I don’t quite see how the Alcarez situation equates. Unless I’m in the wrong circles that’s widely seen as quite a negative decision by the club, especially considering the current form it’s arguable letting Alcarez go is looking a stupider mistake with each passing week.
As for the squad in my opinion it’s all one of those ‘on paper’ things. Yes on paper the squad is full of good players. There was absolutely no reason to believe though that they could gel together, plenty of squads over the years have shown that a bunch of good players mean nothing. Some argued our squad last season was a bunch of good players too and look how that turned out.
All I’m saying is if these players, some of which had shown last year that they’d happily down tools if they didn’t like a managers playing style, didn’t like RM and just continued playing the way we did post Sunderland 5-0, the scenario of us being wildly inconsistent isn’t unrealistic. It would have been a bad season sure, but I don’t think it was a unforseeable problem.