Because Cattermole is ****. He's not a proper footballer. He is unreliable, ill-disciplined and very inconsistent.
He is unreliable because the bloke is always injured but hopefully the hip injury is gone for good and we see him fit and ready to go. The bloke hasn't been sent for about 3 years now so I don't agree with that.
It's not just getting cards that makes him ill-disciplined. Not that I have seen that much of you lot recently, but when I have he has a tendency to put his personal battles ahead of team discipline and what his role is meant to be. Still gives away a lot of free kicks too - some of which lead to goals conceded.
I think some of the free kicks are soft as **** if iam being honest. Refs can't stand him. One match last season he got booked after 30 seconds ffs.
Cattermole is similar to Hayden in that he has an obsession with giving the other team the ball for no apparent reason.
Are you measuring that by the ten minutes he spends on the pitch before getting red carded? He's a pretty smart guy to be fair, Sunderland fans only recently realised they can be gone by half time, cattermole's been doing it for years