a school dilemna...

  • Please bear with us on the new site integration and fixing any known bugs over the coming days. If you can not log in please try resetting your password and check your spam box. If you have tried these steps and are still struggling email [email protected] with your username/registered email address
  • Log in now to remove adverts - no adverts at all to registered members!
S

St George

Member
Feb 17, 2011
702
14
18
Wiltshire
basically, theres a few of us at my school , and we were talking about saints, them not being saints supporters.

they asked me who i thought was our best player and who makes the most impact, and i said lallana imo, but they said lambert , one said he thought chamberlain was better than lallana.

i just wanted to ask those saints fans, who they think is our best player, and who makes the most impact??
 
Thats a tough one to answer really! but for me Lallana was this season, but with the coaching at Southampton being of such high standard you can never discount that he could be surpassed by any number of players, when standards are as high as Saints all the first team regulars were way better then most other player in our league, because of this no one at our club can sit back and relax so standards will be forever moving forward
 
Two very different questions, who is our best player and who makes the most impact.

The answer to the first is debatable. The answer to the second is Lallana, without any doubt.
 
lallana has the biggest impact
but fonte is just a rock
 
Wasn't there a poll asking this question recently? Didn't Lallana dominate it?
 
This goes back to the many discussions in the past. Who is the most influential. The man that scores the winning goal or the man that makes a blinding save to keep us in the match. In truth all are just as influential. That is why it is a team game, the man that scores the winning goal gets the plaudits but the man that crafted the goal gets barely a mention. The team Know that one with out the other is no good. We are blessed with what we call impact players that come on and change a game. Oxo has been one, Chappers has been one, Connolly another Goberne. Yes we do have influential players there is no doubt about that, last season we missed Lallana when he wasn't playing, We also missed Spider and Barney. So in truth St George......... you are really asking more than one question. They should be separated for different reasons..........Lallana at the moment is no doubt Saints best player, he is when he plays often the most influential, but not all the time. Lambert too is a good player at this level he too on his day can be the most influential, again not all the time. Same with any player at some stage most if not all will be the most influential on the day. So I guess for me the most influential player is the man with the most assists. Not necessarily our best player, but the person that actually provides the pass to score the goal. Now that person I don't know, at a guess I would say Lambert. There are better statisticians out there that no doubt can correct that statement if it is wrong. Just as my thoughts on the matter will probably just increase the debate still further............
 
Cheers fellas , that last post was true about a team game, I said Lallana but some said lambert because he scores the goals, but as long as there's someone doing the business, whether it's Lallana, rickie, (or pulis ;) ) I don't care :) COYR!
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top Bottom
Back