Jay-Emmanuel Thomas signs
- Thread starter Geneva Rs
- Start date
-
Please bear with us on the new site integration and fixing any known bugs over the coming days. If you can not log in please try resetting your password and check your spam box. If you have tried these steps and are still struggling email [email protected] with your username/registered email address
-
Watford i think the problem is, that we have gone from buying old names on big wages to lower league players on low wages. There is no in-between. So far all 3 signings have been League One players. Chances are we will lose Charlie/Phillips/Fer and we need players with more experience. I will support these players but remember we are taking a risk with Ramsey and now we are taking a risk on players. I hope it all works out because i don't want to be back here in 12 months saying 'i told you so"
I can sort of see where you're coming from but there's a chronic lack of youth in the squad which they're clearly trying to address. These are all highly rated players from clubs at the top of League 1 last season. They're exactly the sort of signings we used to pride ourselves on making- players we can develop and profit from. For me, that's better than signing a guy who looks ok in most Championship teams.
Although we signed Karl Henry from Wolves when they were in League 1 and played him in the Championship & Premier League where he performed his DCM role adequately.
It all comes down to what the management are trying to do.
They must have a good idea of how they want the team to play and are looking for players to fill those rolls. It's all about the mix.
I think that they want to build a solid team, not build a team around a couple of stand-out players.
It will be interesting to see what CR can get out of JET. It crossed my mind that maybe a black manager could get more out of him - and there are precious few of those around.
They must have a good idea of how they want the team to play and are looking for players to fill those rolls. It's all about the mix.
I think that they want to build a solid team, not build a team around a couple of stand-out players.
It will be interesting to see what CR can get out of JET. It crossed my mind that maybe a black manager could get more out of him - and there are precious few of those around.
I'm not tying to be provocative Eamon but I'm not sure I understand why black players would respond better to a black manager.
Interesting signing. Will be a good squad player who needs to prove he can make it back up the leagues. Should do good in the championship if he puts in the work rate (that's where the coaching will be so important from CR).
Agree with Eamon, we have to find a balance of up and coming youth and experienced quality first teasers. We do still need the likes of Fer and Phillips as well as a quality replacement for Charlie; and we are desperate for some quality CB's. If we don't have a solid defensive back four it will be another difficult season
Agree with Eamon, we have to find a balance of up and coming youth and experienced quality first teasers. We do still need the likes of Fer and Phillips as well as a quality replacement for Charlie; and we are desperate for some quality CB's. If we don't have a solid defensive back four it will be another difficult season
We moan when we sign players who want a last big pay packet and give nothing in return. Now we are cutting back and signing young players on less money we moan again. Judge them on their performances once with have built a squad.
Proper test for CR then. If he's a good player who doesn't apply himself, CR needs to work on his application. We'll see.
They've been losing money, vast amounts of it, on QPR since 2011. They've just decided not to throw any more away on a strategy which failed and would have bankrupted them and the club had they not been so loaded in the first place.
Be patient.
Hope he is more Ray Jones than Rob Hulse. Big striker, versatile, decent in the air, young......worth a punt I say.
I just hope that they are not throwing away less money on a different which will fail also.
Rob Hulse-blast from the past, that. Chris is a man with a plan.
Isn't that what we wanted? Young, hungry players with potential?
If he's as good a coach as people(very many in the game) say, then lets see what happens.
Whatever it is, its gonna be better than Redknapp's.
The Swindon players were/are top players from a team that almost got promoted.
JET has still got a good strike recofrom limited starts and from coming off the bench...Go to the Bristol forums, that are sad to see him go. That says a lot.
I can remember saying all of this about Charlie Austin...is he really good enough to spearhead a promotion team? Can he score in the Premiership?
Answer was yes
So some of these players will step up, a few may not...
We have to be patient as Stan says.
I am not looking to come straight up.
I am looking for strong stability this season and building towards a youngish team that will take us up and keep us there.
JET has still got a good strike recofrom limited starts and from coming off the bench...Go to the Bristol forums, that are sad to see him go. That says a lot.
I can remember saying all of this about Charlie Austin...is he really good enough to spearhead a promotion team? Can he score in the Premiership?
Answer was yes
So some of these players will step up, a few may not...
We have to be patient as Stan says.
I am not looking to come straight up.
I am looking for strong stability this season and building towards a youngish team that will take us up and keep us there.
Not quite sure why people are complaining, Les stated they wanted to go back to bringing players through from lower leagues\teams not from above, some will succeed some will fail that's the process.
I wish him all the best and hope he is a success, he definitely does have potential and if CR thinks he can develop him, I say welcome on board.
I wish him all the best and hope he is a success, he definitely does have potential and if CR thinks he can develop him, I say welcome on board.
That is a very fair point Kilburn, and one I can't disagree with.
Welcome to the club JET look like decent player from the youtube vids. The transfer window is much better without Arry shouting off his mouth before players have even signed well done CR and co.
You must log in or register to see media
Looking forward to seeing him in the hoops. Low risk-High Potential, hoping he turns into one of those players that you look forward to seeing on the team sheet. A good squad player at worst
Stupid question and trying to put someone on the spot. Very difficult to answer without offending anyone.
Last edited:
Thought it was quite a fair question to be honest. We can discuss race without causing offence, can't we?