Mafia XI - An Unknown Evil -GAMEOVER Town/Anarchist Victory!

  • Please bear with us on the new site integration and fixing any known bugs over the coming days. If you can not log in please try resetting your password and check your spam box. If you have tried these steps and are still struggling email [email protected] with your username/registered email address
  • Log in now to remove adverts - no adverts at all to registered members!
Status
Not open for further replies.
moreinjuredthanowen said:
I think it makes zero sense to bring a guy back in to another team.

I think that gives volumes of info on the nature of this game. There are a few teams.

I think ACS is just spinning a line. I don't see any reason to add a second unlynchable person. why?

simply this. if someone says "- One individual in the game is immune to lynching. If he is picked to be lynched, he will be lynched as normal but will not die." at the outset this means to me ONE not one plus another and not only unlynchable but btw indestrucable meaning no-one else can kill him too.

I think he's just thrown that out there as a defence.... is that an issue in itself? nope. I don't think so.

There is one issue. Milk cannot predict who will be FIRST to die..... remember the ORDER OF NIGHT. the lynch was told to us FIRST. therefore how could milk say ok the person we wildly pick to die in a lynch will them over to another team and bascially reveal all to that team.
Click to expand...

Why would he be a second unlynchable dude? How do you know we started the game with one? Something you know that others don't?

The first to die coming back to life and being unlynchable isn't out of the question. Milk mentioned something like this in the sign up thread
 
Gerrez said:
Why would he be a second unlynchable dude? How do you know we started the game with one? Something you know that others don't?
Click to expand...

Because it said in the rules <ok> (unless you mean a 2nd unlynchable guy, not just 'one')
 
afcftw said:
Ok so mito has jumped on the bandwagon.

Final reveal: I've tried to hint at it without actually saying it as it makes us obvious targets for the bad guys, but your going to kill me anyway. The wording of our PM suggested there is an important reason for our role existing, it sounds to me like later in the game there is a reason to have us around. Our role is clearly more than just being obvious cannon fodder ffs dudes.

If you kill me, the bad guys whack gerrez and that could be a major town **** up.

I don't expect to be saved now as clearly there are bad guys voting for me who won't move and the townies will be to indecisive to move away to another target. But your doing the bad guys work for the,.

<laugh> well it's been good fun in this role! hopefully some of you see some sense but I'm not holding my breathe haha
Click to expand...

Quoting this so it's on the latest page and people don't miss it. [HASHTAG]#shubie[/HASHTAG]
 
  • Like
Reactions: Super G Ted'inho
afcftw said:
Ok so mito has jumped on the bandwagon.

Final reveal: I've tried to hint at it without actually saying it as it makes us obvious targets for the bad guys, but your going to kill me anyway. The wording of our PM suggested there is an important reason for our role existing, it sounds to me like later in the game there is a reason to have us around. Our role is clearly more than just being obvious cannon fodder ffs dudes.

If you kill me, the bad guys whack gerrez and that could be a major town **** up.

I don't expect to be saved now as clearly there are bad guys voting for me who won't move and the townies will be to indecisive to move away to another target. But your doing the bad guys work for the,.

<laugh> well it's been good fun in this role! hopefully some of you see some sense but I'm not holding my breathe haha
Click to expand...

The problem is what would you say in this situation if you were evil? Exactly the same.

If we have got this wrong then the hole was dug last night by Gerrez making up **** about what was going on and then you going along with it. Admitting misleading and outright lying to the town is never a good starting point to hoping for a town read. If you are both telling the truth then the way to play it should have been with honesty and arguing logically why the role was important to town - not changing the role and rewards several times.
 
I knew this game would be a calamity but this is something else. Would be gobsmacked if AFC and Gerrez were evil roles. People being lead far to easily by evil parties pushing towards the easiest targets with the most question marks and so much time has been spent recovering the same ground on them that we've gotten nowhere on anyone else.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Super G Ted'inho and afcftw
Less Hope Than Neville said:
The problem is what would you say in this situation if you were evil? Exactly the same.

If we have got this wrong then the hole was dug last night by Gerrez making up **** about what was going on and then you going along with it. Admitting misleading and outright lying to the town is never a good starting point to hoping for a town read. If you are both telling the truth then the way to play it should have been with honesty and arguing logically why the role was important to town - not changing the role and rewards several times.
Click to expand...

And that's worth risking ****ing the town? [HASHTAG]#imnotsosure[/HASHTAG] [HASHTAG]#bodacious[/HASHTAG]
 
  • Like
Reactions: Super G Ted'inho
Lucaaas said:
Because it said in the rules <ok> (unless you mean a 2nd unlynchable guy, not just 'one')
Click to expand...

[HASHTAG]#readtherules[/HASHTAG]

- One individual in the game is immune to lynching. If he is picked to be lynched, he will be lynched as normal but will not die.

That doesn't say they start the game, it says someone within the game will be unlynchable.

Why couldn't it be the reincarnated acs?

[HASHTAG]#dude[/HASHTAG]
 
Gerrez said:
[HASHTAG]#readtherules[/HASHTAG]

- One individual in the game is immune to lynching. If he is picked to be lynched, he will be lynched as normal but will not die.

That doesn't say they start the game, it says someone within the game will be unlynchable.

Why couldn't it be the reincarnated acs?

[HASHTAG]#dude[/HASHTAG]
Click to expand...

True. I thought you were denying the existence of a person immune to lynching <ok>

I think it more likely is ACS, which is why I won't be voting for him until we get more info on his role/team/status.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Super G Ted'inho
I vote AFC this surfer talk isn't helping at all and is only getting in the way.

Only way to go is lynch them or completely ignore there posts and focus on someone else.
 
Less Hope Than Neville said:
The problem is what would you say in this situation if you were evil? Exactly the same.

If we have got this wrong then the hole was dug last night by Gerrez making up **** about what was going on and then you going along with it. Admitting misleading and outright lying to the town is never a good starting point to hoping for a town read. If you are both telling the truth then the way to play it should have been with honesty and arguing logically why the role was important to town - not changing the role and rewards several times.
Click to expand...

Stop concentrating on what we're actually saying and read the way we are playing if it helps. Why would am evil have to stand out ffs?

We're killing a townie. Whether the town are leading it or the evil are taking a easy option is unknown.

Since we are known innocents yo the medium and killing afc will confirm to everyone else that I'm a innocent, I'll be assassinated tonight too destroying our known innocents team <doh>

Bodacious!
 
  • Like
Reactions: afcftw
Lucaaas said:
Why do Swansea fans not like him any more? Did he say/do something?
Click to expand...

Allegedly walked out early of one of Monks first sessions without permission, resulted in a scrap with Rangel whose part of our old guard as it were.

A lot of rumours that he's crocked and his ankle is shot to bits and can no longer play at the highest level. There's a few threads on our board from people who seem 'in the know'.
 
Well everything is revealed now, you can either listen and change votes or stick as you are and it's on your own heads when you **** up <ok>

It was a really difficult role to play and not end up the main suspect, figured most would realise it was far to obvious for us to be bad guys but meh, what can you do!

Shubie.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ValleyGraduate12 and Super G Ted'inho
Mikey said:
I knew this game would be a calamity but this is something else. Would be gobsmacked if AFC and Gerrez were evil roles. People being lead far to easily by evil parties pushing towards the easiest targets with the most question marks and so much time has been spent recovering the same ground on them that we've gotten nowhere on anyone else.
Click to expand...

<applause>

Dude
 
  • Like
Reactions: afcftw
Style said:
I vote AFC this surfer talk isn't helping at all and is only getting in the way.

Only way to go is lynch them or completely ignore there posts and focus on someone else.
Click to expand...

So instead of ignoring them and potentially keeping a useful town role alive, we just kill us off instead? <laugh>

Half wits, the lot of you :p

Dude.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Super G Ted'inho
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom
Back