Our Best 11 ?

[The Little General]

Evening Lads and Lasses,
We're heading towards a fully fit squad, whats your best team, given they are all match fit, and where would you look to improve n January ?
Mine-
McLaughlin

Matthews
Baldwin
Flanagan
James

Gooch
Power
Honeyman

Watmore
Wyke
McGeady

Merry Xmas to all, its so nice to have our Club back .
Another centre back in January would do for me.

 

[Nacho]

McLaughlin

Matthews Flanagan Baldwin Hume

Power Honeyman

Gooch Maguire Watmore

Maja

In terms of the transfer window we need cover for CB and I'm concerned that Wyke is going to be a sicknote. That was his reputation before we signed him and he's barely played for us so he's lived up to it. It seems like a long shot to count on him playing regularly and I think we need to assume he won't.

 

[cumbrianmackem]

Difficult one this...Hume, Love and Robson I don't think we'll see much off before March.
Keeper picks himself and so does the back four.
Will Oviedo go in the January window along with Catts?
There's going to be some disappointed players when they are all back.
I had high hopes for Wyke, but shame about his fitness record however in his defence the tackle that injured him was a red card all day if it had been an outfield player but that Keeper got away with it.
I'd persevere with young Maja even when Wyke returns but it's midfield that were strong numbers wise.
Jack Ross has got his work cut out in the next few weeks but it's a nice problem to have.

 

[clockstander]

We are stronger in midfield than at the back, numbers wise. JR's main task in the window is to add some balance here imo, the versatility of players like O'nien, Maguire and fingers crossed Watmore and Wyke coming back guns blazing, help out up front, so we might get away with the squad that we have now. Picking our best eleven is a tough ask, have we or any other club ever had the luxury of a fully fit squad, I doubt it, ideally you need two players for each position and a manager who can think on his feet, we are not that far away tbh. Interesting times ahead.

 

[Vincemac]

Posted this before

You must log in or register to see images

It’s a difficult one I can’t pick it
Leave it to ross

 

[Saf]

--------------------- McLaughlin ---------------------

Matthews - Flanagan - Baldwin - Oviedo

-------------- McGeough --- Power --------------

-- Watmore --------- McGuire ------ Gooch --

----------------------------- Maja ---------------------


I still think McGeough will come good for us.

 

[Vincemac]

--------------------- McLaughlin ---------------------

Matthews - Flanagan - Baldwin - Oviedo

-------------- McGeough --- Power --------------

-- Watmore --------- McGuire ------ Gooch --

----------------------------- Maja ---------------------


I still think McGeough will come good for us.

That’s how difficult it is
No Mcgeady and he’s storming this league

 

[Jack TheLad]

On what basis do people think Wyke should be above Maja in the pecking order?

Wyke has been injured all season and Maja has scored 11 and assisted 2 goals and its only just December.

 

[cumbrianmackem]

On what basis do people think Wyke should be above Maja in the pecking order?

Wyke has been injured all season and Maja has scored 11 and assisted 2 goals and its only just December.

I had high hopes for Wyke but as the season has panned out I now see him as an ideal sub for young Maja.
Save Majas legs later in games, bringing a big lad on gives the team another dimension and he should be raring to go as well.
Wyke and Watmore getting 20 a game should tear up this league when the opposition is tiring.
I certainly wouldn't drop Maja for Wyke, I have had my doubts about his overall workrate but he deserves to stay in the team because of his goals.
just a thought.

 

[marcusblackcat]

--------------------- McLaughlin ---------------------

Matthews - Flanagan - Baldwin - Oviedo

-------------- McGeough --- Power --------------

-- Watmore --------- McGuire ------ Gooch --

----------------------------- Maja ---------------------


I still think McGeough will come good for us.

I have more hope than expectation about him - have seen so little to convince me so far sadly.

Cattermole is in our best 11 instead at the minute. Hume, IMO, is the best LB at the club but, sadly, got that injury. James is better than Oviedo defensively but Oviedo much better going forward.

Have to say it's nice to have these problems picking a best 11! Means we have options. Maja has hit a bit of a wall recently but still our best first choice striker from what I've seen.

I'd go mostly with yours but change like below:

--------------------- McLaughlin ---------------------

Matthews - Flanagan - Baldwin - James

-------------- Cattermole --- Power --------------

-- Gooch------------ McGuire ------ McGeady--

----------------------------- Maja ---------------------

 

[clockstander]

I have more hope than expectation about him - have seen so little to convince me so far sadly.

Cattermole is in our best 11 instead at the minute. Hume, IMO, is the best LB at the club but, sadly, got that injury. James is better than Oviedo defensively but Oviedo much better going forward.

Have to say it's nice to have these problems picking a best 11! Means we have options. Maja has hit a bit of a wall recently but still our best first choice striker from what I've seen.

I'd go mostly with yours but change like below:

--------------------- McLaughlin ---------------------

Matthews - Flanagan - Baldwin - James

-------------- Cattermole --- Power --------------

-- Gooch------------ McGuire ------ McGeady--

----------------------------- Maja ---------------------

No Honeyman, in this team, I rate him but thats just my opinion, your team looks a good one and it would be interesting to see it in action. Looking ahead I would like to see Robson, Mumba, Honeyman and Embleton form a midfield, all are capable imo. it just goes to show how strong we are in midfield which augurs well for the club and its future. We are certainly managing without stars like McNair and Rodders.

 

[Saf]

I have more hope than expectation about him - have seen so little to convince me so far sadly.

Cattermole is in our best 11 instead at the minute. Hume, IMO, is the best LB at the club but, sadly, got that injury. James is better than Oviedo defensively but Oviedo much better going forward.

Have to say it's nice to have these problems picking a best 11! Means we have options. Maja has hit a bit of a wall recently but still our best first choice striker from what I've seen.

I'd go mostly with yours but change like below:

--------------------- McLaughlin ---------------------

Matthews - Flanagan - Baldwin - James

-------------- Cattermole --- Power --------------

-- Gooch------------ McGuire ------ McGeady--

----------------------------- Maja ---------------------

No Watmore? I can't have McGeady in the team, I think he's got a **** attitude and bit of a lazy bastard.

I've seen James 3 times this season, twice he's been bang average and once he was poor (Peterborough)

I love, Gooch. He's really won me around this season.

 

[Gordon Armstrong]

For me the back five picks itself, and I'd have young Reece in ahead of Oviedo for continuity and a settled back four who seem to 'know' each other now.

Catts and Power is a 'no-brainer' 'cos Catts has undoubtedly been our best midfielder so far this season and Max has 'class' that will show when he settles. I, too, think that McGeouch will 'come good' but he's not my first choice there.

Assuming that we'd use the formation shown in the earlier posts, Goochy Coochy Coo and Ginger Dunc (an unknown at this stage, so I'm going from history) with their energy/reliability either side of Maguire (who has similar 'class' to Power) would be very effective. Vince mentioned McGeady 'storming the league' but he's inconsistent and would be more effective as an impact sub. (unless he shows more consistency (and reliability) in which case I'd play him ahead of Dunc. and switch Goochy to the right with him on the left.

Maja, as far as we know, is a far greater threat than Charlie Boy ('cos we haven't really seen him), who would (I think) be another blinking good option from the bench.

We've got a few good options from the bench, at this level, I think, so the squad doesn't need much tinkering.

My first team choice . . . .

--------------------- McLaughlin ---------------------
Matthews - Flanagan - Baldwin - James
-------------- Cattermole --- Power --------------
-- Dunc------------ Maguire ----------- Gooch--
------------------------ Maja --------------------------

January . . . . I'd look to bring in at least one centre half, 'cos Micky and Mike above, although settled, aren't solid, Loovens is decent but relatively old, and Ozturk . . . . well is an appropriate description, I think.

Midfield is definitely okay, and I'd like another 'proper' centre forward that can fill a void on the pitch rather than in the treatment room, 'cos I'm worried about Charlie Boy's long term fitness.

That's my view

 

[marcusblackcat]

No Honeyman, in this team, I rate him but thats just my opinion, your team looks a good one and it would be interesting to see it in action. Looking ahead I would like to see Robson, Mumba, Honeyman and Embleton form a midfield, all are capable imo. it just goes to show how strong we are in midfield which augurs well for the club and its future. We are certainly managing without stars like McNair and Rodders.

I think that's just it! We have players capable of doing the jobs when others aren't available. Good position to be in without a doubt! Have to say I forgot about Honeyman - he might be one that gets under my radar as I haven't been that impressed with him this season so far - not sure he should be captain (Power is better at that IMO) Just goes to show how different people can see things so differently - but, as you say, how strong we are - still haven't seen anything to make me rate Robson consistently! He's only had one good first team game (and, as a person, is a bit of a dickhead too after the way I saw him have a go at my Dad - that may cloud my judgement form wise!)

 

[marcusblackcat]

No Watmore? I can't have McGeady in the team, I think he's got a **** attitude and bit of a lazy bastard.

I've seen James 3 times this season, twice he's been bang average and once he was poor (Peterborough)

I love, Gooch. He's really won me around this season.

Only reason I've left Watmore out is as I've seen him play 62 minutes in 2 years! He looked decent enough against a low league side. Watmore that we had before his injuries - I'd absolutely have him starting. McGeady on current form - he's been outstanding recently!

I quite like James to be honest (he was rubbish against Peterborough mind) but he's won me over of late