Off Topic Ashes 2021/22

  • Please bear with us on the new site integration and fixing any known bugs over the coming days. If you can not log in please try resetting your password and check your spam box. If you have tried these steps and are still struggling email [email protected] with your username/registered email address
  • Log in now to remove adverts - no adverts at all to registered members!
Trying to be fair now, the top order of both sides has struggled in this test, just England's seems to have struggled more.
 
With England being piss poor and all the problems at Yorkshire (points deductions probably the best case scenario IF the members vote Patel in on Thursday, loss of internationals and probable insolvency if they don't) I've never been less enthusiastic about the start of the cricket season
 
  • Like
Reactions: boltontiger
West Indies need 28 runs to win. Even they can't screw this up.........

Perhaps this will finally see a new captain at the helm, we are in transition as a team, and while Root is a world class batsman, as a captain he is poor. Let him concentrate on what he does best and get someone in who can actually captain the team properly.
 
Perhaps this will finally see a new captain at the helm, we are in transition as a team, and while Root is a world class batsman, as a captain he is poor. Let him concentrate on what he does best and get someone in who can actually captain the team properly.

Root says he wants to carry on, but I think it is time for him to take the pressure off himself and concentrate on his batting, the likelihood is that it will be taken out of his hands when a new leader comes in. His record is abysmal, maybe it is the cards he has been dealt to a certain degree, but it just feels like it needs a new approach now.
 
Root says he wants to carry on, but I think it is time for him to take the pressure off himself and concentrate on his batting, the likelihood is that it will be taken out of his hands when a new leader comes in. His record is abysmal, maybe it is the cards he has been dealt to a certain degree, but it just feels like it needs a new approach now.

Perhaps this will finally see a new captain at the helm, we are in transition as a team, and while Root is a world class batsman, as a captain he is poor. Let him concentrate on what he does best and get someone in who can actually captain the team properly.
Who would replace him though? I don't see candidates lining up...
 
Who would replace him though? I don't see candidates lining up...

Maybe you have to look around the county game and see if there is a good captain that is tactically aware and a good man manager. A captain in Cricket is a much more important role than in many other sports, just because you are a good player doesn't always mean you are a good captain and leader of men.
 
  • Like
Reactions: highpeak tiger
Maybe you have to look around the county game and see if there is a good captain that is tactically aware and a good man manager. A captain in Cricket is a much more important role than in many other sports, just because you are a good player doesn't always mean you are a good captain and leader of men.
Agree, Mike Brearley epitomised that. Sam Billings and James Vince being talked up a bit around the press. The current crop of batsmen and (fit) bowlers make it a bit of a poisoned chalice though imo.
 
Agree, Mike Brearley epitomised that. Sam Billings and James Vince being talked up a bit around the press. The current crop of batsmen and (fit) bowlers make it a bit of a poisoned chalice though imo.

You have to start somewhere, I just feel Joe is hanging on and it is not helping him or the team. His field placings are questionable at times, also his rotation of bowlers. I think we need to start afresh and build from a new base.
 
Who would replace him though? I don't see candidates lining up...

Short term fix Morgan, but he isnt the answer admittedly .. we need a forward thinking aggressive captain, all this hanging around forever trying g to protect your wicket then getting out for 20 runs isnt doing as any good at all. This started with Silverwood, we need to have a go, not sit like rabbits in the headlights waiting to be run over.
 
Short term fix Morgan, but he isnt the answer admittedly .. we need a forward thinking aggressive captain, all this hanging around forever trying g to protect your wicket then getting out for 20 runs isnt doing as any good at all. This started with Silverwood, we need to have a go, not sit like rabbits in the headlights waiting to be run over.
But not go hell for leather like under the previous coach. The aussie white ball specialist whose name escapes me. Shot selection is the key