Player Ratings So Far Tthis Season

Harper - 7 - He's been decent despite the fact he has cost us a few points this season.
Coloccini - 8 - Solid and rarely makes a mistake , scores the odd goal as well. What a turn around after a **** first season in England.
Enrique - 9 - Solid as a ****ing rock.
Nolan - 9,5 - My player of the season so far , been committed ever since we went down and has captained the team in excellent fashion , a character Arsenal wish they had. And scored plenty of goals including 3 against the mackems!
Campbell - 4 - Had one good game against Chelsea but the rest was ****.
Williamson - 6,5 - Would be a good back up in my opinion but still don't feel very comfortable with him in defense.
Barton - 8 - Had the odd **** game but been class for the rest of them. Would have been a 9 if it wasn't for him punching Pedersen.
Guthrie - 3 - Perhaps hasn't played enough but in the matches he did play in , he was poor. West Brom away was one of the worst individual performances ever recorded.
Lovenkrands - 6 - Has shown he can score goals but think he's past it now. Getting too old and doesn't take advantage of his pace , not strong enough , but scored 2 good goals against West Brom and Birmingham.
Simpson - 7 - Good player, can only get better!!
Perch - 4,5 - Unsure and unassertive when playing. Would be an excellent championship player.
R Taylor - 5 - Really disappointed me and never takes opportunities presented to him. Silly red card against Bolton.
Smith - 5 - Admire his determination but gets too many yellow cards and can't pass or finish.
Jonas - 8 - Has massively improved this season. He used to get past defenders with his excellent dribbling skills but then delivered a **** cross. This has really improved now and this was demonstrated Birmingham away.
Best - 7 - Done OK for a first season in the premier league.
Ameobi - 7 - Would have been a 5 if it wasn't for his 2 goals against the Albanians in the demolition derby.
Tiote - 9 - Fantastic , would give him 9,5 if it wasn't for his 10 yellows already.
Krul - 6 - Needs to work on his kicking but great when it comes to reflex saves. ****ed up big time against Man City.
S Taylor - 5,5 - Should have knocked Amy's teeth out.
Ranger - 6,5 - When starting plays terrible , as a substitute he's done brilliant. ****ing lazy as ****.
Amy - 0 - He can **** off and die.
Routledge - 5 - Not physically fit to play in the top flight and can't whip in a proper cross to save his life.

 

Harper - 7 - Done good. Nothing outstanding but he's done his job in a professional and respectable manner.
Coloccini - 8 - He's been great! Strong performer most of the times and looks completely changed from the ''Clown'' Colo of 08-09.
Enrique - 8 - Consistent and strong performer. He's been outstanding. I really hope he stays, he'll be key to our future success.
Nolan - 8 - Not his biggest fan but his goals, leadership and experience have been key and vital to our success this season.
Campbell - Past it. His display against Stoke was nothing short of dreadful.
Williamson - 7 - Solid performer but think we could improve in this area. He looked class in the Championship but doesn't look that great in the PL IMO. He's OK but think we could do better.
Barton - 9 - Quality! Key player in our starting line-up. Consistent and a mostly strong performer. His work-rate, his set-piece delivery, his passing and his crossing ability have been very, very, very useful indeed.
Guthrie - 5 - Injuries/competition for places have ruined his season back in the PL. I thought he looked OK in our 08-09 season and looked quality in the Championship but this season's been pretty much hit(performances against Spurs and Sunderland) and miss(Awful displays against Wigan/West Brom).
Lovenkrands - 4 - Past it. He looked OK back in our relegation season and was great in the Championship but this season he's been horribly average. He's a hard-worker but I'm not sure the PL suits his style of play. Better in a more technical league were he'll have more time and space with the ball.
Simpson - 7 - He's been quite consistent with good strong performances. Can only improve next season.
Perch - 3 - Simply not good enough for the PL. Decent Championship versatile squad player.
R Taylor - 5 - Poor mans' Barton IMO. Hard-worker, good crosser and set-piece specialist but unfortunately if the right bid comes in then we should cash on him. I wouldn't mind him as cover next season but I'm not sure he'll like being cover for too long. Average in the PL but looks very good in the Championship. He's that sort of player.
Smith - 5 - Past it. His best years have gone and I think he's a average DM who yes does give a lot in terms of work-rate, strength, attitude and off the field apparently he's a influence but that unfortunately doesn't make him a top player(he used to be) but IMO this summer will be his last with NUFC.
Jonas - 7 - He's been good this season. He's inconsistent but he offers a lot to the team(defensively, dribbling ability, link-up with Enrique, relives pressure of the team with his ''Messi-esque'' runs and is a very hard-worker), OK he isn't the greatest of crossers, lacks a final ball at times and sometimes does a bit too much ''fancy'' stuff for my liking but he's been good, not great but good.
Best - 7 - He's been good since Carroll left. OK he isn't exactly top-class/top-quality but he's proven IMO that he can cope at this level even if he's reduced to being 3rd choice next season. He'll be good cover/competition for whatever 1/2 strikers we buy.
Ameobi - 4 - Not top-quality but he's been OK in general although I don't particularly rate him nor like him(as a player) he's always useful against the Mackems but lacks consistency and is injury-prone. Sell in the summer IMO.
Tiote - 9 - Absolutely brilliant! What a full debut season in the PL! Can only get better season by season and we hope next season he will be the MAN!
Krul - 6 - Potentially can become a very good 'keeper. Currently good enough as back-up although I'm still undecided on who should be the future No.1 out of Krul and Forster but Krul edges it currently IMO because of his PL experience.
S Taylor - 6 - He's been OK, nothing outstanding or nothing to really shout about apart from that horror show that he produced playing as a full-back against Everton, got ripped to pieces by Arteta!
Ranger - 6 - Needs to improve his finishing but has bags of potential. One for the future IMO but always useful as a impact sub.

 

Cheers 4 the cum back

Yeah I agree with your points

Williamson is not too consistent and I am hoping Stevie Taylor can step up next season and return to his best, if he cant then we defo need another centre back!

Harper is an average Prem keeper and at th moment so is Krul and Forster. In the future, I think Krul will be the boy!

If we can hold on to Tiote, Enrique, Joey then add 2 strikers plus 3 or 4 others we will be mint next year