I voted 2008. You can only ever be one first time (unless you have Alzheimer's). That said there is a much more substantial feel to what is happening this time around and we are playing better football this season.
I think lessons learnt from 2008 have stood us in good stead for this time around and we are better prepared and have a better team and management. This season without a doubt I would say is going to be more successful and hopefully lay foundations for a prolonged stay in the premiership. Having said that 2008 was great because it was the first time ever in the top flight and the unbelievable success up to Christmas. I'm afraid I am going to be one of the annoying ones and say both.