Off Topic Afcftw Mafia Game

  • Please bear with us on the new site integration and fixing any known bugs over the coming days. If you can not log in please try resetting your password and check your spam box. If you have tried these steps and are still struggling email [email protected] with your username/registered email address
  • Log in now to remove adverts - no adverts at all to registered members!
Status
Not open for further replies.
Albert's Chip Shop said:
Sebb - He's been quieter than normal.. big time. As we're at the business end of the game he's come out of the shadows and immediately fingered me as the mafia when the consensus is that I aren't. His 'evidence' is weaker than our defence at the Toon. - Mafioso guaranteed.

Lucaas - Innocent townie.
Click to expand...

Been checking my posts. 85 in this game. Chippy has made 82 with 18 just today.

First mention I can find of my suspicions was comment 1370. Hardly "at the business end" is it Chippy but let's not let the facts get in the way of your general non fact based comments.

Also Lucaas is townie and no explanation of why Mr Chips or should I say Signor Pattatina Fritta.

:emoticon-0176-smoke
 
Sebb's Campaign Manager said:
Been checking my posts. 85 in this game. Chippy has made 82 with 18 just today.

First mention I can find of my suspicions was comment 1370. Hardly "at the business end" is it Chippy but let's not let the facts get in the way of your general non fact based comments.

Also Lucaas is townie and no explanation of why Mr Chips or should I say Signor Pattatina Fritta.

:emoticon-0176-smoke
Click to expand...

How do you find out how many posts you've made? I can find out how many other people have made but for some reason don't have that option on my own profile?

Even the ****ing forum is against me! <laugh>
 
Am, at this stage, very convinced of Less Hope's guilt.
Once the cartel is done he needs to go.
 
Bodanki said:
Am, at this stage, very convinced of Less Hope's guilt.
Once the cartel is done he needs to go.
Click to expand...

Any leanings as to whether he is SK or Mafia? His posts last night did look dodgy as ****, but then so did Tobes, MITO and Funky before they died and only one of them was guilty.

Besides, if Obi truly is town aligned I reckon he's probably unlocked enough power to direct someone to take out Neville tonight, so we may well find out anyway.
 
Bodanki said:
Am, at this stage, very convinced of Less Hope's guilt.
Once the cartel is done he needs to go.
Click to expand...

Not sure what that is based on, especially since you also seem to know that Mikey is cartel. Once Mikey is lynched we'll see what happens. I'm not going to get into defending myself until I see if I survive Mikey's lynching (or any other actions).

At least for tonight we are all agreed that Mikey needs to go.
 
Less Hope Than Neville said:
Not sure what that is based on, especially since you also seem to know that Mikey is cartel. Once Mikey is lynched we'll see what happens. I'm not going to get into defending myself until I see if I survive Mikey's lynching (or any other actions).

At least for tonight we are all agreed that Mikey needs to go.
Click to expand...

Pointing Mikey out doesn't mean you're innocent though. It benefits the mafia also to get rid of Mikey. Maybe the mafia get extra kills/power once they get rid of the cartel?
 
Lucaaas said:
Pointing Mikey out doesn't mean you're innocent though. It benefits the mafia also to get rid of Mikey. Maybe the mafia get extra kills/power once they get rid of the cartel?
Click to expand...
Was just about to point that out.
Fingering Mikey is in no way a sign of your innocence, since the mafia will want rid of him just as much as we do, as he can recruit from either.
 
Lucaaas said:
Pointing Mikey out doesn't mean you're innocent though. It benefits the mafia also to get rid of Mikey. Maybe the mafia get extra kills/power once they get rid of the cartel?
Click to expand...

Agreed - and the same would apply if I was the serial killer.

And now doing what i said I wouldn't and wasting time defending myself but I get drawn in every time <laugh>

But it would have been much easier to just wait and see how the voting was going first for lynchings and then to kill Mikey in secret if I were mafia. There is no advantage at all in going public. The only people who benefit from me going public are the town.

I'd also say look at my voting history. I think the mafia would have been pushing for both tennis ball and Mito to have been lynched. Two easy kills. They certainly wouldn't have gone to the efforts I did. I wouldn't have gone to the efforts I did if the task hadn't been genuine. Yesterday it became obvious that Funky was town. I moved my vote off him when he still had 3 votes (I think). It wouldn't have been difficult to push for lynching Funky based on the whole MITO disagreement would it?

It's hard to see how I could have acted more helpfully for the town.
 
Bodanki said:
No the best way to act like a townie, if you are mafia, is to act like a townie
Click to expand...

So a townie's actions shouldn't try and help the town? This will turn into a circular argument that wont change anything.

I suspect all will be revealed tonight anyway between the 50/50 and the chances of being targeted by the SK/meth head.
 
Bodanki said:
Was just about to point that out.
Fingering Mikey is in no way a sign of your innocence, since the mafia will want rid of him just as much as we do, as he can recruit from either.
Click to expand...

If he was Mafia or serial killer, wouldn't it benefit him more to wait until the cartel had recruited some more? That way they would have a line on all the cartel members and could trot them out in line, preventing any Mafia lynchings for the next day or two. Him going public with Mikey has also broken the first rule of being Mafia - never call attention to yourself.

I'm not saying that makes Neville innocent, but he's played it an odd way if he is Mafia.
 
Swarbs said:
If he was Mafia or serial killer, wouldn't it benefit him more to wait until the cartel had recruited some more? That way they would have a line on all the cartel members and could trot them out in line, preventing any Mafia lynchings for the next day or two. Him going public with Mikey has also broken the first rule of being Mafia - never call attention to yourself.

I'm not saying that makes Neville innocent, but he's played it an odd way if he is Mafia.
Click to expand...

Not really, at this point there are only two mafia left, if one of them got recruited its more or less game over for the mafia
 
Bodanki said:
Not really, at this point there are only two mafia left, if one of them got recruited its more or less game over for the mafia
Click to expand...

But Neville has already been recruited. Mikey has pretty much confirmed that with his responses last night.

Surely that's the only way he could find out who Mikey is? So if he was Mafia it would be game over for the Mafia anyway, and he wouldn't say anything cos he'd be a full cartel member?
 
Swarbs said:
But Neville has already been recruited. Mikey has pretty much confirmed that with his responses last night.

Surely that's the only way he could find out who Mikey is? So if he was Mafia it would be game over for the Mafia anyway, and he wouldn't say anything cos he'd be a full cartel member?
Click to expand...

He said there were reasons why he couldn't be recruited, maybe it was because he was mafia and cartel cannot recruit mafia?
 
Swarbs said:
But Neville has already been recruited. Mikey has pretty much confirmed that with his responses last night.

Surely that's the only way he could find out who Mikey is? So if he was Mafia it would be game over for the Mafia anyway, and he wouldn't say anything cos he'd be a full cartel member?
Click to expand...
If Neville was recruited and then revealed it to us, then he should have gotten Ebola and been thrown out of the game.
If I was mafia or Cartel and recruited someone and they then proceeded to tell everyone they had been recruited and who the rest of the mafia/Cartel are, I would be pissed.
Against the games rules for sure. If you are recruited, you are recruited.
 
Bodanki said:
If Neville was recruited and then revealed it to us, then he should have gotten Ebola and been thrown out of the game.
If I was mafia or Cartel and recruited someone and they then proceeded to tell everyone they had been recruited and who the rest of the mafia/Cartel are, I would be pissed.
Against the games rules for sure. If you are recruited, you are recruited.
Click to expand...

What he claims is that he was recruited by Mikey but due to some technicalities (which he didn't explain) Mikey wasn't allowed to recruit him and instead gained access to the cartel board but had to wait 24 hrs to name him.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom
Back