Not sure but he has definitely regressed while here. He was never anything special but to be fair 90% of ours just saw him as a back up midfielder. Of course it was the fact that quite a few of theirs took it quite badly too which lit up a few of ours which is only natural (despite an equal number saying they weren't bothered because he was bang average). Reality is now, he has got a lot worse than bang average. Perhaps another manager could get more out of him but at present you wouldn't even have him on the bench in the Championship.