Off Topic Afcftw Mafia Game

  • Please bear with us on the new site integration and fixing any known bugs over the coming days. If you can not log in please try resetting your password and check your spam box. If you have tried these steps and are still struggling email [email protected] with your username/registered email address
  • Log in now to remove adverts - no adverts at all to registered members!
Status
Not open for further replies.
Bodanki said:
Right now, I dont think you OR Valley are mafia.
No one else has come forward to say they are the drunk, that would end that debate immediately.
Valley fingered Tobes, which turned out to be correct.
I have a bad feeling that his report on MITO being non town was....hacked...for lack of a better term, through maybe some secret power.
But there is one way to tell if MITO is lying, anyone else want to claim to be the drunk?

Valley wouldnt have outed Tobes if he was mafia, that would have been stupid.

My picks for the mafia are two of Swarbs, Tennis or Lucaas.

MITO fingered Tennis in his first investigation and that has a 66% chance of being right.
My problem with this is, if MITO isnt town, why has no one, even snidely tried to challenge his assertion that he is the drunk?

The other thing I am iffy about is Gerrez's death, its just weird
Click to expand...

Why would they need expose themselves if they know Mito is lying and Valley has just had a positive investigation on him? The drunk PI is an obvious mafia target, he doesn't need to expose himself if he knows Valley is exposing Mito for him. Mito my not be Mafia, he could be Cartel, but he's not Town imo.
 
Bodanki said:
Then who is the f**king drunk? And why have they been letting MITO ride rough shot unchallenged as the drunk?
Click to expand...

Because Mito has been drawing attention himself big style, Maybe the real PI doesn't need to expose himself , especially now Vally is doing it for him, more than ever he wouldn't have to reveal himself now.
 
Bodanki said:
Then who is the f**king drunk? And why have they been letting MITO ride rough shot unchallenged as the drunk?
Click to expand...

This is one of the things bothering me! The only possible explanations are that eithet Tash is the drunk and isn't playing or whoever the drunk is has been silenced by the mafia through a secret power? But.....how many secret power's can they have? Silencing roles, switching investigations, earning hits?? They surely can't all be happening??
 
BobbyD said:
This game is super confusing. I hate how helpful mito is being. I think lynching sirtennis is a sort of testing mito sort of way.

At the very least we dont need to be in a rush to lynch him IF we think he is being helpful until we catch the cartel which he will be interested in if he was mafia and town.

Also bod acting weird and stupid is creeping me out. Is he trying to hint something? Or is it a special task? I dont know.

Agree that valley should be investigating one of the inactives to see if the cartel is one of them.

Lucas is also in the suspicious radar.

In the meantime sirtennis
Click to expand...

Ok, I'm going to follow my own suggestion and join you. I think this could be a safer way of testing MITO.

SirTennis
 
Evening all. Sorry not had chance to go through everything yet.

Right, latest info from AFC, again I have devided to share (remember, he states that AT LEAST ONE of these is TRUE but NOT necessarily ALL):

1. Funky was heard talking to himself in different voices.
2. 666 Tash 666 was tending to his garden ready to enter his prize veg for the town fayre.
3. Lucaaas was driving his Ferrari Enzo down the street where Gerrez lives.

I've no idea how, or if, this will help. I need to catch up on tonight's events and review pre and post lynch postings for clues. <ok>
 
Bodanki said:
My problem with this is, if MITO isnt town, why has no one, even snidely tried to challenge his assertion that he is the drunk?
Click to expand...

Because no one else came forward to say they weren't, so we didn't really bother with him as there was a large chance Tobes WAS guilty because Valley had no other reason to put himself in the line of fire so early on in a game.

Then when yesterday's lynching was over with Valley immediately turned the spotlight on MITO claiming he was guilty and as Valley has a 100% record of pointing out non-Town players we're naturally going to go along with him.

Why is that so hard to understand? The only person who doesn't agree with it is you. You're not willing to accept MITO isn't town even though our psychic has investigated him and said so but you're willing to accuse me and/or swarbs without a single shred of credible evidence against us.
 
So they havent come forward because MITO is on the chopping block?
Sound theory, except with one small wrickle, that means they have been getting info for the last two days without sharing a single iota of it with anyone.
A pretty useless PI then by any stretch.
MITO could have pretended to be the drunk, but even if the real drunk is inactive, MITO would have had no way of knowing that....coming forward to pretend to be the drunk would have been a HUUUUUGE risk.
 
Obi Wan said:
Evening all. Sorry not had chance to go through everything yet.

Right, latest info from AFC, again I have devided to share (remember, he states that AT LEAST ONE of these is TRUE but NOT necessarily ALL):

1. Funky was heard talking to himself in different voices.
2. 666 Tash 666 was tending to his garden ready to enter his prize veg for the town fayre.
3. Lucaaas was driving his Ferrari Enzo down the street where Gerrez lives.

I've no idea how, or if, this will help. I need to catch up on tonight's events and review pre and post lynch postings for clues. <ok>
Click to expand...

My gut feel is that Bri is town, Tash may not be town and lucaaas is Mafia. Just a gut feel but I'm leaning towards Tash. Can the investigator please look at Tash or lucaaas please?
 
Lucaaas said:
Because no one else came forward to say they weren't, so we didn't really bother with him as there was a large chance Tobes WAS guilty because Valley had no other reason to put himself in the line of fire so early on in a game.

Then when yesterday's lynching was over with Valley immediately turned the spotlight on MITO claiming he was guilty and as Valley has a 100% record of pointing out non-Town players we're naturally going to go along with him.

Why is that so hard to understand? The only person who doesn't agree with it is you. You're not willing to accept MITO isn't town even though our psychic has investigated him and said so but you're willing to accuse me and/or swarbs without a single shred of credible evidence against us.
Click to expand...

I have a big bit of evidence against you mate.
Immediately after Valley was revealed to be correct about Tobes, I pretended to say he was talking bullshit and still not believing him.
Knowing that the mafia would know both Valley and I were innocent.
As a mafia, if I saw this, i would immediately jump on this and attempt to accuse me, you did just that.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ValleyGraduate12
Bodanki said:
Valley's info is bullshit.

Valley
Click to expand...
Lucaaas said:
Such a mafia thing to say.

Valley has already pointed out one of the guilty mafia players, why would he do that if he was mafia? And its a hell of a risk to come out that early in the game without a doctor unless you are 100% about your info and he KNEW that Tobes was mafia. Only way he'd know that would be if he'd investigated him.
Click to expand...
 
Bodanki said:
I have a big bit of evidence against you mate.
Immediately after Valley was revealed to be correct about Tobes, I pretended to say he was talking bullshit and still not believing him.
Knowing that the mafia would know both Valley and I were innocent.
As a mafia, if I saw this, i would immediately jump on this and attempt to accuse me, you did just that.
Click to expand...

Are you saying there are not now questions around MITO being mafia? Cos I still think there are.
 
Just read the last three pages and saw my name that many times that I have one thing to say....

[HASHTAG]#obsessed[/HASHTAG]

:)
 
  • Like
Reactions: Obi Wan
Albert's Chip Shop said:
So we take Mito down, investigate Tash, whoever is the schitzo should request something to happen to Lucaas too.

As an aside... Anyone hear from Bobby d?
Click to expand...

There are things about MITO being fingered that don't add up and look a bit like a mafia trick. There are a few of us testing this by voting for SirTennis (named by MITO as mafia) so that we can test him and if it was a mafia trick we don't lose our PI.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom
Back