Off Topic Mafia XII - Game Thread

  • Please bear with us on the new site integration and fixing any known bugs over the coming days. If you can not log in please try resetting your password and check your spam box. If you have tried these steps and are still struggling email [email protected] with your username/registered email address
  • Log in now to remove adverts - no adverts at all to registered members!
astroturfnaut said:
Read the stuff between your last 2 posts <doh>
Click to expand...

So... RHC saw Valley with a gun.
If that is the case either RHC is lying or Valley has a gun toting role.
Tobes was mafia with a gun I thought so would that confirm Valley as being a good guy with a gun then? Town Cop?
Of have there ever been two mafia hitmen in a game?
Just trying to get my head around the variables here.
Also.. on RHC didn't he say he was not going to post for a couple of days or something like that?
 
Albert's Chip Shop said:
So... RHC saw Valley with a gun.
If that is the case either RHC is lying or Valley has a gun toting role.
Tobes was mafia with a gun I thought so would that confirm Valley as being a good guy with a gun then? Town Cop?
Of have there ever been two mafia hitmen in a game?
Just trying to get my head around the variables here.
Also.. on RHC didn't he say he was not going to post for a couple of days or something like that?
Click to expand...

If I had a gun I'd have killed you by now :)
 
  • Like
Reactions: Super G Ted'inho
Albert's Chip Shop said:
So... RHC saw Valley with a gun.
If that is the case either RHC is lying or Valley has a gun toting role.
Tobes was mafia with a gun I thought so would that confirm Valley as being a good guy with a gun then? Town Cop?
Of have there ever been two mafia hitmen in a game?
Just trying to get my head around the variables here.
Also.. on RHC didn't he say he was not going to post for a couple of days or something like that?
Click to expand...

I said previously that its possible that the Mafia can transfer the powers so killing Tobes didn't necessarily kill the Mafias killing powers. Maybe Valley was the one the Don chose last night? Maybe RHC is lying or maybe he got an inaccurate reading as Town Drunk.
 
Gerrez said:
I said previously that its possible that the Mafia can transfer the powers so killing Tobes didn't necessarily kill the Mafias killing powers. Maybe Valley was the one the Don chose last night? Maybe RHC is lying or maybe he got an inaccurate reading as Town Drunk.
Click to expand...

Just to add to this...

If RHC is the Town Drunk (and there is nothing to suggest otherwise bar RHC lying) then he is town aligned. Based on previous games, he probably has a 66% of success rate. Surely we need to look at Valley as a result?

PS...RHC never said Mafia either, just that Valley had a gun. He could be SK or vigilante.
 
ACS you bastard I'm not guilty! Lol

Interesting from RHC RE Valley. But what role would have a gun? Maybe that's supposed to just be a sign of mafia? RHC is the drunk so we can't take it as a guarantee.

I'll vote for Valley for now, though I'm not done with ACS, he has been suspicious since the start.
 
Gerrez said:
Just to add to this...

If RHC is the Town Drunk (and there is nothing to suggest otherwise bar RHC lying) then he is town aligned. Based on previous games, he probably has a 66% of success rate. Surely we need to look at Valley as a result?

PS...RHC never said Mafia either, just that Valley had a gun. He could be SK or vigilante.
Click to expand...

I'm just a regular townie this time lads.
 
Also I've just seen in the tags a comment saying the vigilante got an extra bullet for killing Tobes. So someone is claiming to be a vigilante and claiming they have a set number of kills. This would mean there isn't a SK as we haven't had enough kills for a SK and Vigilante.

If the vigilante got a bullet for killing Tobes does that mean Tobes was the assassin? Does it mean the mafia lost a kill?

It's only a tag so could be nothing or could be a mafia trick <laugh>
 
ValleyGraduate12 said:
I'm just a regular townie this time lads.
Click to expand...

Maybe, maybe not, everyone claims to be a regular townie. Surely you can understand us needing to look at it though?

Are you saying you didn't have a gun? If so, are you saying RHC is lying or pissed?
 
Albert's Chip Shop said:
Having slept on it I have big reservations about AFC.
If he is playing us and fibbing then he is clearly Mafia I'd say (any other possibilities?)
If he genuinely has been 'told' to say stuff can we actually believe a thing he has and will say now? He's already admitted that Mafia had forced him to say what he said so if he is a Mafia 'puppet' isn't that as good as being Mafia as he won't ever be acting in the town's interest surely. He told us this time about it but other times he may have been told he couldn't.

Whichever way I look at it, we need to deal with AFC first.

Vote AFC
Click to expand...

It would be a slightly ridiculous power if mafia could just control me for the entire game lol

Surely the closest thing to that would be recruiting me? In which case I wouldn't want to draw attention to myself by making a claim to be forced to vote for someone! And if I had been recruited I would of voted earlier in the day to avoid suspicion, I also assume IBWT would of told us someone got recruited.

In previous games when someone has been forced to vote for someone it has worked just like how it's just happened with me. A one off forced vote and unable to let on it's a forced vote until after nightfall.

Your insistence that we kill me is pushing me further and further towards confirming your guilt.
 
afcftw said:
Also I've just seen in the tags a comment saying the vigilante got an extra bullet for killing Tobes. So someone is claiming to be a vigilante and claiming they have a set number of kills. This would mean there isn't a SK as we haven't had enough kills for a SK and Vigilante.

If the vigilante got a bullet for killing Tobes does that mean Tobes was the assassin? Does it mean the mafia lost a kill?

It's only a tag so could be nothing or could be a mafia trick <laugh>
Click to expand...

The SK is usually told they must kill every night although I don't think there is usually a consequence if they don't. Would be silly to not kill every night in that role though. What are the odds of the SK, vigilante and Assassin all going for the same target?
 
Gerrez said:
Maybe, maybe not, everyone claims to be a regular townie. Surely you can understand us needing to look at it though?

Are you saying you didn't have a gun? If so, are you saying RHC is lying or pissed?
Click to expand...

I haven't got any weapon. Therefore either RHC is lying or his results have been tampered with. I'd say whoever can investigates should either investigate myself or rhc tonight but don't say who.
 
Gerrez said:
The SK is usually told they must kill every night although I don't think there is usually a consequence if they don't. Would be silly to not kill every night in that role though. What are the odds of the SK, vigilante and Assassin all going for the same target?
Click to expand...

Milk was acting very suspicious so I could understand if a couple of people targeted him lol but the mafia, vigilante and SK all on the same night? I'd imagine it's unlikely.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Super G Ted'inho
ValleyGraduate12 said:
I haven't got any weapon. Therefore either RHC is lying or his results have been tampered with. I'd say whoever can investigates should either investigate myself or rhc tonight but don't say who.
Click to expand...

We also have the AFC issue. I doubt we can investigate everyone and even if we could, we still need to lynch someone.
 
  • Like
Reactions: afcftw
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top Bottom
Back