Let’s not forget that the Premier League is arguably the hardest division in world football for a promoted team to try and build on-pitch partnerships.
Our recent success was roughly built the year before we got promoted from League One, when the likes of Morsy, Chaplin, and Burns came in. Building a winning team in League One is a lot easier and more forgiving than trying it in the top flight. Even when we got promoted back to the Championship, there wasn’t a massive amount of transfer activity - other than clever loan signings to plug squad gaps.
The issue is going to be what we achieve next season in the Championship. If it’s a team that is hungry to return and is so packed with top-end Championship talent that we can beat most teams - we’ll likely return to the Premier League as a better side than the one that went up last season. If we can’t, and this season has damaged the squad mentally, McKenna’s unable to get his tactics right, and we don’t recapture that team spirit from last season - we’re going to be in for an underwhelming season.
You make a very good point and let's remember it took quite a while before all those new signings we made in league 1, 19 if I remember correctly actually resembled anything looking like a team. Which is probably why I felt Cook should've been given more time (what do I know). McKenna came in and solidified the defence but results didn't dramatically improve and whilst we had a decent start to the next season we looked 1 dimensional, it wasn't until Luongo, Hirst and Broadhead came into the team that we really started to look the business. That's a year and a half after all those new signings.
It has been a real challenge managing this change and progression in the most challenging league in the world added to a big injury list. Has the balance been as good as it could have been this season arguably not. Whilst I think we would have struggled no matter what this season I feel some of our Championship team have been dropped after some good performances (Broadhead, Hirst, Chaplin, Woolfenden, Burgess) and showed far better connections than the new players. I feel McKenna could have implemented change far more gradually (as he did the previous 2 seasons).
Our style of play has also been somewhat mixed. I hate hearing from the commentators that we needed to change our style, in my mind we have, we play quite differently from how we did last season and in league 1 our style has progressed under McKenna, from in league 1 initially solidifying ourselves defensively, to dominating possession, to being absolutely ruthless in attack being gung-ho. The signings of Luongo, Hirst and Broadhead changed how we played we went from a team who just passed and passed to a team who could score all sorts of goals, including on the counter and more direct. We took that into the Champ with our possession stats dropping but had enough about us to cling on in games and had enough attacking quality to score goals and also crucially enough energy and quality to come off the bench to make a difference at the end of games (something due to injuries we haven't really had this season and something we've seen opposition teams capitalise on).
It was clear McKenna got the absolute max out of those players last season and also for me the system we played. It was clear we needed to strengthen mainly because we got rid of a load of players who were on the periphery last season and you're not going to bring in 'back ups'.
It was clear to me we needed to adapt the way we played from last season, we played on the very edge, we had quality but McKenna took a lot of risks with how we played and that meant we scored a lot but also conceded a lot. Particularly in the central midfield and full back positions due to the formation we played and asks of the players there's a lot of space and we were often overrun. I felt this needed looking at and we probably needed to bring another body and play 3 in midfield playing either a 433 or 532 formation but we've kept the double pivot and 4 real attacking players on the pitch for most of the season. In some games we've gone quite defensive and tried (with some success) to rely on Delap and Omari doing everything themselves which is a change from how we've attacked the past couple of seasons. We've gone from playing quick 1 touch football in attacking positions to a load of ball carrying players who run from deeper positions. I feel this is where we could've been more balanced, we probably should've sured up the midfield so that we weren't so often outnumbered in midfield, so we could keep hold of the ball better but not one in which were very defensively plus still try to keep some of the patterns of play we had. We seem to have got a mix this season between trying to play the same formation as we did last season which inevitably has exposed us in midfield and fullback positions or tried to sit too deep in a 5 at the back and if Delap hasn't been on his game had nothing up top.
Next season I think we could comfortably play the formation we're used to but I'd like to see us maybe adapt with a view that if we do get promoted again we're more secure in midfield areas.