best and weakest full strength midfield

I'm not the **** who made a claim and when asked to prove his bullshit claim can't do it.

 

Do it then.

 

1. He's more than good.
2. Diaby is a beast against anyone when fit
3. This is only Arteta's 2nd season with us, he can't be blamed for us not winning anything. Even when he was wih Everton he was better than Carrick.
4. He's a starting spanish international. I think that automatically makes him one of the best midfielders in the world.
5. Nani, Young and Valencia are wing forwards. Giggs is a left midfielder, but is way past his best.

 

To save me reading for pages and pages.... what is going on? Is shwan saying United's midfield is better than Arsenal's?

 

Yes and he says Wilshere is average

 

1. Fine, we disagree
2. We're very quick to issue infair criticism to players who don't deserve it. When fit, Diaby is a monster. Anyone who says otherwise has personal problems with the guy
3. We had our worst start to a season, and couldn't defend, Song deserves most of the blame
4. Ask those in the know, they'll tell you how good Cazorla is
5. You don't have mid wingers other than Giggs.

 

I'm still waiting

 

As a neutral, Arsenal's is better. Arteta is class, Wilshere is class. Both better than United's CMs.

 

Thanks Drogs.

 

United's midfield is the worst in the top 6 imo (not the current top 6, I mean out of City, Arsenal, Chelsea, Spurs, Newcastle and them). I think it goes; City, Arsenal, Chelsea, Spurs, Newcastle, United. Ours is worse than Newcastle and Spuds if Lampard plays with Mikel but Ramires and Mikel are brilliant together.

 

I thought yours was the best, you have Mata, Hazard and Oscar. And Mikel. OK, scrap Mikel. But the other 3 on their own are easily good enough to win games on there own.

 

tbh i feel chelsea's and man city's midfield are both better than arsenal's and man's. Im assuming their midfield to be somehting like this

hazard ramnirez mata

silva yaya nasri

 

not gonna disagree tbf but if we were talking about strikers we would be 2nd best out of the 6 at least

 

i think its pretty unanimous you and city have the best strike force...i would follow it by newcastle though.

 

Ok if you're including the wingers and CAM's then I'd say United's is one of the best tbf. I'm just talking about the two players in the pivot.

 

I'd probably put you top in strikers. You have Judas van c*nty and Wayne Rooney. Van C*nty on his own is better than most other teams strikers.

 

Oh, i was counting them as AM's, not wingers. People are including Cazorla in the argument and he's an AM.

 

what about Spurs, doesnt Bale get referred to as a striker these days

 

Cisse has been about as useful as a teapot made of ice this season.

 

well the thread was intended to include am dm and cm but not wingers