Jason McCarthy

  • Please bear with us on the new site integration and fixing any known bugs over the coming days. If you can not log in please try resetting your password and check your spam box. If you have tried these steps and are still struggling email [email protected] with your username/registered email address
  • Log in now to remove adverts - no adverts at all to registered members!
Ron

Ron

Well-Known Member
Forum Moderator
Jan 25, 2011
51,974
19,435
113
France
Hi, Wycombe fan here. Your 19 year old centre back Jason McCarthy has signed for us on a one month loan deal. Can you shed any light on how good he is please. Our centre back is out injured so it would be nice to get a good replacement.

Thanks
Ron
 
Happy to agree with Lamby if this lad carries on making the progress he is at his current rate I can certainly see he will make a Saints skipper. If we can hang on to him that is!!
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Ron
He is a good player, but has to be seen if he can play in the hustle and bustle of a lower league. Not getting at Wycombe, but I know we have been disappointed with youngsters lent from a higher league in the past. I think the difference may be that our lads are brought up with a work ethic, unlike some big time Charlies.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Ron
I've only ever heard positive things about Jason McCarthy, he seems to be highly rated, and already has minutes for the first team under his belt.

However, with no disrespect to Wycombe, the fact that our other 2 young centre backs Jordan Turnbull and Jack Stephens are on loan in League 1 and the Championship, while we're sending McCarthy all the way down 3 divisions into League 2, doesn't fill me with confidence about his development.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Ron
In the handful of games I have seen of our under 21s in the last year he has always been a stand out performer.

Decent positional play and seems very composed.
As Fran rightly points out, although he is well built for his age, there is always a question mark over being able to handle the gulf in physicality between youth football and senior.

Hopefully he will do you a great service and help you pip Portsmouth to the automatic promotion places
 
  • Like
Reactions: Ron
Saint Birdsnest said:
I've only ever heard positive things about Jason McCarthy, he seems to be highly rated, and already has minutes for the first team under his belt.

However, with no disrespect to Wycombe, the fact that our other 2 young centre backs Jordan Turnbull and Jack Stephens are on loan in League 1 and the Championship, while we're sending McCarthy all the way down 3 divisions into League 2, doesn't fill me with confidence about his development.
Click to expand...
McCarthy is better then Turnbull. A month actually playing will be better then being benched all the time like Stephens.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Ron
Saint Birdsnest said:
I've only ever heard positive things about Jason McCarthy, he seems to be highly rated, and already has minutes for the first team under his belt.

However, with no disrespect to Wycombe, the fact that our other 2 young centre backs Jordan Turnbull and Jack Stephens are on loan in League 1 and the Championship, while we're sending McCarthy all the way down 3 divisions into League 2, doesn't fill me with confidence about his development.
Click to expand...
I think the key thing is he is being sent to a good club with an excellent manager. Jordan Ibe (Liverpool) was developed at Wycombe. Williamson (from Southampton?) was captain of Wycombe. Matt Phillips (went to Blackpool) from Wycombe. All brilliant. Our manager is well respected for bringing on young players and those that have moved on have spoken very highly of him and the Wycombe set up. So hopefully it will be a good move for him. Not sure about just one month though. Hopefully he will want to, and be allowed to, stay longer.
 
Ron said:
I think the key thing is he is being sent to a good club with an excellent manager. Jordan Ibe (Liverpool) was developed at Wycombe. Williamson (from Southampton?) was captain of Wycombe. Matt Phillips (went to Blackpool) from Wycombe. All brilliant. Our manager is well respected for bringing on young players and those that have moved on have spoken very highly of him and the Wycombe set up. So hopefully it will be a good move for him. Not sure about just one month though. Hopefully he will want to, and be allowed to, stay longer.
Click to expand...

How long is your lad out injured for?

I guess if it doesn't work out for either party, then a short loan to begin with makes sense. They can always be extended.

I know Wycombe have a strong team for the divison, but do you think defence is the area you need to strengthen to give you the best chance of promotion?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Ron
saintlyhero said:
How long is your lad out injured for?

I guess if it doesn't work out for either party, then a short loan to begin with makes sense. They can always be extended.

I know Wycombe have a strong team for the divison, but do you think defence is the area you need to strengthen to give you the best chance of promotion?
Click to expand...
I can't speak for all Wycombe fans but I would say that, with our full defence squad available, we probably have the strongest defence in the League. Certainly last year whilst we had Mawson (from Brentford). We have a very good defender named Pierre who several clubs have their eye on. I think/hope that Jason McCarthy and him could be a formidable duo. I think our center back is out until the New Year. Our left side defender Jacobson is undoubtedly the best in the League at that position. As is our goalkeeper

Our problem is that we have a very small squad and are therefore vulnerable to injuries
 
  • Like
Reactions: saintlyhero
Saint Birdsnest said:
I've only ever heard positive things about Jason McCarthy, he seems to be highly rated, and already has minutes for the first team under his belt.

However, with no disrespect to Wycombe, the fact that our other 2 young centre backs Jordan Turnbull and Jack Stephens are on loan in League 1 and the Championship, while we're sending McCarthy all the way down 3 divisions into League 2, doesn't fill me with confidence about his development.
Click to expand...

Don't read too much into it. It's only a month so it's relatively harmless, and it's not like we can just choose where he can go. You don't just call up a Championship club and ask them if they will not only pay the wages of one of your youngsters, but also guarantee him a first team spot. Maybe League 2 is his only option right now. At least he might get the chance to get one over on Pompey. A rare thing for Saints players these days.

Hope he does well for you Ron, looks like a quality player.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Ron
Ron said:
I think the key thing is he is being sent to a good club with an excellent manager. Jordan Ibe (Liverpool) was developed at Wycombe. Williamson (from Southampton?) was captain of Wycombe. Matt Phillips (went to Blackpool) from Wycombe. All brilliant. Our manager is well respected for bringing on young players and those that have moved on have spoken very highly of him and the Wycombe set up. So hopefully it will be a good move for him. Not sure about just one month though. Hopefully he will want to, and be allowed to, stay longer.
Click to expand...

Good to know, impressive record. Is Pierre your only other fit senior centre back? If so, I guess McCarthy is more or less guaranteed a starting spot for the time being?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Ron
Seen on a couple of other threads that the loan has been extended to January.

I guess we can flip this thread and ask Ron how Jason has been playing? Results have been mixed since his arrival, but he seems to have kept his place
 
Did you see McCarthy's winner on TV tonight? Will be on later 9pm Channel 5

You must log in or register to see images
 
  • Like
Reactions: lamby
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top Bottom
Back