OT: Mafia game thread starts Sunday 8pm 14/9/14

.

 

TBF, you're not helping yourself with that one!

 

The town investigator has cleared me. Im just simple simon working as a bartender in the sleaziest joint in town. Happy with tips and the odd blowy off drunk skangers. No more no less.

Speaking of which anybody seen minxy today ?

 

Unless the snitch picked on you too of course

 

The town investigator according to him.. Just after he came under suspicion...

Which for me makes the both of you suspicious!

 

Yeah I made a silly move with the best of intentions, but I've been honest and explained everything I've done, as I'm doing it.

It made me an easy target for the mafia IMO

 

I think Sky is the vigilante and I reckon he will strike a certain person tonight. Depending on how the voting goes, we should find out later

 

You also just put a theory together that was completely undone in the opening line because you associated something to the wrong!

 

Yeah it might be worth keeping him alive for another night to see how it plays out... Still not convinced he is a towns person rather than mafia though..

 

It doesn't help that you keep accusing/speculating that most players are mafia. That makes you look extremely suspicious.

 

Isn't a vigilante classed as neither...

 

IBWT... You've definitely been the most vocal defender of Astro! If Astro end up guilty - you know you'll be added to the suspect list now too!
Not saying you are... just pointing out...

Of course if Astro ends up innocent it means you're probably innocent too- because I don't believe Mafia would try to save a guaranteed innocent death.

This is my thought too... I'm thinking DR in last game did something to make himself stand out as guilty and everyone thought he was. Astro remains a leading suspect and can't be ignored- but it's important everyone keeps their mind open.

You did something that made everyone think you are guilty. Changing votes at the last second is a very suspicious thing to do! If you're town- that's a bad tactic!

Unless he is distancing and going to change his vote later. If Astro looked like he was definitely out it would probably be good tactics, even if Mafia, to jump on the bandwagon.

No one got converted. There are three tactics Mafia might try when converting at night:
1) Look for a player they think will help them the most.
2) Look for a player that nobody suspects - someone going under the radar.
3) I had a number three but I've forgotten it... oh yeah, convert a town role. If Sky or Magic really are town roles- they might try and convert them tonight because that would eliminate a town role.

Yes. He said he would announce if conversion took place.

Unless we can assure that Sky is innocent- then we can't presume anything about Hash. If we can prove Sky is innocent then that would make Hash innocent.

 

Yeah I mixed up magic and skylarker who both reared there heads at the same time and both made a claim to have an important role for us. I got them confused earlier in the thread and had to ask which one it was who spoke about Hash and then I bloody did the same thing and used magic instead of sky!

But if sky knew hash was innocent then sky can't be the vigilante, he would have to be the investigator. Or he lied about hash being innocent..

 

This! However, it is also too obvious so if he is mafia, he's trying to deflect attention from elsewhere IMO. Otherwise, he's just being very naive.

 

Without having any accusation thrown at them people can sit quietly and avoid any suspicion... People generally jump in to defend themselves when accused and that gives an opportunity to find information, for them to slip up.

The more you post, the more chance you look suspicious, I'm quite happy to post a lot and a use people based on there actions to see if it gets a reaction!

 

Surely the vigilante has to be a towns person, as being a vigilante is to take the law into your own hands, which would mean trying to stop the mafia.

 

Correct. However, Nozzer nor myself suggested otherwise, we were merely pointing out what afc was saying was incorrect

 

Vigilante definitely isn't mafia but taking the law into your own hands would suggest not being part of the town too, surely?


Edit: from OP...

The vigilante (on town team)

That answers that then

 

Milk I've said I'm suspicious of Astro. Him afc and magic were my 3 to keep an eye on after last round. Only reason Astro is least fav atm was because he was consistent in what he was saying at the start of this game and from how he approached the last game.

Could very well be a double bluff as you say though and he's actually mafia. If Bodanki and afc are innocent then is assume Astro is innocent otherwise why make yourself seem so obviously a mafia? Only Bodanki and afc really know of they are innocent which is why I'm curious to see how they vote as well.

Magic just looks so suspicious with his inactivity then appearing just after, almost like he tried to get on to convert kill but was 2 minutes too late

 

I'm just trying to stay involved, question everyone and everything... It's paranoia being brought on by this game

There are four mafia and I know I'm not one of them which makes me a very easy target, so I'd rather see if I can flush anyone out while I can as I expect I won't last more than a day or two!