Young got worse and worse as the season went on unfortunatley. He started well and initially looked much better than Orr and was proving to be a great buy. But as time went on he was at fault for a number of goals, as Flyer said - he didnt close the crosses down well enough. But I would keep him as reserve imo. When on form he can still cut it.
Good squad player who can cover both full back positions - also played at the top of the english league for some time (we dont have many of them) so offers good experience. I would be happy if he stayed, but if he does go I will be expecting better quality coming in. I can recall plenty of good performances and also a few shockers, but on the whole I believe he offers something and should be retained...I guess it all depends on who is being lined up to replace him?