Austrailian Oscars

[Sportydan]

I haven't see it done on this forum before, but this is just awards for various things during the weekend :

Best Driver:
Worst Driver:
Best Rookie
Best Team:
Worst Team:
Best Overtake:
Funniest-moment:
Most Surprising Result:
Least Surprising Result:
Special Mention to:
Race Rating: /10

Best BBC commentator/presenter:
Worst BBC commentator/presenter:
Best Commentary moment:
Overall BBC coverage rating: /10

 

[DHCanary]

Best Driver: Perez
Worst Driver: Karthikeyan
Best Rookie: Perez
Best Team: Red Bull (Honourable mention for Mclaren)
Worst Team: HRT (then Mercedes and Ferrari)
Best Overtake: Vettel around the outside of Button in turn 4
Funniest-moment: MB on the commentary nearly making the Virgin innuendo
Most Surprising Result: Petrov's third place
Least Surprising Result: Vettel winning
Special Mention to: Button - did well to fight back up after the penalty
Race Rating: 6/10

Best BBC commentator/presenter: DC
Worst BBC commentator/presenter: EJ
Best Commentary moment: DC impressively noticing Hamiltons plank was loose before turn 1 - that would have been completely missed last year
Overall BBC coverage rating: 8/10

 

[Julius Caesar]

Best Driver: Vitaly Petrov
Worst Driver: Nick Heidfeld
Best Rookie: Sergio Perez
Best Team: Red Bull
Worst Team: Hispania
Best Overtake: Vitaly Petrov on Jenson Button
Funniest-moment: Just how slow team lotus are after all that fighting talk.
Most Surprising Result: Nick Heidfeld being so low
Least Surprising Result: Vettel Winning
Special Mention to: Paul Di Resta, congrats on your point.
Race Rating: 6/10

Best BBC commentator/presenter: David Coulthard
Worst BBC commentator/presenter: N/A
Best Commentary moment: Brundle failing to spot Schumachers now non existant rear tire
Overall BBC coverage rating: 8/10

 

[DHCanary]

Best Commentary moment: Brundle failing to spot Schumachers now non existant rear tire

That struck me as odd too! I'd spotted it quite early on, and I was sat there thinking, well surely one of them will have seen it?!

 

[nh-f1]

Best Driver:Sergio Perez
Worst Driver:Narain Karthikeyan
Best Rookie: Sergio Perez
Best Team: Force India, good result, considering where we thought they'd be
Worst Team:HRT
Best Overtake:Buemi on whoever it was, round turn 4
Funniest-moment: neither HRT able to quailfy under 107%
Most Surprising Result:Vitaly Petrov getting 1st podium
Least Surprising Result:Vettel winning
Special Mention to: Sauber, unlucky, but their drivers were fantastic today
Race Rating: 6/10

Best BBC commentator/presenter: DC - good start to season
Worst BBC commentator/presenter: None
Best Commentary moment: DC spotting Schumacher puncutre, Brundle had no idea!
Overall BBC coverage rating: 9/10

 

[nh-f1]

sportydan, you should do this for all the races, like we all have a post GP review!

 

[u408379965]

I haven't see it done on this forum before, but this is just awards for various things during the weekend :

Best Driver:Perez
Worst Driver:Alguersuari - Anonymous but for ending Schumacher's race
Best RookiePerez
Best Team:Red Bull Racing
Worst Team:HRT - Admit it El_Bando
Best Overtake:Barrichello on the Sauber
Funniest-moment:Brundle's Virgin comment. Or more to the point the awkward silence before he clambered out of the hole he'd dug
Most Surprising Result:Petrov
Least Surprising Result:Vettel
Special Mention to:Massa for his stoic defending against Button. He completely crumbled from that point onwards though
Race Rating: 6/10

Best BBC commentator/presenter:DC
Worst BBC commentator/presenter:N/A
Best Commentary moment:Eagle eyed Coulthard clocking Hamiltons damaged tea tray
Overall BBC coverage rating: 10/10 - They did a great job, the forum was decent as well, and Ted's video blog afterwards was very ineresting

 

[Forza Bianchi]

Best Driver: Perez
Worst Driver: Karthikeyan
Best Rookie: Perez
Best Team: Red Bull
Worst Team: HRT
Best Overtake: Alonso on Kobayashi, T11
Funniest-moment: Brundle's Virgin comment
Most Surprising Result: Petrov 3rd
Least Surprising Result: Vettel 1st
Special Mention to: Perez for one pit stop
Race Rating: 6/10

Best BBC commentator/presenter: Coulthard
Worst BBC commentator/presenter: None
Best Commentary moment: Alonso got a face full of ...
Overall BBC coverage rating: 9/10

 

[BrightLampShade]

Best Driver: Petrov
Worst Driver: Karthikeyan
Best Rookie Perez - Close to best drive of the day
Best Team: Red Bull, Maybe McLaren for the rapid improvement
Worst Team: Guess, starts in H and ends in T
Best Overtake: Barrichello on Rosberg - Really: Buemi turn 4 (May come back to this one)
Funniest-moment: Post race, Eddie/Coulthard with the empty RB garage.
Most Surprising Result: Ferrari+McLaren wouldn't have guessed that last week.
Least Surprising Result: Vettel
Special Mention to: The Saubers, esp Perez
Race Rating: 7/10

Best BBC commentator/presenter: MB
Worst BBC commentator/presenter: N/A
Best Commentary moment: Waiting for them to spot MS's tyre
Overall BBC coverage rating: 10/10 -Flawless

 

[McWilliams]

Best Driver: Hamilton
Worst Driver:Alonso
Best Rookie: Perez
Best Team: McLaren
Worst Team: Ferrari
Best Overtake: Barrichello on Kobayashi
Funniest-moment: Watching Alonso watching another trophy slip at the same time as viewing Vitaly's rear end
Most Surprising Result: Barrichello making so many mistakes
Least Surprising Result: Ferrari team orders
Special Mention to: The lads at Woking
Race Rating: 6/10

Best BBC commentator/presenter: Brundle
Worst BBC commentator/presenter:Jordon
Best Commentary moment: Brundle predicting Ferrari team orders
Overall BBC coverage rating: 8/10

 

[Canary f1]

Best Driver: Perez
Worst Driver: Karthikeyan
Best Rookie Perez
Best Team: Mclaren
Worst Team: HRT (I wish they would just sod off)
Best Overtake: Vettel on Button
Funniest-moment: Alonso behind Petrov again!
Most Surprising Result: Sauber one stop
Least Surprising Result: Vettel
Special Mention to: The MTC
Race Rating: /10 6/10

Best BBC commentator/presenter: Brundle
Worst BBC commentator/presenter: I like them all
Best Commentary moment: Coultard clocking Hamilton's broken floor
Overall BBC coverage rating: /10 10

 

[Julius Caesar]

For the interests of Tallying up the best/ Worst driver in this forums opinion over the season i have tallied up this thread ( i got bored and was intersted by the results for the canada awards)

Aus Winners are:
Best Driver: Sergio Perez
Worst Driver Narain Karthikeyan
Best Rookie Sergio Perez
Best Team Red Bull
Worst Team HRT

Race Rating average 6.125

 

[Big Ern]

why were HRT worst team? surely not being able to build a legal car and having both drivers DSQ for it is worse?

Worst team: Sauber.

 

[cosicave]

Ha! This is an interesting idea Julius.

Presumably you are going to do it for every Grand Prix? - Perhaps it will eventually give a statistically definitive 'best Grand Prix of the season'!


[Edit:
Hahaha… it seems you might be opening a can of worms if you need to take account of opinions which are voiced some time later! Well done Miggins for showing the potential difficulty! ]

 

[genjigonzales]

[Edit:
Hahaha… it seems you might be opening a can of worms if you need to take account of opinions which are voiced some time later! Well done Miggins for showing the potential difficulty! ]

As Sportydan usually posts an empty template first he could actually update that with the average, then later posts could just modify the OP. I'd like to see total scores, too, e.g.

Best Driver: Perez (5), Petrov (2), Hamilton (1)

 

[Julius Caesar]

As Sportydan usually posts an empty template first he could actually update that with the average, then later posts could just modify the OP. I'd like to see total scores, too, e.g.

Best Driver: Perez (5), Petrov (2), Hamilton (1)

Would be easier than me doing it.

 

[genjigonzales]

Sorry, JC. I didn't even check who was doing the totals. Good work - you carry on.

 

[Sportydan]

Funnily enough, not joking i was thinking about this, thanks Julius, ill give a look at it tomorrow.