Gutierrez or McClean

[Moorsleymountainman]

Never really rated Guitierrez. Bit of a headless chicken, (the mags would see this different of course) very little end product v McClean, OK only a hand full of games, a bit raw and a lot to learn.

Who would you rather have??

Try not to have to much bias.

 

[poolie_mackem]

I actually like Gutierrez, he works hard for Newcastle from what I have seen

If I wanted a player who is going to create for the chances, get me off my seat and grab a few goals I would take McClean everyday 2bh, he is a young lad and is only going to get better and better.

 

[Commachio]

Guiterrez is a decent player..................

 

[Oh Titus She Said No]

Two complete different players, put them together and they'd probably be the best winger in the league

 

[poolie_mackem]

Two complete different players, put them together and they'd probably be the best winger in the league

agree with this, don't want to make this another Sess vs Ben Arfa debate but why hasn't he started this game let alone game on for Taylor if he is that good?

 

[Moorsleymountainman]

Two complete different players, put them together and they'd probably be the best winger in the league

Thought Jonas was your LW? Play same position. Attack down the left. Try to make goals, score goals.

 

[Moorsleymountainman]

agree with this, don't want to make this another Sess vs Ben Arfa debate but why hasn't he started this game let alone game on for Taylor if he is that good?

Eh? He started the game.

 

[froggy1973]

McClean all day long looks good enthustiastic and can only get better.

 

[Commachio]

Eh? He started the game.

Think he's referring to HBA mate.

 

[Poyet's Eleven]

Moorsley, he's talking 'bout HBA

 

[Gil T Azell]

Disagree. Think he is a complete w*nker.

If he doesn't get past a man he falls over for the free kick.

 

[Moorsleymountainman]

Think he's referring to HBA mate.

Oops. Get ya.

 

[Oh Titus She Said No]

Thought Jonas was your LW? Play same position. Attack down the left. Try to make goals, score goals.

He's there to track back and help Santon, where McCleans there to get the ball in the box

 

[Beardsley's Rancid Sack]

On today's evidence there isn't much of a contest...

 

[Moorsleymountainman]

He's there to track back and help Santon, where McCleans there to get the ball in the box

I just don't get that mate. Your saying you play a left sided midfielder to "track back". Fair enough he does do that but first of all has to be atacking play surely.

 

[in carr we trust]

Jonas has been a bit rubbish recently so i'd say McLean.

 

[froggy1973]

He's there to track back and help Santon, where McCleans there to get the ball in the box

Thought that a wingers job was to get the ball in the Box not track back to help the backs although McClean does both.

 

[Commachio]

Jonas has been a bit rubbish recently so i'd say McLean.

Bold statement, and totally un-baised..fair play...

Guiterrez is still a decent player, one of your better one's from when i watch your lot play.....Along with that Colo.

 

[MrToontastic]

End product is a no brainer but it isn't all about going forward. At the moment I'd still go with Gutierrez. MacLean is fastly becoming a decent talent, I am expecting bigger things from him.

 

[ive.seen.the.light]

id have our jimmy mcclean any day, i wouldnt touch that long haired ****stain