I can find disagree with most of that, Fosse. But Sky has a point, banning the guy is a bit like taking a sledgehammer to a nut.
In my view, all that was necessary was to remove the thread, and send the guy a P.M. Explaining why and warning him about any repeats of that kind of post.
There was no need to castigate the guy in public, and then ban him. It should have been handled with a bit more subtlety.
I have some sympathy with your view NSIS ... but the thread had been reported (I have no idea of by whom) and so a Supermod had to investigate and act upon the reporting accordingly / as appropriate ...
.... but HIAG wouldn't / couldn't let it go and, in the event, taunted the Supermod into banning him ...he has trodden a fine line on similar issues previously yet, bizarrely, has demanded bans for other posters for things that are completely innocuous in comparison .. if Resurgam hadn't granted his wish you and I both know that HIAG would have kept on spitralling the issue ad nauseum because his 'fun' had been curtailed ...
.... he'll no doubt do it on his return mind

You lot don't half get precious.
.