Our loan players

[Nacho]

For what it's worth I think both Simms and Amad are good players that we should keep.

Amad looks quality to me and is probably the fastest player at the club, unfortunately in the games he's played (that I've seen) we haven't taken advantage of that. Simms I think is a natural goalscorer and will get plenty if he gets a run in the team, first touch not always great but that could be part of settling in.

 

[Sunderpitt]

Personally I would have to give Diallo and Simms more game time before I could pronounce a hit or a miss.

However Dajaku... he has had time and in my view he is a miss. Diamond is better.

Roberts undoubtedly very skilful and scored a good couple of goals a few games ago. BUT very inconsistent whereas Clarke does more often than not deliver. Also Bennette seems to be a gem.

I recall Mowbray saying that Roberts was brilliant, but not often enough (or words to that effect)

 

[smithy in nl]

Personally I would have to give Diallo and Simms more game time before I could pronounce a hit or a miss.

However Dajaku... he has had time and in my view he is a miss. Diamond is better.

Roberts undoubtedly very skilful and scored a good couple of goals a few games ago. BUT very inconsistent whereas Clarke does more often than not deliver. Also Bennette seems to be a gem.

I recall Mowbray saying that Roberts was brilliant, but not often enough (or words to that effect)

Don’t agree with djaku mate I think he’s a real Tallent and will show his worth when he gets a steady run in the team.

 

[Mackem 10.1]

These loan players have been here 5 mins and people are judging them. Would love to have seen the comments on Broadhead at this time last season

This, Simms looked decent before he got injured, diallo hasnt really played many games. Some people right players off far too early