Off Topic Mafia XII - Game Thread

  • Please bear with us on the new site integration and fixing any known bugs over the coming days. If you can not log in please try resetting your password and check your spam box. If you have tried these steps and are still struggling email [email protected] with your username/registered email address
  • Log in now to remove adverts - no adverts at all to registered members!
Just looking for patterns, I've played against the town with some good players before.. They're never the obvious ones. Gerrez through the process of elimination, I'm leaning towards Milk purely because he's a little eager to pin his three, think we should keep an open mind and suspect every one. Then the third could be any one.. Could be way off, I'm sticking with Gerrez anyway for tonight and I probably won't be changing.
 
Magic said:
I'm not sure. Whenever I've been on a mafia team, we've often gone under the radar.. They don't get drawn in to things and are often behind the scenes, sometimes throwing in the odd disagreement just to cover the tracks. I buy that Gerrez could well be but I think Lucaas and Valley too may be a tad too obvious, well all three of them anyway.
Click to expand...


Valley, Lucaaas and Gerrez have all been very quiet except when challenged. Of course that is normal for Lucaaas. Less so for Gerrez, and I don't know Valley well enough to judge.

AFC, (who just popped in to say Lucaaas is his most likely town read and like Gerrez's commet that he was being persecuted) is also usually very busy but been quiet this game. He also hasn't placed a vote yet.

I could be wrong. Nothing concrete to go on yet and the worst danger in this game is getting stuck thinking you know the answer before you do... However that's my theory du jour.
 
@afcftw, do you mind explaining why you think Lucaaas is the most likely town player? It's rather odd to call someone innocent this early, especially on so little evidence.

If you have any observations that will help the town look elsewhere it may be important to share so we don't waste our time.
 
1 hour until nightfall

[xtable=363x@]
{tbody}
{tr}
{td=64x@}No.{/td}
{td=64x@}Lynchee{/td}
{td=235x@}Lynchers{/td}
{/tr}
{tr}
{td}2{/td}
{td}Gerrez{/td}
{td}Magic, Milk{/td}
{/tr}
{tr}
{td}1{/td}
{td}Astro{/td}
{td}RHC{/td}
{/tr}
{tr}
{td}1{/td}
{td}RHC{/td}
{td}Astro,{/td}
{/tr}
{tr}
{td}3{/td}
{td}ACS{/td}
{td}Style, Nev, Lucaas{/td}
{/tr}
{tr}
{td}2{/td}
{td}Magic{/td}
{td}Gerrez, Valley{/td}
{/tr}
{tr}
{td}2{/td}
{td}Nev{/td}
{td}ACS, Bobby{/td}
{/tr}
{/tbody}
[/xtable]


Yet to Vote - AFC
 
@Astro... Any reason for your vote on a known innocent? (RHC doesn't do discreet)
 
Gerrez said:
@Astro... Any reason for your vote on a known innocent? (RHC doesn't do discreet)
Click to expand...


I wouldn't call RHC a known innocent although I think given his personality and game play habbits it's likely.

I'm curious about the vote on rhc too and curious if it will stay there.
 
Gerrez said:
@Astro... Any reason for your vote on a known innocent? (RHC doesn't do discreet)
Click to expand...

How is he known innocent?

Yep, begging to join the game just to accuse someone, then say he's ****ing off for the next 2 days certainly isn't discreet
 
Out of curiosity what do people think about RHC and Bobby both claiming to have similar roles but with different descriptions of what the roles mean?

Is one lying? Are they both telling the truth with subtle differences in roles?

Is Bobby king of the drinks and each day gets to see a different drunk identified?
 
Milk Can said:
Out of curiosity what do people think about RHC and Bobby both claiming to have similar roles but with different descriptions of what the roles mean?

Is one lying? Are they both telling the truth with subtle differences in roles?

Is Bobby king of the drinks and each day gets to see a different drunk identified?
Click to expand...

No help, but I can't read that one yet.
 
Milk Can said:
I wouldn't call RHC a known innocent although I think given his personality and game play habbits it's likely.

I'm curious about the vote on rhc too and curious if it will stay there.
Click to expand...

Is certainly not 100% but we all know rhc can't do subtlety and he confirmed what I said too.
 
astroturfnaut said:
How is he known innocent?

Yep, begging to join the game just to accuse someone, then say he's ****ing off for the next 2 days certainly isn't discreet
Click to expand...

He made one of his cryptic comments, I pointed out I obvious it was and he admitted to having that role. As I just dais to Milk, it's not 100% but we all know rhc lol
 
  • Like
Reactions: In MILK we trust
Less Hope Than Neville said:
I have a larger suspicious list this time (including you) but nothing is definite in my head yet. I definitely think ACS is hiding something, but that doesn't have to be bad.
Click to expand...


That's fair enough. I should be a suspect. Everyone is suspicious to me for at least one reason. <ok> some just strike me more suspicious than others. <laugh>

What strikes me odd Is, why was Tobes assassinated day 1? From peoples reactions in last game and this one it sounds like Tobes frequently survives long and he didn't appear to be a huge threat to anyone. If he's likely to get lynched anyway why kill him?

He seemed a strange choice to assassinate. I doubt a mafia team would pick him to kill which is why I think SK.

Astro is famous for his spats with Tobes which is why he drew my suspicions and ACS seems random enough to go after him. (plus ACS's actions day 1 seemed counter-town with the vote hopping... )

I'm happy with a vote on ACS. Being in a tie.
 
Milk Can said:
Out of curiosity what do people think about RHC and Bobby both claiming to have similar roles but with different descriptions of what the roles mean?

Is one lying? Are they both telling the truth with subtle differences in roles?

Is Bobby king of the drinks and each day gets to see a different drunk identified?
Click to expand...

I commented on this earlier too. Can't see them both having that role considering the game numbers. Rhc is incapable of keeping a secret, Bobby is known for playing silly buggers.
 
Milk Can said:
That's fair enough. I should be a suspect. Everyone is suspicious to me for at least one reason. <ok> some just strike me more suspicious than others. <laugh>

What strikes me off Is, why was Tobes assassinated day 1? From peoples reactions in last game and this one it sounds like Tobes frequently survives long and he didn't appear to be a huge threat to anyone.

He seemed a strange choice to assassinate. I doubt a mafia team would pick him to kill which is why I think SK.

Astro is famous for his spats with Tobes which is why he drew my suspicions and ACS seems random enough to go after him. (plus ACS's actions day 1 seemed counter-town with the vote hopping... )

I'm happy with a vote on ACS. Being in a tie.
Click to expand...

Crap logic. I'm famous for almost pulling off the greatest win ever working with Tobes on [HASHTAG]#teamzombie[/HASHTAG]
 
  • Like
Reactions: Tobes The Grinch
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top Bottom
Back