OT: Mafia game thread starts Sunday 8pm 14/9/14

I've not voted for Milk, but I'm defending myself because Milk seems to be naming me as the don (not even just mafia) based on nothing but a random late change during yesterday confusion started by you

Milk however keeps pointing fingers at 5 others (claiming everyone knows he's innocent despite that not being 100% accurate due to snitch potentially protecting or him being converted). While also seeming to suggest that even if Billy goes and is innocent he thinks afc is innocent despite AFC having been near enough responsible for RHC, Hash & Billy then going?!

 

I'm leaving work now so won't be on for a little while...

 

That's because you are the least active of the Mafia... besides Lucaaas. Or can you point to one of your teammates who has been less active...

 

You've been working?

 

Ssssh...you'll get yourself shot with talk like that

 

How was AFC responsible for Hash? How do you know AFC was responsible for Hash? Why are you including Billy in that list... Billy isn't dead yet... and we don't know he is innocent yet?

Aren't you jumping the gun?

 

Bit suspicious isn't it. Milk is adamant afc is innocent even if you go and he would have been responsible for 3 people going and all 3 innocents

 

don't take my quote out of ****ing context


Milk you've just got sneaky batard written all over you.

And Hash named him on his death bed.
AFC changed his vote to protect Bod last minute to kill RHC claiming he knew he was guilty... oh he turned out innocent as well.

 

No... but if you go... and turn out guilty- I'm going to be a little suspicious of AFC now.

 

Isn't he just talking through options? Not dismissing things that are still possible? We don't know AFC was responsible for Hash but we do know Hash voted for him and suspected him due to his early vote rigging/discussions (as bad a crime as any I've been accused of no?). Not sure it's massively relevant on its own but taken in context of him gunning for me (and having a firm ally following his lead) it suggests he might be worth looking at rather than you just dismissing him as having nothing against him.

He's including me as we've been discussing me being the sacrificial lamb (which I've said since this morning I'm happy to be....but not if you then ignore the evidence in front of you )

 

But how is RHC responsible for Hash?
Hash may have pointed his finger at AFC but how is AFC responsible for killing him?

 

Honestly I think AFC would make a FANTASTIC target for the cops to look at tonight.

His actions are too erratic to judge on what he says and does- I think the only way we'll figure him out is through killing him or investigating him. I'm not convinced enough of him to say we should lynch him- but at the same time, I don't think we can hope to catch him out by his actions.

 

RHC isn't responsible for Hash.

RHC was killed day 1

Milk, you afc and possilbly Bod need to go to pm, get your story straight and come back

 

Sorry... AFC... you know what I mean. How is AFC responsible for Hash? Hash fingered him (dirty Hash... ) - but I don't think AFC even voted for him.

 

Milk, just going to ignore where you've completely taken my quote out of context to make it seem like I'm saying Billy is already gone and make it seem like I know something?

 

I've got no idea what you're on about anymore...

 

You're completely ignoring the point. You say AFC is responsible for Hash's death. How is AFC responsible for Hash's death. You blame him for RHC, Hash, and Billy.

RHC, maybe. Hash, how?!?!?! Billy isn't dead yet and not confirmed innocent yet- yet you're blaming him for his death. You actually placed the 2nd vote on Billy and made him the leading candidate. How can that be AFC's fault if Billy dies and is innocent?

And if you think Billy is innocent, why is your vote on him?

 

Hash fingered him on his death (and if he's mafia probably had a say in killing off Hash).

I'm not blaming him for Billy's death, but he has been pretty insitant that Billy is mafia and if Billy goes and is innocent, you were denying any real chance that he could be mafia despite other pretty much saying 1 of Billy/AFC are mafia due to how they are going against each other so much.

 

Hash had no more clue than the rest of us... he had no special role. We've all thought AFC is guilty at one point... I had him in the Bodanki triangle. I'm not convinced he is innocent- but I don't think he is one of the major candidates for being guilty.

It's very common for townfolk to be at each others throats because they don't know who is guilty. I'm not ruling out completely Billy or AFC- but I don't really see a case for either of them.

 

I'm as good as dead though I'm pretty sure IBWT wasnt saying anything of the sort for definite. Just questioning why you aren't even willing to consider AFC has more to him than just a few revenge votes?