All time United/Liverpool XI

No he lined up there for us in the team with Mascherano and Alonso.

 

He was at the tip of a 3 man midfield with them 2 in CM

 

...totally agree...if Ronaldo had taken the clatterings that George Best took there would be voluminous tears and a hurried retreat to the safe haven of the eyebrow plucking boutique...

George punished you for the tackles by staying on his feet and scoring...amazing balance, technique and speed...and not a hint of eyeliner...

 

Mainly in the case of Best he was a piss head as were most of that day, he trained when he liked done what he wanted but a great player of his day.

 

my team
Schmeichel
Neal Hansen Ferdinand Irwin
Best Charlton Souness Barnes
Suarez Rush

Barnes is very questionable but i just loved watching him play and whilst i may only have seen the *** end of charltons career i saw enough of him to know he was a true great and would have been in any generation.
As for Edwards don't get people putting him in their team as they will never have seen him play and no-one can be certain of how his career would have turned out if it hadn't been for the Munich tragedy

 

Souness is the only Liverpool player I could genuinely see in my 11, he was a brilliant player, but even then Keane was better of their ilk.
I doubt you'd play both in the same side.

I can't even get Charlton, Law and Giggs in my prefered 11 so there's no way a Pool player gets in!

Without bias. Honest!

 

To be honest I felt the same way.

Souness was probably a touch more creative (technically) than Keane? So he edged it. Plus I thought if I included Keane or Robbo instead as well as the rest of my selection then it would seem like I was being biased.

 

Yeah, cos Gerrard out of position is clearly better than Ronaldo, Beckham and Best when played in position. No bias there at all

please log in to view this image

That's mine. It was wafer thin between Law and Dalglish up top, willing to admit I went for Law largely for the Utd connection, and of course the Ballon d'Or and better goal scoring record . Also arguments for Scholes, Alonso or Molby in midfield ahead of Keane or Souness for balance (although Alonso and Molby didn't even make the BBC list!)

 

Hanson and or Stam and or Vidic?

Hard to choose

 

Depends on the amount of thuggery required.

 

How good would he have been had he not been a piss head and/or had use of modern day methods? #scary

 

So deluded. Keane Scholes Robson and I would guess Edwards all better options in central midfield.

Gerrard 2 goals in 38 games v Chelsea until his final appearance

 

sorry when i did my team i didn't realise that the criteria was performance against Chelsea

 

He also went a decade without scoring v United. Big game player my Arse. Unless you count ten minutes v Olympiakos and a dive in Istanbul

 

Take no notice mate, he's a renowned plazzy Chav.

 

oh yes if you also disregard goals in EUFA cup final FA cup final League cup final etc
you sir are a tosser
i didn't put Gerrard in my team but for legit reasons not for your bull

 

i'm gathering that rapidly

 

Or being allowed to run at players in an age where players aren't allowed to tackle like they used too

 

And until a decade ago world football hadn't heard of Chelsea

 

Hanson. Always Hanson.