January transfer thread

  • Please bear with us on the new site integration and fixing any known bugs over the coming days. If you can not log in please try resetting your password and check your spam box. If you have tried these steps and are still struggling email [email protected] with your username/registered email address
  • Log in now to remove adverts - no adverts at all to registered members!
Southern A

Southern A

Well-Known Member
Aug 18, 2020
21,441
30,724
113
Not sure if we have this yet but seems a decent time to start one now we are in December?

Anyway first main rumour is Nixon (I know I know) saying we are after an experienced midfielder tonight.

Whilst he’s probably guessing (he usually is when he doesn’t name specifics), it would make some sense. I think Ba, Michut and Matete will all be top players but I’d be wanting to loan Matete out in January as he’s not getting the game time he needs and isn’t QUITE championship ready IMO.

could see Ba loaned out in Jan as wel, if somebody else came in. I think Ba could end up the best of the lot so need to ensure his development is well managed
 
  • Like
Reactions: Random lad, COYCS and Oliver's Army
Good stuff. I'm excited to see who we bring in. I can see one or two leaving though and we may not be too pleased about it. (Just guessing btw)
 
  • Like
Reactions: Random lad
A backup or compliment to Evans would be great but with so many CMs you wonder what that would mean for the likes of Matete, Ba and Michut. 3rd striker in the Broadhead mould would be great. I don't think we need a great deal of bodies through the door which makes a wonderful change. Genuine competition for Patterson and maybe a 4th wide player to compete with Clarke if I'm being really greedy

I'm terms of outgoings, Dajaku and Matete could leave without us needing to replace them. Wonder if Hume would benefit from a loan spell to L1 or bottom end of Championship.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Young Ted, Sunderpitt and Robertson
Oliver's Army said:
Good stuff. I'm excited to see who we bring in. I can see one or two leaving though and we may not be too pleased about it. (Just guessing btw)
Click to expand...
Stewart is the big question mark. Do we stick or twist? Seems as though the lad wants away (or at least wants money we cannot/will not pay). I'd be gutted if he went next month as there is very little quality about in Jan. Be better all round if he goes in the summer
 
  • Like
Reactions: Sunderpitt and Oliver's Army
TopCat_ said:
Stewart is the big question mark. Do we stick or twist? Seems as though the lad wants away (or at least wants money we cannot/will not pay). I'd be gutted if he went next month as there is very little quality about in Jan. Be better all round if he goes in the summer
Click to expand...
I'd be a lot more comfortable with us activating the additional year and coming to an agreement with him about moving in the summer when we can properly prepare a replacement.
 
TopCat_ said:
Stewart is the big question mark. Do we stick or twist? Seems as though the lad wants away (or at least wants money we cannot/will not pay). I'd be gutted if he went next month as there is very little quality about in Jan. Be better all round if he goes in the summer
Click to expand...

Wether he stays or goes we still need another centre forward bringing in. Two if he leaves.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Random lad, Young Ted, vic9 and 1 other person
TopCat_ said:
A backup or compliment to Evans would be great but with so many CMs you wonder what that would mean for the likes of Matete, Ba and Michut. 3rd striker in the Broadhead mould would be great. I don't think we need a great deal of bodies through the door which makes a wonderful change. Genuine competition for Patterson and maybe a 4th wide player to compete with Clarke if I'm being really greedy

I'm terms of outgoings, Dajaku and Matete could leave without us needing to replace them. Wonder if Hume would benefit from a loan spell to L1 or bottom end of Championship.
Click to expand...

I think an experienced midfielder is to compliment Evans this season and replace him next. Evans is 33 next summer and out of contract. Next season after 6 months out on loan Matete may be ready to contribute more regularly and it also gives the new experienced player 6 months to ease into a new club before he needs to run the midfield.

I agree that a 3rd striker is a must and that someone in a different mould to the other 2 is preferable. Joe Gelhardt on loan would be a great addition.

After that, I don't think we need anyone. Dejaku and Hume out on loan is a good plan. Hume can come back fighting for that 1st team spot next season.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Makemstine Roger, Random lad and TopCat.
Once we get most of the lads back, Im not sure we're desperate for much apart from up front.

Always good to strengthen, and I imagine we'll see some young incomings at least. But certainly we need to sort out the Ross situation and get another if he leaves, and ideally even if he doesn't.

But no one can think we aren't doing proper, serious research now, so we can hope there'll be a decent window.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Random lad
Here's an idea I've had. Say Stewart does want away and Everton come in for him - would you ask them for Simms as had been muted previously as well as get them to recall Broadhead and throw him in and a few million on top?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Random lad
Essayyeffcee said:
Here's an idea I've had. Say Stewart does want away and Everton come in for him - would you ask them for Simms as had been muted previously as well as get them to recall Broadhead and throw him in and a few million on top?
Click to expand...
Think the player has to agree and if he's turned us down once I don't see any reason why he'd suddenly change his mind
 
Essayyeffcee said:
Here's an idea I've had. Say Stewart does want away and Everton come in for him - would you ask them for Simms as had been muted previously as well as get them to recall Broadhead and throw him in and a few million on top?
Click to expand...

Broadhead has made no impact at all at Wigan this season and we already know he's injury prone. I'd stay clear altogether now.

Simms I like, and if he was thrown in at a value of say £2.5m then I'd be fine with that to soften the blow. What I wouldn't want is Simms to be around half the value of Stewart and decrease our ability to invest and replace him.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Makemstine Roger, Random lad, Young Ted and 2 others
Just a thought. We got Stewart because Johnson and Speakman rated him highly but instead of waiting for him to be on a free, and likely losing out to someone, we chucked a couple of hundred grand at it that nobody else would. I wonder if they are looking at lads with 6 months left, willing to spend where others wont. It is probably a good Jan tactic to get some long term prospects done.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Random lad, Forpadydeplasterer, SpikeyBob and 3 others
Flash Gordon said:
Broadhead has made no impact at all at Wigan this season and we already know he's injury prone. I'd stay clear altogether now.

Simms I like, and if he was thrown in at a value of say £2.5m then I'd be fine with that to soften the blow. What I wouldn't want is Simms to be around half the value of Stewart and decrease our ability to invest and replace him.
Click to expand...
I am still unsure on Simms. Would you bid £2.5m for him if it wasnt part of the Stewart deal? Dont think I would. Probs £1m tops for me.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Makemstine Roger and young2077
FellTop said:
Just a thought. We got Stewart because Johnson and Speakman rated him highly but instead of waiting for him to be on a free, and likely losing out to someone, we chucked a couple of hundred grand at it that nobody else would. I wonder if they are looking at lads with 6 months left, willing to spend where others wont. It is probably a good Jan tactic to get some long term prospects done.
Click to expand...

We got Roberts in the same way. He was free in the summer but we agreed to sell on clauses and cash upon promotion to get him from City before he was a free agent.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Random lad and FellTop
FellTop said:
I am still unsure on Simms. Would you bid £2.5m for him if it wasnt part of the Stewart deal? Dont think I would. Probs £1m tops for me.
Click to expand...

I think £1m is peanuts. I'm not totally sold on Simms but he has 5 goals this season and he's been injured. I'd pay £2.5m for someone who could contribute 15 goals a season at this level which I think Simms can. Add in that he's only 21 and you could easily be making a significant profit in 3-4 years.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Coastal Dolphins, smithy in nl, Southern A and 1 other person
I know Jonson Clarke-Harris is an old link, and doesnt fit the model. I could see us making the odd exception now though to the model. He will be in his last year of contract next year, teams will be all over him in the summer. Peterbotough would probably take £1m-£1.5 in Jan. If Stewart goes and we get Simms part ex, somebody like Harris would make sense.
 
TopCat_ said:
Stewart is the big question mark. Do we stick or twist? Seems as though the lad wants away (or at least wants money we cannot/will not pay). I'd be gutted if he went next month as there is very little quality about in Jan. Be better all round if he goes in the summer
Click to expand...

This is the big question for me!
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top Bottom
Back