Garde in talks with NUFC

  • Please bear with us on the new site integration and fixing any known bugs over the coming days. If you can not log in please try resetting your password and check your spam box. If you have tried these steps and are still struggling email [email protected] with your username/registered email address
  • Log in now to remove adverts - no adverts at all to registered members!
Status
Not open for further replies.
I honestly believe, with no reinforcements and possible outgoings in Jan and despite an decent gap between us and the bottom, if Carver takes charge until the end of the season we will rapidly drop down the table and have a good chance of a relegation battle
 
I honestly believe, with no reinforcements and possible outgoings in Jan and despite an decent gap between us and the bottom, if Carver takes charge until the end of the season we will rapidly drop down the table and have a good chance of a relegation battle


With no incomings and some outgoings, we will be in a relegation battle whoever is the manager. With no significant outgoings, I think we will be more or less safe whoever is in charge.

If I were making the decisions, I would give it to Beardsley/Carver/Bloke I Happened to Sit Beside On the Bus, not sell Sissoko and shop for managers in June.
 
We only probably need about 10 points for safety from the last 18 games, so I find it difficult to see us getting relegated but I'm sure given the opportunity we will take it with both hands.
 
There is a definitely a question of respect. However we've had plenty of big names who've struggled to get respect. Garde isn't that big of a name too, lets not dress it up. He hasn't achieved much either as a manager or a player. For sure if we were talking about Frank De Boer then its a different kettle of fish. But Garde is neither a big name to the English or indeed the French players.

Every manager is a risk, regardless of reputation. Its about being a good fit. This thing with Howe having found his level at Championship could be true. However you'd have to think his style of football and management certainly fits the bill of a modern attacking PL manager. This is not like say a Steve Bruce or Pulis type scenario where they will always get you promoted and often keep you in the division for a year or two. This is a developing young manager who looks to have a very bright future.

What players respect is how you operate. The likes of Mourinho, Van Gaal, Wenger all had pretty low key playing careers. The respect they enjoy now comes from the way they have operated as a coach.

I accept if we were talking about a big name former player, or big name already established manager, then respect could come into it to a small degree. As it is we are talking about Remi Garde. And how you operate is what really matters.

Someone made a good point of course, it won't be Eddie Howe. My point is PL clubs are far too quick to look abroad and it is hurting our game in terms of opportunity. There isn't actually any sound reasoning behind it now we have coaches who being educated the right way. You can always make an excuse to say the risk is this or that. It just doesn't stack up for me and is exactly that, an excuse that has been fed to us by pundits, media and all these other parasites riding the PL bandwagon over the last 20 years.

Personally I'm more interested in seeing coaches in this country being given a chance. I'd like to see them doing well here and then being the ones going abroad. Some of these guys are travelling round Europe often expending their own money to learn from the best. Then they come back but find that they are too much of a risk. It stinks for me.
If this is the case then it could have been a lot worse look at previous appointments to proof that.
I would love a de boer type manager however we all know under Ashley that will not happen still fat mike goes.
On a positive note the fact that he knows the french league Well so potential signings like grenier etc might be more open to the idea of joining and he could become more in sync with graham Carrs transfer ideas.
 
Garde has a decent win percentage at 51.5% but the real stat that has MA rubbing his hands together is this:

2011/12 - Toulalan and Pjanic sold for £22million. £4.6 million reinvested in incoming transfers. Finished 4th.
2012/13 - Over £30million of first team sold. Under £9million reinvested in incoming transfers. Finished 3rd.
2013/14 - Over £24million of first team sold. £4million reinvested in incoming transfers. Finished 5th.

Credited with development of Lacazette and Grenier as academy director. Brought through Lacazette, Grenier, Umtiti etc.

In short it sounds like he could be Mike's new money machine.
 
Garde has a decent win percentage at 51.5% but the real stat that has MA rubbing his hands together is this:

2011/12 - Toulalan and Pjanic sold for £22million. £4.6 million reinvested in incoming transfers. Finished 4th.
2012/13 - Over £30million of first team sold. Under £9million reinvested in incoming transfers. Finished 3rd.
2013/14 - Over £24million of first team sold. £4million reinvested in incoming transfers. Finished 5th.

Credited with development of Lacazette and Grenier as academy director. Brought through Lacazette, Grenier, Umtiti etc.

In short it sounds like he could be Mike's new money machine.

He's got a very good record, but he's foreign therefore, he will fail and we should be hiring someone from league 1.
 
You can hire whoever you like it's not going to be any better with our financial backing
 
Had to laugh at a piece in today's Sun. Apparently, someone from Newcastle made a secret call about Eddie Howe but apperently the conversation stopped immediately they found Howe earns more at Bournemouth than Newcastle were prepared to pay him.
Why does that not surprise me?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Salomon #9
Had to laugh at a piece in today's Sun. Apparently, someone from Newcastle made a secret call about Eddie Howe but apperently the conversation stopped immediately they found Howe earns more at Bournemouth than Newcastle were prepared to pay him.
Why does that not surprise me?

Well if the sun said it.....
 
Sky Sports reporting we are formally interviewing 4 different people, 4th being interviewed tomorrow.

Interesting..
 
He's got a very good record, but he's foreign therefore, he will fail and we should be hiring someone from league 1.

He has a decent record, lets not get carried away. I have no problem with league 1 manager. I have no problem with a foreign manager. The first port of call for a british club should of course be a british manager if we are interested in looking after our managers though. If you can't get a top job here, you sure as **** won't get on abroad! We are starting to send out a really bad message
 
Jo
Garde has a decent win percentage at 51.5% but the real stat that has MA rubbing his hands together is this:

2011/12 - Toulalan and Pjanic sold for £22million. £4.6 million reinvested in incoming transfers. Finished 4th.
2012/13 - Over £30million of first team sold. Under £9million reinvested in incoming transfers. Finished 3rd.
2013/14 - Over £24million of first team sold. £4million reinvested in incoming transfers. Finished 5th.

Credited with development of Lacazette and Grenier as academy director. Brought through Lacazette, Grenier, Umtiti etc.

In short it sounds like he could be Mike's new money machine.

Which could mean that the fat man sticks around a lot longer if he can cream an easy 10 - 20 mil every season. :(
 
Status
Not open for further replies.