Off Topic Coyote Canyon Game Thread

  • Please bear with us on the new site integration and fixing any known bugs over the coming days. If you can not log in please try resetting your password and check your spam box. If you have tried these steps and are still struggling email [email protected] with your username/registered email address
  • Log in now to remove adverts - no adverts at all to registered members!
Status
Not open for further replies.
but do they have the confessional thing of the priest that their roles cannot be revealed (without going back to the rules)
 
Obi Wanaldum said:
I'm still not sure we are 100% agreed on which gang Albert is aligned to. Been reasons for/against both.But it's obvious that he is a bandit and so must be lynched tonight.
Click to expand...

We know he's a dodgy twat but there is nothing to suggest he is aligned to either team imo
 
  • Like
Reactions: Obi Wan
Sebb's Campaign Manager said:
Can't seriously think the Donaldsons would save Chippy knowing fine well that he would just be hung the next day especially if it also meant that they had no other actions on the day he was being saved.

Not sure if anyone would automatically assume Brb would then be hung but should have as No Chance has stated before that there will always be a lynching and Brb was next in the queue.
Click to expand...

This is the only logic for claiming he is a lone McGraw
 
  • Like
Reactions: Obi Wan
mustyfrog said:
firstly if I knew who all the klopps real names were it would make it easier, don't trust gerrez or the binocular dude as they saught sanctuary, ACS just does my head in for wanting to die BUT did/can he know he was going to be rescued?? will add shortly after I have reread a comment by the dude who did the summary
Click to expand...

First true comment you make and you instantly put a big doubt in what I would imagine to be a few peoples minds <laugh>
 
  • Like
Reactions: Sir Tennisball and Obi Wan
mustyfrog said:
but do they have the confessional thing of the priest that their roles cannot be revealed (without going back to the rules)
Click to expand...

The roles are revealed to the priest and the priest is revealed to the visitors. GCB and I know who the priest is, the priest knows who we are. Because its been roughly 38hrs since GCB and I cowardly visited the chapel, we also now know the other is innocent too based on game play involving the priest. The only doubt comes when you consider the possible recruit last night (the priest can't be recruited though)
 
Obi Wanaldum said:
What's your take on ACS being McGraw vs. Donaldson? I had assumed McGraw, Tennis thinks Donaldson.
Click to expand...

Genuine don't know. I posted my thoughts last night.

I doubt both newbies were made bad guys, I think its a maximum of one so only one bandit team possibly increased in numbers.

Neither team took action last night which is strange. The sensible argument in my mind is the MgCraw's (who only had one member) choose to recruit hence not doing anything else and no reports being issued. The Donaldsons choose to save ACS which means the other team members couldn't act.

Of course, this would mean the Donaldsons sacrficed BRB. Can't say I'd be surprised because BRB had said he'd had enough and ACS has a better accuracy too. On the other hand, ACS was always going to be lynched the following night so saving him was a bit pointless, especially as it meant they couldn't act last night too. They've just delayed his death by 24hrs and killed one of their own.

I think we're going round in circles tbh. We lynch ACS and hope our killers get lucky. Hopefully, the sheriff and deputy have plenty of bullets left. The vigilante started with five and if the Tash kill was his then he now has four. He can only attach twice though so can choose one more person.
 
mustyfrog said:
do yourself and GCB also reveal your roles to each other (if not previously known)?
Click to expand...

No. I don't 100% know GCB's role (I know its one of three though by his actions) and he's told me he doesn't know what mine is. This was discussed on this board, the three of us are not allowed to talk privately.

Only three players were allowed to reveal roles; Sheriff, SK and Cat Burglar. the latter two are already dead.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Obi Wan
Sebb's Campaign Manager said:
I would guess as they recruited. Which I think prevents other actions but not sure.

[HASHTAG]#donttellmetoreadtherulesplease[/HASHTAG]
Click to expand...

I don't think it does. It is a gang leader action so the other team members can still do their thing.

I believe ACS is a Donaldson which is why they didn't act. I think there was just one McGraw who choose to recruit hence there no appearing to be an action.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Sir Tennisball
Can I just say that voting ACS does nothing to prove if someone is town or bandit. It's basically impossible to nominate anyone else based on the fact that we know ACS is a bandit.

Musty is high on my list unless he's just misunderstood the rules given that he's targeting me and gerrez.

On that note though, given ACS is leading the vote by so much and is going to swing whether me and gerrez vote anyway I'd quite like me and gerrez to revisit the priest to prove amongst me, him and the good man of the cloth that neither me or him have been turned.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Sir Tennisball
Kloppezinho said:
Genuine don't know. I posted my thoughts last night.

I doubt both newbies were made bad guys, I think its a maximum of one so only one bandit team possibly increased in numbers.

Neither team took action last night which is strange. The sensible argument in my mind is the MgCraw's (who only had one member) choose to recruit hence not doing anything else and no reports being issued. The Donaldsons choose to save ACS which means the other team members couldn't act.

Of course, this would mean the Donaldsons sacrficed BRB. Can't say I'd be surprised because BRB had said he'd had enough and ACS has a better accuracy too. On the other hand, ACS was always going to be lynched the following night so saving him was a bit pointless, especially as it meant they couldn't act last night too. They've just delayed his death by 24hrs and killed one of their own.

I think we're going round in circles tbh. We lynch ACS and hope our killers get lucky. Hopefully, the sheriff and deputy have plenty of bullets left. The vigilante started with five and if the Tash kill was his then he now has four. He can only attach twice though so can choose one more person.
Click to expand...

Agree re the plan. We lynch ACS (voted already, but just to avoid any doubt)

Also agree it seems crazy for Donaldsons to save ACS. My point is why would the whole team sacrifice actions, if they coild recruit instead? Especially when brb was next in line. If they wanted to sacrifice brb over ACS, thn all they had to do was pile votes on tk brb and Albert not go all stupid and tey'd have the same outcome. Why waste the team save in that situation. If that happened, it is the biggest fck up ever. Waste an action, lynch a player and leave another out to dry the next night?
NOT EVEN ALBERT, BRB AND TASH ARE THAT CRAZY. Are they?

I think Acs was a lone McGraw and saving himself as a last act of desepration.

If so, that means the Donaldsons may have recruited. Hence the lack of other news. In which case, they are still strong numerically.

That's my theory.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Nolberto's Salsa Inferno and Rum & Black for 2
Kloppezinho said:
Because we know ACS is a bandit so must be killed. The second choice should be a sheriff, Deputy or Vigilante target
Click to expand...
The way I understand it the Deputy can't try to kill anyone, only the Sheriff and Vigilante can.

From tonight the Sheriff and Deputy are Tradesmen so only the Vigilante will be able to target someone. The rest will defend if someone shoots at them (or someone in the same building as them). <ok>
 
Graham Carr's Binoculars said:
Can I just say that voting ACS does nothing to prove if someone is town or bandit. It's basically impossible to nominate anyone else based on the fact that we know ACS is a bandit.

Musty is high on my list unless he's just misunderstood the rules given that he's targeting me and gerrez.

On that note though, given ACS is leading the vote by so much and is going to swing whether me and gerrez vote anyway I'd quite like me and gerrez to revisit the priest to prove amongst me, him and the good man of the cloth that neither me or him have been turned.
Click to expand...
Computer says NO, coward <laugh>
OP from Neville: "Any player can choose to take sanctuary in the town chapel once during the game and this replaces other actions. This is the action of a coward."

I agree though Musty is my next target after ACS
 
  • Like
Reactions: Graham Carr's Binoculars, Super G Ted'inho and Obi Wan
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom
Back