- May 22, 2011
- 73,296
- 25,357
- 113
One is a whore, one is a serial killer and possibly a sherrif and deputy so it's not going to end well.
Weve got Sherlock amongst us everyone

Or is it miss marple?
One is a whore, one is a serial killer and possibly a sherrif and deputy so it's not going to end well.

I could write a brief summary if you want? Shouldn't be much longer than Neville's game description.How come? Any particular reason?
(Yes I havent read all 24 pages yet, only just finished the War and Peace size rules post)

Weve got Sherlock amongst us everyone
Or is it miss marple?
I'd say more like Zed at the moment to be honest.Weve got Sherlock amongst us everyone
Or is it miss marple?
I'd say more like Zed at the moment to be honest.
Deleted media
Rules Update
Just been pointed out to me by a very observant and honest player that there is a loophole in the rules.
I said you cannot reveal your role or you die of scarlet fever. I didn't say you couldn't claim every other role bar your own - or deny having every other role bar your own.
Obviously there will be an element of claiming false roles - but you can't do it to an extent to bend the rules or you will get scarlet fever for that too.
How many mafia games have you played before Captainchaos?
I've only played with a few NUFC fans before so most of you are total unknowns.
You seem like a gem thoughquiet, reserved and a real thinker.
I change to Sir Tennisball 
Don't tempt me
Going to try post less as I'm busy at work, but I end up getting sucked into the game and I write my epic posts! Will definitely be quiet in the evenings as I'm busy doing DIY every evening with the wife, not going to be able to sneak off and log in too often.
Rules Update
Just been pointed out to me by a very observant and honest player that there is a loophole in the rules.
I said you cannot reveal your role or you die of scarlet fever. I didn't say you couldn't claim every other role bar your own - or deny having every other role bar your own.
Obviously there will be an element of claiming false roles - but you can't do it to an extent to bend the rules or you will get scarlet fever for that too.

Rules Update
Just been pointed out to me by a very observant and honest player that there is a loophole in the rules.
I said you cannot reveal your role or you die of scarlet fever. I didn't say you couldn't claim every other role bar your own - or deny having every other role bar your own.
Obviously there will be an element of claiming false roles - but you can't do it to an extent to bend the rules or you will get scarlet fever for that too.

Painting, replacing plug points, replacing skirtings..."DIY" Yeah, okay mate.


I understood it to mean that you can't claim any of the roles except one of the 3 you said were claimable.
So essentially:
A) If you claim to be Sheriff, SK or Cat Burglar you're fine (whether it's true or not is immaterial).
B) If you claim to be any other role you die of scarlet fever (whether it's true or not is immaterial).
Simples![]()
So you can only deny having a role if its not your role you are accused of having?
So if I accuse someone of having role and I am right, they have to own up?![]()

Sorry, RHC already claimed that one (honorary role)Can I claim the role of the confused as **** player?![]()
)Can I claim the role of the confused as **** player?![]()

I think its more about people not denying every other role. Anyone claiming to have any other role than the ones you mentioned will prove to be lying when they aren't killed off - so if they claimed them all bar one it would give away their real role.
No![]()
