue his corner (like Corbyn did for 30 odd years on the margins) he spits the dummy?

Forgive me if I put that down to a classic celebrity tantrum. Get over yourself, Tony.
 
How can anyone think that Boris Johnson would be fit to lead a political party and, God forbid, become Prime Minister, when he can’t stop telling really stupid lies?
He claimed to have voted Conservative, today, when there were no elections for him to vote at.
Seriously, what is genuinely wrong with people that admire and support him?

You must log in or register to see media
 
So rather than remain in the Labour Party and argue his corner (like Corbyn did for 30 odd years on the margins) he spits the dummy?

Forgive me if I put that down to a classic celebrity tantrum. Get over yourself, Tony.

I'd normally be inclined to agree, but this is something of a 'stand up and be counted' moment. The only way that Brexit gets put to pasture is if proceeding with Brexit becomes an existential threat both to the Conservative and Labour parties. And the only way that happens is if they both start hemorrhaging votes and members. I'm perfectly fine with members deserting/mutinying until someone there comes to their senses.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ChilcoSaint
How can anyone think that Boris Johnson would be fit to lead a political party and, God forbid, become Prime Minister, when he can’t stop telling really stupid lies?
He claimed to have voted Conservative, today, when there were no elections for him to vote at.
Seriously, what is genuinely wrong with people that admire and support him?

You must log in or register to see media

That assumes he is registered to vote in London!!!
 
You must log in or register to see images


You missed your calling as a spin doctor. Pick one constituency and weave a tale about what happened as though it's some kind of national point.

National results so far. Biggest gain by party most recognised as being pro Remain, the Lib Dems.

By the way, CUK/TIG isn't standing anywhere.

You must log in or register to see media

Vin

I didn't pick anything. You are posting here at 8 in the morning. I posted early morning when Sunderland was being talked about.

And the narrative here is of "remain parties making gains." Yes I voted Green. If there was no green I would have voted Lib Dem. Lots of other leavers have also. We voted for options that weren't the main 2 parties and with no "leave option" on most people's ballot then Lib Dem and Green were the only protest options.

So yes they will have attracted lots of people to them but they also were on the receiving end of a lot of protest votes.
 
I didn't pick anything. You are posting here at 8 in the morning. I posted early morning when Sunderland was being talked about.

And the narrative here is of "remain parties making gains." Yes I voted Green. If there was no green I would have voted Lib Dem. Lots of other leavers have also. We voted for options that weren't the main 2 parties and with no "leave option" on most people's ballot then Lib Dem and Green were the only protest options.

So yes they will have attracted lots of people to them but they also were on the receiving end of a lot of protest votes.


That doesn't make any sense at all.

But then, nothing in UK politics has, since 2016.
 
Voters flock to the Liberals and the Greens, both remained parties and Mrs May interprets results as being a message from the electorate to ensure Brexit happens.. Is it me, or is it logic that has flown out the window to join the pigs?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Ian Thumwood
I didn't pick anything. You are posting here at 8 in the morning. I posted early morning when Sunderland was being talked about.

And the narrative here is of "remain parties making gains." Yes I voted Green. If there was no green I would have voted Lib Dem. Lots of other leavers have also. We voted for options that weren't the main 2 parties and with no "leave option" on most people's ballot then Lib Dem and Green were the only protest options.

So yes they will have attracted lots of people to them but they also were on the receiving end of a lot of protest votes.
You obviously didn’t get the message that a lot of Brexiteers were spoiling their ballot papers by writing “Brexit” on them. You vote for something, you live with the consequences. That’s the way FPTP works, and until we get a proper voting system it always will.

The incontrovertible fact is that both Remain parties made massive gains, and both Brexit-supporting parties, particularly the Tories, made staggering losses. Only one conclusion can be drawn from that.
 
You obviously didn’t get the message that a lot of Brexiteers were spoiling their ballot papers by writing “Brexit” on them. You vote for something, you live with the consequences. That’s the way FPTP works, and until we get a proper voting system it always will.

The incontrovertible fact is that both Remain parties made massive gains, and both Brexit-supporting parties, particularly the Tories, made staggering losses. Only one conclusion can be drawn from that.

Yes, but what worries me is that May and Corbyn get together to agree a Brexit without anyone else being able to make an opinion. Then May resigns, the likes of Johnson/Rees-Mogg et al take over as leader, tear up the agreement and do the whole Tory hard Brexit thing. This MUST be stopped :emoticon-0121-angry:emoticon-0121-angry
 
Yes, but what worries me is that May and Corbyn get together to agree a Brexit without anyone else being able to make an opinion. Then May resigns, the likes of Johnson/Rees-Mogg et al take over as leader, tear up the agreement and do the whole Tory hard Brexit thing. This MUST be stopped :emoticon-0121-angry:emoticon-0121-angry
Whatever deal May and Corbyn lash up still has to get through Parliament. Emily Thornberry said yesterday that she thought any deal should go back to the people, not just one that the Tories try to push through on their own, so I think (hope) that a second referendum will be the price for getting it through. The only hope of passing a deal is to satisfy the opposition benches, as the ERG and most other Tories won’t vote for it.

*crosses fingers*
 
Yes, but what worries me is that May and Corbyn get together to agree a Brexit without anyone else being able to make an opinion. Then May resigns, the likes of Johnson/Rees-Mogg et al take over as leader, tear up the agreement and do the whole Tory hard Brexit thing. This MUST be stopped :emoticon-0121-angry:emoticon-0121-angry
I'm concerned to but no deal was voted down see https://www.bbc.com/news/uk-politics-47562995 . Anything May and Corbyn agree to has to get through parliament and be accepted by the EU 27.
 
I'm concerned to but no deal was voted down see https://www.bbc.com/news/uk-politics-47562995 . Anything May and Corbyn agree to has to get through parliament and be accepted by the EU 27.

The problem is that if a deal's agreed and both the Tories and Labour whip it through hard enough, they could get a majority.

It'll split the parties but (and I'm not joking) May has (apparently) told people she's regularly praying for guidance and think God wants her to deliver Brexit. So she won't care about splitting the parties. She's on a mission from God. And if you think that, you care about nothing else.

You must log in or register to see images


Vin
 
The problem is that if a deal's agreed and both the Tories and Labour whip it through hard enough, they could get a majority.

It'll split the parties but (and I'm not joking) May has (apparently) told people she's regularly praying for guidance and think God wants her to deliver Brexit. So she won't care about splitting the parties. She's on a mission from God. And if you think that, you care about nothing else.

You must log in or register to see images


Vin
There’s been enough defiance of whipping on both sides already in the Brexit saga, I just can’t see enough Labour MP’s voting for a May-Corbyn deal, and certainly not enough Tories. Not without a second ref as a sweetener, anyway.